32 Best Bakeries near New Holland

“Amazing pies and breads😚“

“Great people, found them while delivering over the years as a truck driver.If you have a farmers market in your area with Amish selling cheesecake, cakes, and torts most of it is Pellmans, if you can't make it out to the New Holland area“

“Alway a good place for a quick lunch, often there are samples for you to try.“

“I have ordered the pumpkin rolls for 3 yrs now from Amazon and they are so delicious,l will continue to order them for the holidays“

“Michael's Homemade Breads are the absolute best breads in the area! Their cinnamon raisin Bread is so delicious, it keeps me driving an hour away just to get it! Love it!“

“This was something like my 3rd visit. It is an absolute must when coming to Amish Country. Make it a jumping off place for your exploring. The baked goods are amazing, the service is friendly, efficient and well thought out and the ambiance lets you begin to feel that you have really stepped away from your busy, modern life. Great for families, tourists or those who just want a to slow down.“

“As always amazing the woopie pies where a hit at our friends party .. Thank you again“

“The owner of the shop was wonderful and extremely friendly. We stopped in and purchased one of each cupcake flavor. They were the best cupcakes I’ve ever had. Highly recommend this shop !“

“Beautiful White Rhapsody Birthday cake! The colors and the glitter were so pretty! The raspberry mousse and raspberry marmalade are like clouds of heaven. First cake from here and would definitely order from them again. Prices are reasonable as well. Thank you!“

“I liked the store very much!“

“I've had cheesecakes, special order cupcakes and special order cakes and everytime they were delicious and decorated so beautifully. My recent turtle cake was amazing! Always above and beyond my expectations! Thank you Pastry Paradise“

“I took a cookie decorating class and it was so fun! Laura gives step by step directions while giving us the freedom to be creative. I am looking forward to taking another class!“

“Inclusive and delicious! My favorite combo!“

“The journey to this bake shop is a story.

We drive into an Amish farm and saw no cars parked, nor a sign telling us where the bakery is. We drive deeper into the barn, almost knocking over the family dog. There were some dogs in cages barking at us, not sure if it was to welcome us, or to warn us.

We saw a guy who seem to work there, or owns the place. He told us that we went too far in, and said “turn around, it’s the red shed”.

We turned the car around, again, looking around to see which of those could be the bakery. We saw a hand written board “open”.

We go in. Shelves were almost empty except for a few trays of whoopie pies and some fry pies in the refrigerator. No one was inside except a box saying “self service”. “Interesting” we thought. Never have we seen such an establishment that was based on trust.

OH yes, how were the pies you say? SO GOOD. Just gotta bake them real good for a little. The whoopie pies are also really moist and cream not coyingly sweet.“

“Just had the vanilla cake at a bridal shower. Woah, it was the best cake I’ve ever had. Please for the love of god, i hope you make your bakery more visible. Proper website, voicemail with store hours on a separate business line, professional email, google search results posted, and marketing material. Your bakery is too good to be lost by poor advertising and going unnoticed. Sooo good, but not easy to find. Creative consultant could do wonders. Best of luck!“

“Unique accent to the local "flavor". Neat, clean, well stocked with only locally made food for that unique experience. Staff is friendly and knowledgeable. Stop in, a must see that's worth it!“

“I love this place when I'm in Lancaster! It's one of my go-to spots. The shoo-fly pie is amazing, and the whoopie pies are great too. The people are so friendly, and I always feel welcome. They even give you a free sample of shoo-fly pie, which I can never resist. You should totally check it out.“

“After seeing a lot of advertisements on Facebook I decided to go ahead and place an order (good job marketing team).
I ordered a six pack of assorted cookies. The order shipped right away and was at my door within in couple of days. The cookies arrived carefully packaged and everything got to me in one piece. Right away I tried the S'more cookie and... O M G!! Everything exceeded my expectations. Fresh, delicious, and pretty much the perfect cookie. I will definitely be a returning customer.
**Editing**
I was about to place another order and noticed that some cookies are only available if you subscribe to their cookie club. The monthly cost is a bit steep, but I figured I'd try it for the minimum three months. Once reached check out and saw that it was going to cost almost two hundred dollars for the order, I immediately hit the brakes and decided that I couldn't justify paying that much money for cookies. Especially because I have no way to know if I would even like the flavors without trying them first. Can your average customer really afford this? I'm still giving you five stars because your cookies are incredible. But please consider allowing customers to order any of your flavors without needing to subscribe.“

“Wonderful experience! Clean, and fun rides“

“La Bella Cakery made the most beautiful cake for my daughter's bridal shower. The theme was "Almalfi Coast" (blue, white & lemon). I interviewed several cake places and chose La Bella Cakery because they were willing to deliver and set it up and Pamela, the owner, cared about each detail in making the cake of our dreams. And, the best part was that it tasted divine too. She put just the right amount of lemon in the buttercream frosting. So delicious. The price was so reasonable too. Many guests asked who made the cake and I gladly referred them to Pamela. Cudos and many thanks for making a special day even more wonderful!!!“

“Love! Our local store delivered pretzels for all staff! Thanks, Tanya (Ephrata store)“

“Sweet Ash cakes made such a perfect wedding cake for me ! Not only did it look beautiful it tasted amazing....my guests were fighting over my top tier ! I had a naked cake with blush pink flowers, my cake looked magical. She was extremely responsive, and made sure I was having an easy process. I was very happy and satisfied with the cake. I cannot wait to have another party!“

“She makes the most amazing tasting cupcakes, my whole family loved them and she makes so many different kinds. I would keep buying from her! Definitely recommend 100%. They are so soft, fresh, and the taste of the frosting is to die for.“

“amazing cakes and pastries beautiful work friendly service 5 ⭐️“

“Excellent cakes!! Tracy was very communicative and matched our cake to the reference picture perfectly for my son’s birthday. Will be going here for all of our special occasion cakes moving forward.“

“While I like most of Stoltzfus’s items, I’ve been disappointed in their chicken salad. It used to be a staple in our home but seems like they’ve changed the recipe. It’s now so runny with mayo (or whatever they use) that it plops right off our sandwiches. They’ve also seem to cut back on the celery which added a nice contrasting crunch. Please bring back the old recipe.“

“Linden Coffee makes my taste buds happy! Seriously though, we stopped by one day on a trip to PA. We are from MD. In ordered a hazelnut cold brew, oh boy was it yummy. We came up to PA again and I made it a point to stop before we headed home. Again, they did not disappoint! This coffee is GOOD! I dance inside when I drink it. ❤️“

“The baked goods are amazing, friendly staff with good customer service. Would definitely recommend!“

“Would definitely recommend! We went around 3pm and it was very quiet. The atmosphere is very nice. There prices are very reasonable. I got a salad and sandwich combo for $11 with a drink and chips. I thought the food was delicious. Service was great. Would go back!“

“Nicole has to be one of the nicest clerks I have ever met in a store, always willing to go the extra mile and when she found out, I drove all the way from Baltimore to come to the store. She gave me her number and said to call her when I am headed there and she will make me up a fresh batch of my favorite pralines. She really does go the extra mile and I look forward to coming back to see you all during the holidays. Your pralines are made exactly the way my grandmother used to make them and I can’t wait to share them with the rest of my family. Thank you Nicole for being. Delightful every single time I come into River Street Sweets! I’m sure you know who I am. I’ll be seeing you soon to stock up for Thanksgiving!“

“We stayed on a summer weeknight and had a great experience! The grounds are beautiful with tons of photo opportunities and peaceful walking trails. We stayed in the Carriage House—very clean rooms with their own parking, and just a short, easy walk to the main hotel. The complimentary breakfast buffet for guests was a highlight—especially the made-to-order omelettes, which were absolutely delicious! The shops on-site are super cute, and the pool and playgrounds kept the kids happily entertained. A relaxing, family-friendly getaway—we’d definitely stay again!“