11 Best Sandwich Shops near New Oxford

“We worked with New Oxford's Subway to provide meals for our school's volleyball team on 9 different occasions this spring. The staff has been welcoming and helpful at every pick up. We appreciated their efforts to individually pack the meals, have the order ready on time, provide fresh subs and accommodate our team's needs each time.“

“The food is amazing and the owners are the best. We genuinely love this place!“

“They really care about the customers. I used to come here frequently but didn’t go for almost a year.
Despite this, they still remembered my order and had it made quickly like they always do. Can’t recommend stopping here for a bite to eat more.“

“Hot, fresh-made food in a flash, kind & courteous staff, outdoor tables so I could dine outside w/my dog (who of course loves JM’s). We’ll be back….Thanks so much! :)“

“The 2 young men that were working tonight are great workers! They work well and efficiently together like a well oiled machine! I had a fairly large order, which they are able to put together quickly and accurately! I didn't get their names but I was served by number 34 according to my receipt. Great job guys!“

“I've ordered here a few times, but this most recent time I ordered the outlaw, with a few small changes to fit my preferences, and it was the first time I had it; it was one of the best subs I've ever had if not the best. The customer service was great: everyone was polite, patient, and gave great advice when I was indecisive, the sub was DELICIOUS!!!
5/5 stars on all accounts for my favorite Subway. I will absolutely eat from here again.
Shout out to Brett, Debbie, Jake, Garrett, Ariel, and Miranda for all the positive experiences at the Eisenhower Walmart Subway!!“

“Ordered the NoBready Bowls last Tuesday Sept 26 early afternoon and it was prepared really well! Both bowls were filled to the brim. I was pleasantly surprised so Kudos to whomever prepared our meals. During this time there was also a promotion for a free footlong and we got to avail it. Sub was made very well, all ingredients packed and prepped well! Again, thank you so much to whomever prepared our meal (we ordered the same NoBready Bowls last month but the quality was not as good as this week’s order).Unfortunately, the receipt got soaked with the sauce seeping from the sub so we were not able to retrieve the feedback link/code.Once again thank you to whomever prepped our meal! You did a wonderful job and you provided quality service! God bless you and your family with more!(Order was delivered to us via DoorDash - our Dasher was prompt and gave us immediate notice as soon as they dropped off our order)Satisfied customer! Just hoping the service we receive is consistent. Guess we’ll see by our next order! :)“

“Last night we met Ian, Logan, and Max. They are the most fun, happy, and positive subway employees that I have ever met. The atmosphere we experienced made me look at their name tags so that they could get credit for their great personalities and positive work ethic. One of them said they were even working a double shift! Anyway, the food was great, the employees were great. It’s rare to have an experience like this anymore. Thank you!“

“Don’t know what everyone is complaining about. Love it EVERY time we go“

“Great food! Good prices. Always clean and staff is friendly.“

“Love this Subway. It's nice and clean. The staff was very friendly and they take extra measures to make sure you have a nice meal. While I was in they had a van of special needs adults arrive for lunch. The staff were very kind and patient to each and every one of the customers actually to an impressive degree. The best part came when the group left and the staff said to one another that they loved it when the group came in. It was so nice and they probably had no idea I heard them. The food here is always nice and fresh. I like that they have cherry peppers and spinach as toppings. The bread is nice and actually fresh here, no hard dry ends like at some Subway's.“