50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Plum

“Noticed today this place popped up on Google and I hadn't seen them before. Saw they had a deep dish and took the plunge with a medium Sausage/Pep deep dish pizza.

The crust is perfect with a great taste; the sauce isn't too spicy or sweet and with plenty of garlic.

This is a tad pricier than other options, but well worth the couple dollars more.

Don't sleep on Calabrese' Pizzeria. They're new to the area and need some business. You won't be disappointed!“

“Definitely a family friendly welcoming group of people! The pizzas have a fresh homemade type crust with no skimping on the toppings just like I'd do it at home! We stopped by for the first time when we had just picked up our 2nd Xoloitzcuintli pup from the airport and the staff enjoyed meeting her which made us feel at home and part of the family! Lots of options to try here so we'll have to keep returning for sure!“

“Absolutely delicious. It smells like perfection and is so hard not to dig into in the car on the way home!! Every pizza we’ve ever gotten from here is to die for. Even the crust is so flavorful and made with love. We will always be repeat customers!!!“

“Fox’s in Plum is our go to for pizza take out. Our kids love it … and the dessert pizza too! Generous amount of toppings which is always appreciated compared to other places. We had it last night and will have it again in a few weeks I’m sure!“

“Tried Grandslam Pizza for the first time yesterday and it did not disappoint. The pizza has a lot of flavor and was delicious! The deep dish Chicago style is the best Chicago style pizza I have had for what you can get in Pennsylvania that is. Overall it was a great place to order from. The workers are very nice and the sit in area is very clean. The dining area is very open and a lot of room for multiple families to eat here. I highly recommend ordering here!“

“So happy to say I work here. Everyone is super nice and just great people to be around. The food is really good too. I would 100% recommend the buffalo chicken pizza (and of course you need our amazing homemade ranch to dip it in).“

“Love everyone and everything about Amilis . We order at least 5/6 a month.“

“Never disappoints! With lots of other pizza options on this road, this will always be our top pick! Nice family owned business, owner was very accommodating, and the pizza is always 11/10“

“Having heard so much about this place, I had to try it.

Reading the reviews, all of the favorite things about Della Sala's is true.

Pizza was delicious, crust was perfect, sauce and toppings were del8cious.

Staff was friendly.

It was like going back in time to the best memories.“

“We’re in the neighborhood every few years and come here semi-regularly. Just ordered the vegetarian plate and was really delighted by the different vegetables. Cooked thoughtfully, great flavor. The kebab are also quite good.“

“Best pizza and wings. Had a group of 14 friends there for eat-in and they all loved it.“

“Delicious food by a wonderful local family!“

“Amazing experience all the way around! Super food and super staff!! Great spot!!“

“Everything is amazing The fresh baked Italian bread is to die for The soups, pizza, hoagie, ravioli all outstanding“

“Pizza Palermo’s is a good place to eat and the girl that works on Wednesday nights. The phone girl has very good customer service skills and I would definitely eat there again“

“The pizza is delicious, the wings are great, never had anything that wasn't delicious, and my wife "Her Highness" LOVES the Wediges. Ok fine, she's not really a queen, she just threatens to throw me in the dungeon if I don't order from Meglio's. My only issue is I need them to add an item to their menu. There are nicotine patches to help those with a nicotine addiction. I need some Meglio's patches so I can slap one on my neck when Meglio's is closed. I'd hate to cause problems in my neighborhood, you know, local flooding due to me slobbering while craving Meglio's.“

“This is God's pizza! Pizza by which all others are judged. Pizza all pizzas aspire to yet never achieve. To eat this pizza is to ruin all other pizza on the planet. You will forever hang your head at the thought of another's pizza.“

“Food is amazing and they are always friendly, and their delivery is always fast and efficient.“

“We ordered several Charlie’s Super Square for a party. 24 slices for $23! Great deal.They came hot and fresh. Absolutely delicious! Everyone at the party raves about the pizza. We will definitely order again!“

“My wife and I drove an hour after seeing someone’s post on FB about Common Oven Pizza. We ordered the Red Sauce pizza with Pepperoni and House Sausage. We were completely blown away by this pizza. The sauce didn’t overwhelm the basil, homemade mozzarella cheese, or the toppings. It was a perfect blend of flavors. Then there was the crust. Perfection! The absolute best part for me. We will be back without hesitation. We highly recommend Common Oven.“

“Food is mediocre, but the bartender Missy keeps us coming back!!!! She is attentive, friendly, and funny. You never have to wait for a drink if Missy is behind the bar.“

“Great service, great food, the Britannia do a fantastic job“

“We ordered wings and pizza, and trust me they did not disappoint.The wings were a little bit hard but was still juicy and had crisp. My pepperoni pizza was also very good but kinda messy.One thing I liked the most was their waitress (Shout out to Kara) was really nice and served us very well.The atmosphere I couldn't judge very well.“

“The most important reason is that this is a local, family owned business. Throughout the year there are holiday baked goods offerings. This is more than our local pizza shop. We feel like neighbors and friends.“

“First time ordering and I WILL be back! Gluten free pizza is the closest I've had to tasting normal, and the knots were also fire! I also came almost 20 minutes late for my order and the food was still hot 😍 I'd rate it 10 stars if I could. Fantastic 🤗. My roommate has a texture issue with food and he is pleasantly suprised. Way to go, guys! You found another customer for LIFE!“

“Delicious food, a wide variety of options, a great local place!“

“Quintessential pizzeria... not only is the staff fast and friendly inefficient they also go above and beyond with a little extras that mean the world to customers such as myself.

Guys if you're reading this to the staff of Bellisario's I wish there was a way to get you guys even more business not like you're hurting though because honestly your pizza is a Hidden Gem in West Mifflin particularly in Duquesne Shopping Center....yinz keep up the excellent work!

Wheelchair accessibility: It's on ground level and easily accessed and I guarantee if you have the phone number ahead of time which is on Google someone will open the door for you.“

“From entering till leaving service was A+, atmosphere was great, waiters were excellent 👍🏼💯😁 very helpful as well, Food was awesome, by far the very best salad and pizza I have ever had in my life, I totally recommend this place💯💯💯💯💯“

“Oh my, fist time trying and fabulous pizza- we got a white and red pepperoni- awesome delicious and then a follow up phone call from Diane -to see if we enjoyed it as I was a first time customer. I will be back again and again. Wonderful staff and excellent food. 💞👍“

“Great fresh, homemade, tasty food. love the cold Mac salad! friendly and helpful service.“

“Latina Pizza needs no introduction. They are one of the places always mentioned when people talk about the best pizza places in southwestern Pennsylvania. They maintain a compact menu of pizzeria staples that are done extremely well. The pizza is a square, Sicilian style and is absolutely delicious.“

“Best in the city!! Great family… only downside is you can’t enjoy pizza anywhere else in PA after knowing this place exists.“

“Great Food, always consistent, Nice vibe. definately will return“

“One of thee best pizza shops in the area.(this is my opinion so don't get all bent out of shape if you don't agree). Great service, very clean establishment, and the food well if I'm writing this that means something cause I'll ghost you if it's bad lol. Keep it up sir, you gained another loyal customer. See you soon“

“We ordered yesterday, we have 3 teen boys so our order was large lol! Everything was amazing, hot and delvered fast! ❤️ Thanks!“

“The fact that they used sourdough for their crusts and garlic knots makes it gut healthy and is a justification I’ll forever utilize in our house as an excuse to eat here. It’s truly “NY style” pizza with flavor that’s incomparable. I can also appreciate how big the slices are. Truly the best pizza place! 👏🏼“

“Awesome food and great customer service“

“Our server Elaine was nothing short of excellent! She was so pleasant, was very quick and always made sure we had everything we needed. She made our trip very memorable (we are staying at a hotel close by for a business trip). My daughter (she is four) saw they had a claw machine for a bouncy ball but we didn’t have cash on us play, Elaine overhead my daughter’s disappointment and came over and gave her a dollar to play! My daughter was so excited to win a ball for herself and her sister. I can’t thank her enough for making my daughter so happy and you can see she genuinely care for her customers, you don’t see that often nowadays. We want to thank you again Elaine for such an amazing experience and a delicious dinner. Would totally recommend this location to anyone!“

“We just had this last evening it was brought by our kids. Taste was great, size was huge.. meat lovers pizza was the best!! New place for our pizzas from now on!“

“Excellent food and service at Fox Chapel location . My first time here busy Saturday crowd Gabby was a wonderful bar server actually excellent. I had Bruschetta salad which I highly recommend Over any other“

“Absolutely amazing food and atmosphere. We’ve walked by it many times but haven’t stopped in. Super excited for their big move closer to the theater. Also, special shoutout to their scrumptious homemade meatballs. Might be the best I’ve ever had! See you soon!“

“Nice staff good food and reasonable prices“

“We were in the area and wanted to have pizza night. I looked at local places and saw that Bishop's was a full star higher than the surrounding pizza chains.
We got 1 pizza and an order of garlic wings. The crust was incredible! We were concerned that the 8 inch pie would be small but it was filling and just right.
The wings were CRISPY and cooked to perfection (I can't stand soggy wings and they were not soggy). I'm so happy to have randomly found this pizza joint, and we will definitely be returning!“

“This pizza slaps“

“Their Philly Steak Hoagies are the best. They use REAL BEEF STEAK. Not that cheap "Steak Ums" or poor quality questionable meat.
Plus, their fries are fresh, not frozen, cut potatoes.
Their pizza is above "average." I'd give 4 1/2 ⭐.
But, I'm not really a pizza connoisseur. To me, a pizza is a glorified cheese sandwich.
I do like their crusts and options given for their crusts. Thin or "Sicilian style," a thick crust.
I prefer thin. I'm not a dough/bread/pasta lover.“

“White pizza is delicious!! [Original] White pizza is delicious!!“

“The thin and the thick square (sicilian) were excellent! I'm a total pizza snob and tried both and am so glad that I did! This was my 1st time trying as I don't live in this area and I'm totally impressed. Can't wait to order again! The owners were very nice and everything was ready on time and hot!“

“Great Food and Great Service!“

“great people and excellent food ! couldn't ask for nicer people and the ranch is the BEST. so is the Italian hoagies ! and the garlic knots , everything is delicious!“

“Great place with great food every time 🍕“