17 Best Ice Cream Shops near Quarryville

“The absolute best place locally to get ice cream. I highly recommend the Blue Goo. We go there weekly. Dog friendly, accessibility friendly. Please note there isn't a bathroom on the property. The outdoor furniture is always clean and the staff is incredibly friendly. We look forward to seeing them each summer season!“

“very cute hidden gem. the ice cream was very reasonably priced and delicious. it is well maintained and has lots of outdoor seating as well as playgrounds for children. will definitely be back!“

“very cute hidden gem. the ice cream was very reasonably priced and delicious. it is well maintained and has lots of outdoor seating as well as playgrounds for children. will definitely be back!“

“Whenever I get to Lancaster I hit Rolled Cold Creamery. And once again they created me an edible work of art. It was a cheese cake strawberry masterpiece.
Beautiful and delicious as usual.
These young ladies do incredible work.
Kind Regards,
Darl Layher“

“Incredible selection and super-friendly standholders. My parents used to buy strawberries there on our way down to Port Deposit back in the 60's, and the quality and prices are just as reasonable. I bought 6 large tomatoes there for $3--unbelievable compared with other market stands.“

“My family loves to get ice cream here! It is a little more pricey so we don't come very often. But when we have, it has been great! The only downfall is because it is such a small shop and the process takes a while, there's often a long wait. If you are willing to wait, the ice cream and the experience is great!“

“Its good. Great service specially the young man with glasses. Con is the girl who was working with him, maybe she is new but she does not know how to talk to customers. I think she might have brain freeze from ice cream or something but she can not look people in the nor hold a conversation. But hey ya still get 4 stars the custard is great.“

“Visited twice - had ice cream the first time. Very good. The second time Italian ice - hubby had watermelon and I had peach. Both were delicious- they actually tasted like fresh frozen fruit. Lovely sitting area with beautiful flowers. Wish they had one in our home town.“

“The pretzel was the best pretzel I’ve ever had. It was soft and buttery and salty. Definitely homemade. Contrary to the other review, I think a pretzel is supposed to taste like bread, salt and butter.
We also got the root beer. It’s homemade as well and I wouldn’t suggest it unless you like the taste of real homemade root beer - it’s a lot different than the bottled stuff.
The BBQ Pork Dinner was phenomenal. Great BBQ sandwich and the BBQ potatoes were the best. Definitely learning how to make potatoes like that.“

“This is an extension to that farm and it works. Better access location with same items and more. Lunch and dinner simple menu was good. Breakfast was minimal. Would have liked more items or a breakfast sandwich. Great for kids and excellent ice cream and neat varieties. Fried ice cream. Need I say more. Quick access for their dairy products.

Kid-friendliness: Neat play stuff and milk cow learning for kids.“

“We visited Katie’s kitchen for the first time today. The food was absolutely delicious! The service was prompt and friendly. When you visit, don’t forget to try the complimentary homemade strawberry jam! We will definitely be back!“

“This place needs more publicity, best cupcakes I've ever had. This is a great, local shop that makes extremely high quality cupcakes for an extremely reasonable price. Not too sweet and fresh as could be. This location being right beside the central market is just another plus. Couldn't recommend stopping in for a treat more!“

“Stopped by today on my way through town for the first time and ordered a waffle cone with Cherry Ice Cream, 2 scoops. I swear those were the biggest scoops I've ever seen in my life and the Ice Cream was DELICIOUS!“

“The three of us went for a late lunch and even though we had to wait about 20-25 minutes to get a seat, the staff for the most part were really friendly. One of the waitresses has been there for a long time and is always super friendly to my mom and I. Food came out fairly quickly and tasted wonderful“

“Excellent cakes!! Tracy was very communicative and matched our cake to the reference picture perfectly for my son’s birthday. Will be going here for all of our special occasion cakes moving forward.“

“Perfect“

“No restaurants are open after the show at Sight and Sound so we lowered our expectations and went with fast food . We were kind of hungry so that might affect my rating. The downside comments were, "fries could use more salt, garlic bacon burger was too garlic y and could have been hotter." But hey, they were open and fast and we got to eat! Thank you“