21 Best Pizza Restaurants in State College

“My coworkers and I stop here often for lunch. We have had all kinds of pizzas and many subs, all of which have been absolutely delicious. Friendly atmosphere!“

“Outstanding pizza. The best in town.“

“I would still recommend them. However, my sister and I ordered pizzas today. I LOVE truffle oil. I ordered a Kennett Square pizza and they forgot my truffle oil…..made my pizza less than appealing. It did not taste good without the truffle oil!!!! Hopefully if I return they will remember the BEST part of my pizza……truffle oil!!!!!“

“This is a great place for some VERY, and emphasis on very, good pizza. Also, a major benefit of this restaurant is that they have HALAL food here. S9 for those who want pepperoni pizza but can't because the pepperoni is not halal, then this is DEFINITELY the place to go. Hope y'all shout me out, reply to me, or pin me or smt.“

“went here a couple weeks ago! best pizza I ever had. I will be back. plus I told a few other ppl who didn't know.“

“Ville Billy's has amazing food. Highly suggest . Wings and pizza are the best in State College. Wings are crispy and flavorful and pizza is thin and crispy and sauce is amazing. Very friendly staff.“

“A friend introduced me to The Cove about a month ago and I am a fan! I've gotten delivery from them twice and have had such pleasant experiences. Then, I was having a birthday party for my son and the people at The Cove were nice enough to make the pizzas for us even though they weren't open by the time the party started. I can't say enough good things about this place. Love the food, but love the people who work there even more! Highly recommend!!“

“Had lunch there today as part of our office's quest to find the best pizza in State College. I was impressed with their new lunch menu that let's you pick from 3 crusts and any toppings by the slice at a reasonable price. The flakey crust was unconventional but very tasty. I went to the Hi-Way downtown in college but have largely forgotten it but was pleasantly surprised today and will go back for lunch much more often. Will they win our office vote for the best pizza? Not sure but I suspect they are in the running.“

“Derrick and the staff at Allen Street Pizza ? were amazing! The pizza was delicious, and I got a slice of pepperoni ($2.75) and cheese pizza ($2.25) for ONLY $5! These were big slices too, the size of the paper plate! I decided to take pictures ? ? ? ? so I could share with out-of-towners. I HIGHLY recommend this place. I'll be back.“

“Best college drinking experience I’ve had on state college. It’s not always that crowded, the live music is a hit, I am a personal fan of the iced coffee drink. The pizza is decent, def the best in the area, and it’s nice to sit outside when weather permits, if you don’t want to be inside the bar“

“I visited this pizza spot on an out of town business trip. I was introduced to Brothers pizza on my lunch break. I have to say I was highly impressed. Being a Philly native I wasn't sure what to expect, but I was pleasantly surprised! The pizza was so flavorful, on the thin side how I like, but the cheese combinations and crust were delicious and I usually don't eat crust! Please stop by it's so worth it! Reasonable prices as well, you won't be disappointed!“

“It’s hard to find an atmosphere where mom and dad can chill while the toddler is welcome- but we found our new spot! A kid friendly brewery with delicious beer and appetizers was a win for all. We can’t wait to go back!“

“My favorite food here is 'Sausage and spaghetti, with two spoons of red source, and pepper and onion'. The inflation is so bad in the past few years but the price is still very cheap. As a fast food chain, you cannot expect anything more than that.“

“cutest delivery girl ever,and the pizza's very good too“

“Usually happy with my meal at Marzoni’s but the new crab tacos are terrible. Very fishy and just awful. Definitely do not recommend.“

“I haven't been here in years, but we always swore that this Papa John's tasted better than any other we had been to. There's something about it that's different. We went here for years when visiting my grandma - it was our favorite place. There's a window on the side of the building that allows you to go outside and look in and watch them make the whole pizza every step of the way, which is pretty much the coolest thing ever as a kid, and honestly, even as an adult lol.
One time, when my brother was very young, he was playing with a toy truck at the window sill outside the restaurant as we were watching the pizza making process.
The manager/owner/maybe just an employee waved to us and smiled at us and engaged with us through the window. When we got home and ate our delicious pizza we realized my brother had left his truck on the window sill. The next day we went back to check if it was still there and the same pizza guy had it sitting on the counter waiting for us. The fact that he noticed it, went outside and retrieved it, and remembered us and had it waiting for us, was all so sweet, and above and beyond, and shows you what kind of a place this joint is.“

“I went to Penn State for 6-7 years (don't judge me) the previous decade. Margarita's was my go-to!

Embarrassingly, I really don't have much to say about their pizza, I've actually never tried it.

HOWEVER - Their baked Italian Sub is top-3 on this planet! Maybe #1 (I've tried a lot).

Perfectly toasted with right amount of dressing with premium meat/cheese. It's also ginormous so come hungry. I'd actually recommend not eating at all the day before you're planning to try one. I literally cannot order another menu item because I enjoy it so much and don't want to deviate from the script. They're not open on weekends, so I usually will take at least one Friday off a year during PSU football season to come up and get one - it's THAT important.

This may be burying the lede, but Juan and Margaret are the nicest folks. My I went in with my brother (who was also a regular) during his time at State, and Margaret remembered his exact order! After 10 years!

Anyway, Margarita's is a local treasure and you should try it out.“

“Was a little crowded, but that just means it's a great place to eat!!! Food was great and I had a cast on my arm, and when the employee noticed he became even more helpful.. very caring to customers and that was fantastic! Not sure of your name but Thanks kiddo!“

“Out standing !!! Food was amazing service was traffic! The place was packed and we got our food in a timely manner! This was our first time here but it will not be our last ! Can’t wait to come back !“

“Pricing is A++; $16.99 for a XL Pizza?! Sounds like a pretty good deal to me.
I can definitely see this as a good late night option as almost anything beats Dominios.
Pizza was pretty good, the cheese kind of peels off very easily when you bite into it. Otherwise, the sauce is very sweet (which I very much enjoyed)
The store itself was a little iffy. Overflowing trashcans, some of it was blocking the door. Kitchen looked cleaned and well kept, it was just the rest of the store that definitely need more attention. Staff was great, even though it was just one guy.

Not recommended for Wheelchair or Mobility Device Users: It is a very tight, compact space that would be hard to navigate without extra assistance.“

“We ordered the meat & cheese raviolis with the meat sauce and a burger — washed it all down with a blueberry cider and local beer. Not sure busy (because it was prior to football / school starting) but it had plenty of seating and TVs to come hang out with a crowd.“