50 Best Italian Restaurants near Warrendale

“We had a fantastic dinner. The service was perfect and the manager, Jason, is more than accommodating. Made you feel right at home. 🤩🔥🤩“

“Excellent customer service from start to finish. Very attentive waitresses knowledgeable on what they are serving. Excellent menu not overwhelming.“

“Great food and great service!“

“We had a memorial luncheon there and the food was fantastic! Our waitress was wonderful!!! ☆☆☆☆☆“

“Wow! Every bite was a culinary experience. Everything on the menu looked so good it was hard to choose. And our server, Jennifer, was fantastic! She is very likable, pleasant, accommodating, and service oriented. She never made us feel rushed or pressured despite being very busy. We are visiting from NY but we will go back here again.“

“I like it a lot, but my 86-year-old full blooded Italian mother loves it. thankfully I pick up extra slices for her to bring to her house on the weekend.“

“Staying at a hotel in town, utilized Uber eats since my truck and trailer are not restaurant friendly. Ordered lasagna. WOW. Best lasagna I’ve had in a long time. Good mix of sauce, meat, noodles, and cheese.“

“The best! Had the chicken Romano.. hands down the best Italian food I’ve had in the area. Great, friendly service too“

“my boyfriend and i tried pelegrino’s after we got sent a menu from them in the mail. we each got a pizza, and the cost was INCREDIBLY lower than the other pizza places we’ve ordered from. they deliver as well, which is nice. what i also appreciate about pelegrino’s is the option for online ordering, which allows me to pay & tip so i don’t have to fumble whenever the delivery comes. it takes some time, but it’s always worth the wait; we’ve never been disappointed!! this is our go to pizza spot!!“

“We checked in, then people that came in after us got seated, when we checked to see what was going on, we were not in the system, then the table we were seated at had the previous people check on the table side paying kiosk, not cleared so the waitress thought we were them so waited awhile to serve us, then she rarely checked on us after that , we had to ask other waitresses to help us“

“great food, great service, and great employees!! highly recommend!!“

“Great food , large outside patio area with fire pit.“

“Was very surprised, because the establishment is small. The food was excellent. I had arugula salad with vinaigrette and Chicken Parmesan. I wanted every last desert behind the glass counter. No bad choices! I chose cannoli, my wife had the tiramisu 😋“

“10/10 amazing food and service!“

“Please give Chris a raise! Been here for many years! Makes the best drinks brings everyone’s energy to a different level when he enters the building he makes your bar fun and uplifting! He’s is truly a special human being and I want someone to recognize his talents! He’s someone you don’t want to lose! Love Dimitri and Kya! You make are drinks special! Thank you Chris!!!“

“IWasn't overly l impressed. Ate lunch here today after my mom's sigleftnificant other (Joe) passed away. I have to say I was pretty hungry by the time we the cemetery, and I was almost excited to see Chicken Romano on the buffet. It wasn't terrible, but the chicken tasted like very low quality meat. I was not the only one tobacco that“

“So glad reopened back up under new ownership from other locations. Sooo delicious always“

“Been going there for fish sandwiches for over a year. Recently size of fish has gotten smaller and smaller. Today I thought I had actually gotten a small fish stick. Guess have to re-evaluate my satisfaction.“

“The Piada North Hills location has a great staff“

“I really enjoying going to Monte Cello's Wexford for lunch & dinner! Their staff is incredible and personal. My favorite menu items are the buffalo chicken rolls, walnut and apple salad, white pizza, bbq chicken pizza & they have these amazing fresh cookies which I really enjoy! I highly suggest you check them out next time you are craving pizza.“

“We stopped here with my son and his fiancé to plan food for their reception and eat. It’s their favorite restaurant. The food was yummy, our server was excellent, and we got our catering squared away! They chose Olive Garden since there is a great variety for vegetarians and carnivores. Her side is all vegetarians, while ours is primarily carnivores. The pasta stations worked great for this! Plus, the lasagna is an add on vegetarian option. Plenty of salad and breadsticks and the menu was set perfectly!
The day of the wedding the food arrived on time, was set-up for us, and was hot and delicious! They were outstanding!

Vegetarian options: My daughter-in-law and her entire family are vegetarians, while my son and our side are not. Olive Garden works great for both the vegetarians and the carnivores! Everyone loved the food, had great choices, and plenty to eat!“

“The food is great, all homemade. Big fish sandwich for lent. The pasta is delicious. You will not leave without food for another meal. The portions are so big.“

“Celebrating National Pizza Day“

“First-Time Visit – Great Service and Atmosphere!

This was my first time picking up a pizza to-go, and I had a really good experience. The lady at the counter was very nice and welcoming. She took the time to explain that on Tuesdays and Thursdays, their traditional medium pizzas are just $9.99—which is a great deal!

The place also has a bar and seating area if you want to dine in. The atmosphere feels authentic and cozy, definitely somewhere I'd consider eating in next time. Looking forward to trying more from their menu!“

“Della Terra is one of the best Italian restaurants in the area. Scratch made pasta and dough, Neapolitan style pizza, and creative dishes and cocktails. It’s a beautiful atmosphere and great place to eat.“

“Un spatiu primitor și elegant cu mâncare delicioasă! Am primit atenție și produse de calitate. Revin cu drag de fiecare data!“

“We thought for a special occasion we would come here, however... We aren't complaining, however... We more than likely will not be returning . On another note, our food was delicious and service was just ok. I'm not a fan of complaining, however, we felt that maybe our opinion would help in the future or we may bring to light what others may be thinking. No salad, & only 1 side dish with the main course.“

“Great food and service!! I will definitely go back“

“I stopped into SIMPLE SUBS today. I CHOSE A CHEESESTEAK SUB. IT WAS DELICIOUS. IF YOU HAVE NEVER STOPPED IN YOU SHOULD TRY IT OUT CUZ IT'S GREAT.“

“I picked up my incomplete order. I told the lady working that I was missing part of my order. She then began making the missing item. I told her that it was ok, I didn’t need it. She then gave me my pizza and I kindly asked her for a refund for the item o did not receive. She then raised her voice at me and told me Sicilian pizza takes 40 minutes and to remember that. She then showed me my order slip that showed when i ordered. Obviously the Sicilian pizza wasn’t the issue since it was done and ready. They forgot to make the other item and I got yelled at. Not a friendly atmosphere there.“

“We have eaten at Lucianos many times!!! Always great food at reasonable price! Great portions! Always have leftovers for lunch the next day! I hope that never changes! It does stink that they charge 3% fee for credit card usage but I understand they have to watch their bottom line just like any other small business. Love the food and the server was very good as well. Always a good experience!“

“Got to b one of the best pizzas iv had in a very long time! Def recommend if you in the area.“

“Rachel was our waitress. She was awesome. It was busy and she didn't skip a beat. Food was delicious. Here on vacation from Michigan. Thank you.“

“Amazing food and the friendliest service… We will definitely be back!!!“

“Great food and great service!“

“Couldn’t be happier and more pleased! This place has impeccable pricing they are extremely consistent with food quality and time frame of when things will be done. The owner and employees have went out of their way to be very nice to myself and family when we stop in. I live close by so it makes for an easy trip but even if i lived an hour away i would find myself coming back constantly! Cannot recommend this place enough awesome people awesome environment!“

“We had a memorial luncheon there and the food was fantastic! Our waitress was wonderful!!! ☆☆☆☆☆“

“Amazing food and the friendliest service… We will definitely be back!!!“

“We ordered dinner this evening. My husband had a whole meatball hoagie. He said it was really good and has enough left over for another meal. I had a crispy chicken salad bit had a good variety of veggies and plenty of chicken. I also had a few breadsticks on the side. Everything was delicious.“

“Just had a birthday lunch catered by Bellisarios and love, loved, loved the chicken marsala! I know family and friends rave about their pizza pies! Cannot wait to sample more!“

“THANK YOU! I always get pizza delivered, but accidentally hit pick-up last week. I called wondering where my pizza was, only to find out my mistake. I asked if I could switch to delivery and they said yes, it would probably be about 30 minutes…no problem. It was at my door in less than 10 minutes! Great customer service even though I was the one that made a mistake.“

“menu prices need to be updated. The last pizza I got was medium with 2 toppings, sausage, hot peppers and ithe bill for that was almost $25.00 l“

“Very fast and efficient with their food service! They will greet everyone that comes into the door and acknowledge them! They will use their manners to customers! The buffalo chicken was a personal one small 4 slice with loaded with flavor especially dipping into their homemade ranch! 😋😋 Always enjoy them so much and will return for further purchases thanks you guys!! Stay strong major 🫶🖤💛🫶🖤💚“

“My family and I order from Carlucci’s for pizza nights!!! Their breadsticks are my favorite. And all 3 of my kids love their pizza!!“

“We often order delivery from here and are always impressed with the quality of the food, the quantity, and the speed of delivery. Tonight it was chicken parmigiana with angel hair and a side salad with fried zucchini as an appetizer for me, while my dad did the build-your-own-pasta with gnocchi and carbanara (bacon, mushroom cream) sauce and caesar salad. They said it would be an hour and it was only 30 minutes. I don't know how the fried zucchini travels and still arrives crispy, but they do it, and it's awesome, large slices, very generous, like a whole zucchini, with crisp, though not too thick, breading. It does not include a dip, only lemon wedges, but I have ranch dressing here. The chicken parmigiana was two large breasts, breaded, moist, and smothered in sauce and cheese. The side salads are generous with a thick slice of cucumber, grape tomato, red onion, and lettuce (the caesar - not real authentic but good - with croutons, black olives, grape tomatoes, lettuce, and parm cheese). We are never disappointed and always have leftovers. The one time something was wrong with our order, they promptly came back with what was missing and gave us a credit. Try the focaccia pizzas for a week's worth of great food! Highly recommended!!!“

“Extremely good service, they're always nice. Being the only pizzahut location really accessible to my current location I can't say I've ever had bad service. Every time I go in its a pleasure to deal with the employees and honestly, despite being a "Pizza Hut Express" The service here is better than when there was actually a fully Pizzahut, the only thing that really bums me out about this place is that you can't place orders for pickup, but that's not too bad as as long as you're in the store and pay for it and are willing to wait the 10 minutes, if they're not busy at least for me, they'll go out of their way to cook an order if it's not in the heating rack already. 5/5 Stars, always gets my service, I just wish it was a full pizzahut over an express.“

“Had the custom deluxe when we were staying around the corner at the Super 8, and it was incredible!!! Absolutely would recommend!!!“

“This place is the best. I haven't had pierogies that tasted like my grandma's since she passed. So trust: This place is legit if you are looking for authentic pierogies. I purchase from her every holiday and the family loves it. The owner is a sweet woman, too. Not understanding the snobby reviews here - she certainly doesn't deserve the rudeness.“

“We have been enjoying this great establishment for over 30+ years, and its ownership has great passion for its creative dishes, and this historic Pittsburgh culinary family is still providing delicious and creative Italian cuisine to the Butler County community! Keep it going. We are still spending $$. Love it.“

“I've been ordering from AJ Bambino for almost 8 yrs now. My family & I are regular customers. Their food is amazing. They are very clean. The Philly steak hoagies & spinach pizza are a plus other than the regular pizza & hoagies that we've gotten. The only bummer is the prices went up but I guess they have to in our economy right now.“