25 Best Pizza Restaurants near Watsontown

“Excellent food, served in a family friendly environment, and budget friendly. Best Cosmos on the planet!“

“Everything was delicious. Atmosphere is clean and inviting. Service was great!“

“Thank you Pi Pizza for allowing us to host a birthday party for this fun group of children. The pizza was delicious ~as always ~and the service fast and friendly!“

“Came here on a stop-through. Lewisburg is adorable, and this place seems like a staple. The main street is very walkable and there is ample parking. The service was super friendly and the dining room was very clean. The food was so good! Light crispy pizza and a very filing serving of spaghetti and meatballs had us happy and on our way! We will definitely stop back.“

“Hands down the best pizza and subs. Cosmos are my favorite!“

“Mom and pop shop with amazing greasy pizza. Check out where they put the pepperoni. 😉“

“Yum👍🏻“

“Penne alla vodka was the best I’ve ever had, 10/10!!! Waitress was also outstandingly nice.“

“2 slices and a soda for $6 what a great lunch!

For me personally the pizza was too tomatoey, but it was still a solid slice.

Service was quick and friendly, can’t as for much more.

Atmosphere was seemingly right out of the early 2000s and gives an incredible nostalgic feeling.

Parking: Plenty of parking in the front and on side of building.“

“Amazing pizza and Stromboli!“

“My Genny Cream is a dream, it's been decades and it's all coming back to me now. Go Bison!“

“Best wings around!!! Actually know how to put the sauce on the wings and are ACTUALLY buffalo flavor!!!“

“Love many items and the service but the sauce for the pizza seems a bit salty lately, therefore not as enjoyable as it has been in the past. (last three pizzas bought) otherwise great place.“

“Delicious subs, will be back.“

“Absolutely delicious food!!!!“

“Small pizza shop in Milton. Seems to be a popular spot for pick-up orders, as we were the only ones sitting down to eat at 12:40pm, but several people came in to pick-up or place to go orders. Decently sized menu and fair pricing. Food came out quick, and the pizza was good.“

“I had a delivery today and everything was fantastic! Shout out to the woman that took my order. She was great 👍 and the delivery was really fast!“

“Excellent food !“

“They lost my on line order, so I had to wait while they made it. Later that night, they called me to find out when I was going to pick up my order, which they apparently found after I picked up the order I had to re-order because they didn't get it until after they got it. Yeah, I know. Hope they figure it out before I order another one.“

“Frank, Rosalia, and staff took great care of a large group of us at a moment's notice. They were lightning fast, served up tasty food, and thanked us for coming when they easily could have turned the party of 15+ away on a busy Friday night. We'll continue to support this hard-working, kind family again and again. Thanks, Muncy OIP!“

“I've been eating the food here since 1990 & I've always loved it, I hope this place never changes! Was in recently for pizza with my daughter & the pie was perfect, waitress was super friendly & accommodating & the pictures on the wall take me right back to eating slices here with friends at lunch in high school, this place is one of the last old school pizza places still doing it right!“

“Pizza has really improved over the years. Would say it is better than Williamsport and other locations now. Great job on the improvement. 4 stars because it isn’t always consistent.

Update 7/22:
They have not been accepting gift cards for nearly a month. Submitted claims to corporate, heard nothing. Submitted claim to FTC. This store is ran a bit odd/scammy but if using credit card/cash, you’re fine.“

“Huge fan of their cheesesteaks….homemade bread, yummy! The pizza is awesome….always delivered hot, the girls are super nice and polite. Definitely recommend.“

“They have remodeled and are back for dine in! I was getting carry out and the nice young woman was fantastic! She was doing it all! Take out, waitressing, and keeping it all clean. Such a hard worker and excellent service! ( Aleshia I think was her name) She made my day 😃. Pizza was good, too!“

“My husband and I were traveling towards New York for a weekend getaway and stumbled across this gem . Husband and wife owned , the wife was our waitress and bartender and the husband was the cook . They were very friendly and comfortable atmosphere. The food was AMAZING! They also make homemade bread .It was so good we returned on our way back home . We highly recommend this place .“