17 Best Italian Restaurants near Wellsville

“I placed an order for pizzas and loaded fries during a 2 hour special when they were likely incredibly busy. I had not had what I would determine as good pizza in this area of PA. I mentioned this to the owner because all restaurants here seem to be pizzerias but despite trying everyone’s favorite, none were as good as from restaurants in big cities. I added 2 cannolis at the last minute when checking out at the restaurant. The owner said that their cannolis were amazing. They were freshly piped and not already prepared sitting and getting soft, already a great sign. I should have ordered more! I’ve had cannolis made in Little Italy and homemade by generations of Italian family recipes, this was absolutely one of the best I’ve ever had. I cannot recommend these enough. The pizza was everything I had been missing. The sauce had a little something special to it, the dough was perfectly between thick and thin, and the cheese wasn’t the tasteless junk too many restaurants put on pizzas these days. Now I’m not saying everything on the menu is amazing because I haven’t tried it. You cannot go wrong with the pizza and cannolis though. Their banana peppers were different from anyone else’s I’ve ever tried. They had more spice/heat than most but it only made it better in my opinion. I’m not a huge fan of fries in general, but their loaded fries were abundantly topped and had great flavor. Even better than the food was the owner and staff’s warm attitude. Keep in mind this is a small town so if you want some fancy atmosphere and impeccably dressed waiters, you won’t enjoy it here. If you want to get some of the best take out you’ve ever had though, I definitely recommend the pizza and cannolis. I’ve been dreaming about them ever since.Parking: Parking was plentiful which is incredibly important when carrying a large take out order.“

“It didn't take long to get seated an put my order in. The waitress seemed rather new. She couldn't answer my question about the food and brought my soup and main entree at the same time. Luckily the food was really hot so it stayed warm. It was an okay experience.“

“My company hired Moonlight Cafe for our company christmas luncheon. We had about 20 people attend. The Chicken Afumicato was the favorite, and I hear it's a favorite in the restaurant too for those who dine in. The catering was on time, polite, helpful and everything came organized, hot, ready to serve. Would definitely recommend for your business events.“

“Honestly, the best pizza I had in a long time! And these cheese frie...sooo good. My favorite, gooey gold.The lady taking our order was awesome. You order upfront, and pay before you go. She was awesome, gave us suggestions on our food. Got us a box before I even had a chance to ask. On top of all that, they were busy, but she still had time for us.Parking: There's two spots out front, but a whole lot out back“

“We went through the Drive thru and ordered a pizza. Delicious ? the wait wasn't bad either!Parking: Close quarters, but at least it's not street parking or paid. Just be cautious backing out and watch for other people's doors.Kid-friendliness: Not a pizza + barWheelchair accessibility: Flat surfaces to enter and exit. I believe the door is wide enough for a wheelchair or walker.“

“We stumbled upon Nanno’s by chance and have to say we were very pleasantly surprised by how very very good our lunch was. We had fries a cheeseburger & Italian sub ~ absolutely delicious!In addition, the staff was friendly, and the atmosphere was very pleasant.We highly recommend it. We were just coming through town visiting the folks. However, anytime we come back through town it will be a stop.“

“A Family Business with the Best Pizza in the State! I live near but discovered this restaurant almost a year ago and never went back. If you want new york dough and really good sauce come to Vito’s! Super nice family environment with loyal customers enjoying good food. Come and bring friends. Anywhere else for Pizza will only disapoint! This is the place to eat!“

“I was hungry for pizza, but then I saw their menu. Wow! I ended up with the penne & meat sauce and added meat balls. Couldn’t believe how much food they give for the price! The whole meal was absolutely delicious, it came with salad and bread, and their house dressing was also amazing! Becca was my server, and she made sure I had a box to go (SO much food!) and a bag for my leftovers. For a counter service restaurant, the atmosphere was very nice. They have lots of desserts, milkshakes, alcoholic beverages, and the place was spotless. I’ll be bringing my friends and family next time!Parking: Wide open parking lot, plenty for everyoneWheelchair accessibility: Plenty of spaces near the door“

“This new pizza shop boasts a small town feel, or place you could go for a quick bite to eat. The inside is quaint and has little tables to sit and eat at. The pizza has a great taste to it but the only issue I have is that it's a little pricey (I mean, what else is new now days!).This is a great place to check out. Stop on in and get yourself some quality food if you can!“

“We are so glad we decided to call in a pizza order today, we have always wanted to try Rocco's and boy what we have been missing ! We ordered the Sicilian Special and it looked amazing being pulled out of the oven, it weighs a ton So ...... we just enjoyed a slice and let me say that it is AWESOME ! Crust had a crunch and the edges baked to perfection. The toppings were bountiful and full of flavor We Love It The ladies working were very friendly and welcoming, made me feel at home. We are looking forward to giving their Cheesesteaks a try, especially with homemade bread .... Thank You Always Support our Local Business“

“Ordered 4 pizzas and they were amazing! The wait wasn't too long and the customer service was wonderful! New to the area I wasn't expecting to find the perfect pizzeria so quick but I'm so happy with the food and service we received!“

“"Serendipity" refers to the occurrence of fortunate or unexpected events by chance, often leading to a pleasant or beneficial outcome. It's often used to describe the experience of finding something valuable or delightful without actively seeking it.“

“I work at the FedEx building down the road and have passed this place until today. I placed my order 30 mins before I got there and The pizza was delicious. they do allow you to park ur semi truck there just the truck but the parking lot is to small even for a day cab park at the gas station and walk over there.“

“Tried this place for the first time because we found their menu in the junk mail that shows up on our mailbox. Cool family owned business! We called in for carryout and got a Sicilian 2 topping pizza. The pizza was done when they said it would be and they gave us a discount because the sausage we ordered they were out of so they only charged us for 1 topping. The pizza was a little crispy on the crust, but was a great representation of a Sicilian and was delicious. Staff was friendly and helpful and we would definitely get food there again. The price was a little steep on the toppings at $4 per on a Sicilian, so I would recommend ordering one of their "signature" pizzas if it's close to what you want to save some money. Didn't dine in so I can't comment on the atmosphere.“

“Just had my first ever experience here! In the area due to work & saw they offered a Gluten Free pizza, it is the best GF Pizza I’ve ever had! Hands down! Keep doing what you’re doing and thanks for the AMAZING service and first experience :)“

“Food was excellent! Large portions for great prices. Pizza was delicious!! Had a great flavor. Everyone enjoyed. Thin and crispy!! Not greasy!!!! Wings were great!! Juicy and flavorful. Great amount of sauce. Will definitely get wings from here again. Fries are my favorite kind of fries. Thick breading! Crunchy!!! Yum. Good service and will be returning.“

“Wow so where I begin to thank the wonderful staff at Sals Pizza. I called them out of their delivery zone and they still rushed and brought me my food for my friend and I (who were starving. I got the Hamburger sub which was delicious! And a (still very hot, thanks to the driver!) delicious pizza. If there was a sixth star on a review they’d get it, going above and beyond for my friend and I!“