30 Best American Restaurants in Williamsport

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Our party of 10+ enjoyed The James bar vibe over their dining vibe, but the food we did have was very good. The environment is warm & welcoming whether it be morning or night. We had a blast, and honestly the bartenders both Friday & Saturday night made our experience top notch! They were conversational, knowledgeable of the area, friendly, easy going, funny, and overall the high-light of our stay. They handled our large party with ease and respect. We were definitely loud and roudy and they adapted to that 💯 and made our stay pleasant. Billy & Hunter are both class acts and next time we visit the area, we hope they're working because they will be the reason we stay in the Holiday Inn again. 😊 If you stay here, definitely consider a sit down at The James, and when you do, i hope you have a chance to meet these two wonderful bartenders! 🥰 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“my husband and I went to dinner at the Old Corner on Sat 7/13---EXCEPTIONAL all around - service, food, atmosphere. I got the chicken with a spicy bbq sauce - It was absolutely delicious and perfectly cooked. Highly recommend! The service was A+“

“Wings, homemade chips, cocktails, and service were all wonderful. we will be back!“

“Absolutely loved everything I had tonight. Their allergen menu online is great! The tofu wings were incredible. So crispy. Would definitely go back!“

“Wow! we just ate dinner at The Sticky Elbow and we were very happy with the portion size and prices. Sierra was our waitress, and she was awesome. We are so happy we were told to try it.“

“After looking at the online menu compared to others this place had the best to offer. Everything about my experience here was very good and I highly recommend it to everyone.“

“We, and another couple, had lunch there yesterday. It was a great experience. The service was top notch and the food was amazing. Great neighborhood vibe atmosphere, good service and wonderful food. Looking forward to our return visit soon.“

“Need to see planned dinners and specials, to be able to make reservations.“

“🥰🥰🥰I love the 50cents wings“

“The food is yummy 😋 also just a really nice atmosphere“

“Would definitely recommend stopping by here. We made a pitstop off the highway here and our food came promptly. I had a bowl of chilli and a 1/2 burger, both were excellent, my partner had the soup of the day (clam chowder) and prime rib sandwich which was also fabulous along with the chips that came with both meals. We had a side of fresh cut fries to share that were good too. The server, "Leslie" was very busy when we arrived but she still had good insight and recommendations, while being timely and attentive, even with it being Saturday at lunch time.“

“Great comfort food, great service, clean restaurant. What more can you ask for? We had the chicken salad and the greens were super fresh. My pancakes and sausage were perfectly done—pancakes were light and fluffy. We also ordered a roast beef and cheese on sourdough and kiddo loved it. If we are ever in the area again we will be back!“

“We had a wonderful anniversary dinner tonight at Barrel 135. My pan seared scallops melted in my mouth and my husband’s steak was cooked to perfection. The tailored cocktails were amazing and our server Kelly was delightful! Check them out if you’re in the area and looking for a unique and pleasant dining experience.“

“My new favorite restaurant! Beautiful facility, plenty of seating options! Delicious food, seasonal and locally sourced, fantastic libations and GREAT service!!“

“You don’t do bars or drinking? No problem. Their food is great and they have take out. Try the flatbread, you won’t be disappointed!!!“

“Great home-style cooking, service is excellent.“

“Stopped in this morning for breakfast and everything was delicious. Staff was very friendly as well. Will definitely eat here again.“

“Great location and place to have cold beverage on a hot day. Enjoy the Loyalsock Creek but eat somewhere else as the food quality is no longer very good for the inflated prices!“

“This was my first time coming here staff was greeting,and friendly. The food was very good I will definitely be back . Thanks for the wonderful night“

“Thank you to the 505 staff for helping us throw a surprise birthday party for my dad. Your back room is perfect for a gathering. The food was delicious, and drinks were never empty.“

“Great wait staff and great food 😃“

“Here on vacay from Canada….just had our second order of Cheese Steak subs, and O…M….G! They were absolutely delicious!!! Highly recommend you give this establishment a try…you won’t be disappointed!!! 😊“

“Domers is a wonderful neighborhood bar with fantastic food and friendly staff.. it’s obvious the owners put their heart and soul into their establishment, ensuring their customers are treated kindly, with prompt service, in a very clean environment … would highly recommend!!“

“They were very accommodating and very nice.“

“Love that I can drawl on the bar!“

“OMG we had so much fun. Great band and bartender was very good. However my husband got pickpocketed by a heavyset short haired white woman pretending to help him with the gaming machine. She got over 200$ so beware of other patrons. Too bad people like that have to ruin a good time. But I will go there again and just watch my wallet!“

“Awesome place. Staff is fantastic. Bar stock needs help though. Consistently out of regular whiskeys and beers like Yuengling or Miller lite, stuff like that should be a no brained. Food is consistently good and reasonably priced. Bar staff is always friendly and accommodating. Stop by if you are in the area.“

“Stopped by for breakfast on our way back home to Buffalo....Connie took care of us...took our drink/ food order, and everything came out fresh and hot ...we got the Dolly special and bacon and eggs.... delicious... generous portion sizes...if you rub through Williamsport, stop in....you won't be disappointed...“

“Great selection of beers (not the typical 90% IPAs) with a cozy freindly atmosphere. Great food with table service, no going out in the weather to pickup food from a truck. The Irish Stout on nitro hit the spot. Cheers!“

“Had the lunch buffet during the weekday for $8.99. Everything was warm and savory. The salad and toppings all tasted fresh. For such a small buffet they had a wide range of American food like chicken and waffles, goulash, fried chicken and corn nuggets. Only four stars because there really wasn’t any great tasting food, everything was just good.“