12 Best Sandwich Shops in Sumter

Jersey Mike's Subs Sandwich Shop • $
1222 Alice Dr, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Chipotle Chicken Cheese Steak
Jersey Mike's Famous Philly
Chipotle Cheese Steak
The Original Italian
Subs by the Bag
Chicken Caesar
Baja Chicken
Chicken Parm
Jersey Mike
Salad Bowls

“This location offers consistently fresh food, and the staff is always professional. While the overall experience is decent, a bit more attention to cleanliness—both inside and out—would enhance the overall appeal. Nonetheless, I'd still recommend it for a satisfying meal.“

4 Good45 Reviews
McAlister's Deli Sandwich Shop • $
1177 Broad St, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

French Dip Sandwich with Spud Max
Savannah Chopped Salad
Turkey Club Sandwich
Country Potato Soup
Kids Mac & Cheese
Southwest Chicken
Kids mca89 Salad
The Italian 12
The New Yorker
Potato Salad

“Favorites are the Veggie Spud with added roast beef and au jus. Also like the pick 2 option. Usually get the veggie sandwich and whatever the seasonal salad is. I appreciate the gluten-free sandwich bread option, nice and soft ? ? Always get their tea, usually half sweet half unsweetened.

Only complaint is the floor always seems to be sticky, I don't think it's sticky from food but rather whatever product they use to clean it with. But either way the sticky feeling and sound it makes are annoying.“

3.8 Good68 Reviews
Sub Station II Sandwich Shop • $
1272 Peach Orchard Rd, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

You Name the Sandwich We'll Build It
Roast Beef Turkey and Cheese
The Italian Regular
Chef Salad
Cookies
Sub

“I wanted a great sub and that's just what I got!! Super fresh & delicious. That bread makes that sandwich for me. It was crisp on the outside and soft inside. Annnnd the best part for me is the online order service. Thnks for great food!!??“

3.8 Good30 Reviews
Firehouse Subs Sumter Sandwich Shop • $
1297 Broad St, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Medium Firehouse Meatball Sub
Large Firehouse Meatball Sub
Small Firehouse Meatball Sub
Medium Hook and Ladder Sub
Small Hook and Ladder Sub
Large Hook and Ladder Sub
Small Turkey Breast Sub
Hook and Ladder Salad
Small Honey Ham Sub
Italian Sub Bussin

“Fresh sandwiches but too expensive for sub sandwiches. We bought 2 combos, which cost a little over $28.00. This is a sub sandwich shop. Now, please don't get me wrong. The sandwiches were prepared well (medium-sized subs) with no extra toppings. Bread (wheat) was soft and tasted great. Staff was friendly and professional. Establishment clean. But other than the sandwich preparation, the chips and drink were everyday items. I'm thinking twice about spending close to $30.00 on lunch.“

3.6 Good45 Reviews
Palmetto Subs Sandwich Shop • $
15 E Wesmark Blvd, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Palmetto Special- Ham Turkey Salami Bologna Cappicola Pepperoni & Cheese
Small Turkey Sub on Honey Wheat Bread
Ham Turkey Breast Bologna & Cheese
Ham Roast Beef & Cheese
Palmette Philly
Chef Salad
Pickles
Chips

“I was delivering cars to the enterprise next door, seen the sign so I figured I get a sub but walked in and changed my mind and got a chef salad. I swear it’s the best salad I’ve had in years. I’m a car hauler who lives in GA and i got the salad around 8 pm didn’t get home till midnight and the Salad was delicious still. I wish they had some out in Ga cause I want another one so bad!!!“

3.6 Good38 Reviews
6

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
1175 Loring Mill Rd, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Cookies
3.7 Good9 Reviews
Palmetto Subs Sandwich Shop •
1155-4 N Guignard Dr, Sumter
3 Average2 Reviews
8

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
1146 Broad St, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Auntie Anne's Footlong Pretzel
Sunchips Harvest Cheddar
The Hotshot Italiano
The Ultimate B M T
The Boss
Sandwich
Steak

“Came to the subway expecting sub-par customer service but nah, was 10 outta 10. my girl n i had a great experience. we were helped by Daylen. n if it wasn’t for him, prolly would’ve walked straight out after cus they were out of most things. but he came in clutch n made ts good. definitely coming back ?“

3.2 Average29 Reviews
9

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
1961 McCrays Mill Rd, Sumter

“Everything was fresh and the staff was friendly. It took a while for the 2nd employee to come out and help, but he could have been on break or something else. It was very difficult to hear them though with the loud music playing ( it was good music though!) And their masks. I was also bummed I couldn't try the new smores cookie...maybe next time.“

3 Average11 Reviews
10

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
9 E Liberty St, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Sweet Onion Chicken Teriyaki
Elite Chicken & Bacon Ranch
Oven Roasted Turkey & Ham
Rotisserie-Style Chicken
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Oven Roasted Turkey
Black Forest Ham
Grilled Chicken
Steak & Cheese
Italian B M T

“Subway has become a go-to spot for my wife and me. We usually share a foot-long sandwich, which perfectly satisfies our appetites. The variety of fresh ingredients and the ability to customize our sandwiches to our liking is a huge plus. The quality of the food and the friendly service make each visit enjoyable. Whether we’re in the mood for something hearty or light, we can always find a combination that hits the spot. Sharing a sandwich has also become a special, budget-friendly way for us to enjoy a quick meal together, making Subway one of our favorite casual dining options.“

3.1 Average25 Reviews
11

Subway

Subway Sandwich Shop • $
1681 US-15, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Black Forest Ham for Kids
Teriyaki Chicken Sub
Subway Sorry Sandwich
Spicy BMT Sub
Spicy Italian
Rotisserie
Cookies
Steak
Tuna

“They took out the nice seating and replaced it with cramped, cheap booths. It feels very confined and unwelcoming.. food was good, servers seemed overwhelmed as two people had to handle food preparation, guests, drive through and register. Subway can do better!“

3.1 Average28 Reviews
Sub Station II Sandwich Shop • $
15 N Harvin St #4933, Sumter

Customers` Favorites

Bologna Ham Cheese & Turkey Sub Small
Roast Beef Ham & Cheese Sub Large
Grilled Chicken Breast Salad
Reuben on Rye Sandwich Large
Italian Meatballs Sub Large
Italian Meatballs Sub Small
Turkey & Cheese Sub Small
Super Special Sub Small
Meatball and Cheese Sub
Ham and Cheese Classics

“Stopped in on 7/19/24 for lunch. The staff was so nice and the large #19 was one of the best subs I've had in years. My hats off to everyone today and I will be back even if I did drive 50 miles for it. It was worth it. Keep up the great work.“

3 Average48 Reviews

You May Also Like