5 Best Pizza Restaurants in Madison

“I was actually surprised by how much I end up liking this pizza. I usually don't like the thinner NY style pizza due to how oily or greasy most places make it per my previous experience at other places but I read the reviews and wanted to give this a try. The pizza came out well cooked and most importantly it was seasoned enough and even though it's thin, it wasn't drenched in oil at bottom of box so I'm very happy with it. Even after reheating leftover in air fryer it tasted good. I do wish they add more topping, as in the quantity, in the pizza, due to high expensive it is, but that's just my personal preference. I like more toppings to eat than the bread.

They did do the half order for 1 side wrong so they made it right and redid it so I'm happy with it overall. I'm glad they were able to remake it right. Great customer service and help when I called so I'll come back again to order in future. There's outdoor seating if you want to eat there but I think this place mostly does take out. This is a nice hidden gem place.“

“We ordered the mixed burrito, the double smash burger with everything, 8 piece wings (honey hot and lemon pepper) and a gyro plate.

mixed burrito- Giffin's review: I would have enjoyed it more because I didn't know that cilantro was in it. (but that was my fault for not asking) the rice was delicious and all the flavors worked really well together. So big I couldn't finish it all. 8/10

smash burger - Lewis' review: cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickle, onion. AMAZING and satisfying. Fries were hot and crispy. I would drive out of my way to get this again. Thank goodness I live near by. 18M/10

Chicken wings - My review: hot honey and lemon pepper. They were a bit on the small side, but MAN they are delicious!!! I got the dry lemon pepper seasoning, but Mr. Wiz was trying to convince me to get the sauce. I'm gonna do that next time. :0) I will surely order these again! 10/10

Gyro Pate - My review: warm, flavorful, and comforting. Rice was nice and fluffy, gyro was tender, salad was very fresh. 9/10

Mr. Wiz is a delightful person. It seems like he never meets a stranger. He took great care of us and we will be back again, not only to order more tasty food, but to see our new friend again, Mr. Wiz.“

“I order here pretty consistently and they have never gotten my order wrong despite always having several pizzas with different toppings each time.

When I walk in, I’ve never felt ignored or that the staff takes a while to get to the counter. It’s outstanding service every time. I truly think this is the best pizza in the area!“

“My boys love this place, we were there this Past sunday, but is been really bad with customer service .They definitely need to hire more people , there’s only one person at the front register , line was too long and it took them more than one hour to fill the salad bar , or fountain station , we had to bring it to their attention more than one time.“