5 Best Pizza Restaurants in Madison

“Absolutely delish! Took a special trip on our motorcycle on a Sunday afternoon to enjoy a couple of slices. People are right. Their red sauce is something special, and I’m glad we ordered a variety of slices so we could taste the dill pickle pizza with white sauce, the Sicilian with the most flavorful red sauce, and a hot honey pizza which I think is served with focaccia as the base. We will definitely go back, and even though we aren’t gluten free, we have friends that are and know they’ll appreciate the gluten free pizza options! Can’t wait to order a whole pie!

We ate outside on the covered patio but there was still plenty of room inside. They have lots of seating along the walls inside (bar stool style) but not a bunch of inside tables that would be good for groups. The super clean restrooms were a bonus.“

“I can't lie... I hate burgers. But that was one of the best burgers I've ever had in the city. This is definitely a hole in the wall spot (no seating; order at the window.) I also had the mixed plate and I was floored by the flavors and toppings. I also met Mr. Wiz himself and he smiled during our entire interaction. A very friendly gentleman. Looking forward to returning.“

“I order here pretty consistently and they have never gotten my order wrong despite always having several pizzas with different toppings each time.

When I walk in, I’ve never felt ignored or that the staff takes a while to get to the counter. It’s outstanding service every time. I truly think this is the best pizza in the area!“

“My boys love this place, we were there this Past sunday, but is been really bad with customer service .They definitely need to hire more people , there’s only one person at the front register , line was too long and it took them more than one hour to fill the salad bar , or fountain station , we had to bring it to their attention more than one time.“