50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Old Hickory

“every since I first bought a Hunt Brothers pizza I was sold to deliciousness. I worked for pizza hut at the time and the second time I bought a Hunt Brothers pizza I told the clerks at the store the pizza to me is better than Pizza Hut. then I seen the sign in the window and found out Hunt Brothers has breakfast pizza and it's been a little over four years now and Hunt Brothers pizza is all I buy. what I love is taste, quality, price and fact the toppings don't cost extra. keep up the good work and keep the customers happy. Thank you Hunt Brothers.“

“This Dominos has been my go-to pizza place for probably 7 months at this point. I regularly get the pan pizza - meatlovers edition and me and my youngest son love it. They really do have something for the whole family and we order from there nearly weekly. I have to say, they don't always get the pizza perfect but 9 times out of 10 I don't even have to tell them. It's as if they intuitively know and I get an email that says "That delivery is not what we expected, let us make it up to you" and they do, with enough points to get a free medium pizza on my next order. You really can't beat that kind of service and suffice it to say they have won my pizza business!“

“We got there within 40 minutes of closing (not busy thank goodness for us). We were served quickly. We had the Detroit pizza and it was fabulous. Food was great and the service was fabulous. We are only here for two days, otherwise I would definitely go again.“

“Run, don't walk. A+ in every way! Locally sourced, beautifully made, and genuinely fun. This is what a neighborhood pizza spot should be. Don't miss the Little Gem salad (who knew?) and the street corn pizza. OMG! SOOOOO delicious. Currently my favorite restaurant in Nashville!!!“

“I was actually surprised by how much I end up liking this pizza. I usually don't like the thinner NY style pizza due to how oily or greasy most places make it per my previous experience at other places but I read the reviews and wanted to give this a try. The pizza came out well cooked and most importantly it was seasoned enough and even though it's thin, it wasn't drenched in oil at bottom of box so I'm very happy with it. Even after reheating leftover in air fryer it tasted good. I do wish they add more topping, as in the quantity, in the pizza, due to high expensive it is, but that's just my personal preference. I like more toppings to eat than the bread.

They did do the half order for 1 side wrong so they made it right and redid it so I'm happy with it overall. I'm glad they were able to remake it right. Great customer service and help when I called so I'll come back again to order in future. There's outdoor seating if you want to eat there but I think this place mostly does take out. This is a nice hidden gem place.“

“Really, really good food and beer! Awesome clean spot!!“

“So, I just had to share; I found this adorable pizza place! They've got tons of options, and honestly, every single one is a taste sensation - so fresh! It's such a warm, welcoming spot, and the staff are all about making sure you’re taken care of. And the bacon cheeseburger pizza? Hello, new favorite! Seriously, so glad this place popped up on my radar.“

“Had the ribs and collards yesterday evening , both were outstanding. Highly enjoyed“

“Great pizza good environment very fun“

“We went today and Kayla was our server. She exemplifies what good Customer Service is. She was amazing in every way and we didn’t have to wait on a thing. We didn’t have to ask for refills. She was on top of service to the fullest with a smile on her face and delightful attitude. Food was amazing as always., melt in your mouth pizza. Garlic knots are perfection. Good large salad portions. This is the second time I’ve been but the first time I’ve taken my husband and he is absolutely in love with this place. The atmosphere is very romantic and private. It’s not loud. Good for families too. Hostess was nice on arrival. We will come back again and again and sending anyone I can tell, to this place. Thanks for another great meal, great service and experience.“

“Great pizza in Nashville. Perfect crust and great taste. Plenty of choices“

“Ho. Ly. Sh*t. What an amazing experience! The food was delicious, the vibe was immaculate, and the staff was TOP NOTCH!!! Shoutout Adrian for being the most attentive server we’ve seen in Nashville in a while! The night was made because of you and your team!!! Will certainly be back, again and again and again!“

“What an incredible hidden gem! We celebrated our 25th anniversary there tonight and I could easily go back tomorrow for another round! We had the whipped ricotta, Caesar salad, and Ophelia’s lasagna. Fantastic service, amazing ambiance. Make a reservation….you will not regret it! And the Hamlet book they bring your check in….so unique!“

“My dad and I visited from out of town. I had looked up celiac friendly restaurants (aka gluten free). Let me tell you this place did not disappoint. Truly the best gluten free pizza I have ever had! When you get extra of a topping they dont skimp on it like most. MK was our waitress and we loved her. She was so kind. She took my celiac seriously and made sure I was taken care of. The manager was friendly. Truly LOVED this. It will be my new spot when i move here!“

“Absolutely phenomenal!! A must try!“

“I have brought family and friends to sixty vines a few times and really enjoy their atmosphere, food, and service! Each time I have been has been 10/10. Parking down on 5th broad and going up to the top is so quick and easy as well. The food is fresh, wine is delicious, and the atmosphere is a fun boho vibe. I have had the pleasure of having Johnathan as our server the last few times and he is so personable , fun, kind, and one of the best on broadway!! One of my favorite spots In Nashville 🍷“

“Great food, friendly service, and the perfect late night dining spot.“

“The owner is the sweetest most genuine man you’ll meet! My car was broken into and not only did he help me get camera footage, crawl in a dumpster to get some items that were stolen and thrown away but gave me a free pizza and drink since my lunch box was stolen too! The pizza was amazing but the service and people that work there are even better. He’s a saint!“

“We had dinner here tonight. Good ambiance and excellent service. We enjoyed the fettuccini, pesto and rigatoni. ♥️“

“Best pizza in middle TN, hands down ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“This was my first visit, and I was definitely not disappointed! Started with a garden salad with Italian vinaigrette dressing. Had meat lasagna as a main course then a slice of coconut cake for dessert. The portions were very generous, and the quality was top notch. Our server was very nice and prompt; she never let our drink cups to go empty. I will definitely be back!“

“I went to Emmy Squared in Germantown with a couple of friends on the later side on Thursday night. They were unfortunately very clearly understaffed so it took some time for us to get a table despite there only being a couple of tables with patrons. They were very kind about it and we didn't mind the wait. Once we got our table, service was great and very helpful. Our waiter walked us through the menu and gave us recommendations on what to order. We ended up getting the Zia Fries and the Roni Supreme pizza. They both came out hot and in a good amount of time. It was plenty of food for the three of us to share! Parking can be a little bit tricky in Germantown so just be aware of that. If you can get lucky and are okay with walking a bit, it can be possible to get free street parking throughout the neighborhoods. Otherwise there are paid parking garages and lots around the area as well.“

“Yum!! Had a pizza and salad. So good“

“We happened upon this great bar our last day in Nashville and wish we would have found it sooner! Great place and Kyle was great! We will be back!!“

“Went twice while in Nashville and both times were a delight. Great staff and the pizza was phenomenal!“

“The best pork roll, egg and cheese on a hard roll. The bagels are great too.“

“We ordered the mixed burrito, the double smash burger with everything, 8 piece wings (honey hot and lemon pepper) and a gyro plate.

mixed burrito- Giffin's review: I would have enjoyed it more because I didn't know that cilantro was in it. (but that was my fault for not asking) the rice was delicious and all the flavors worked really well together. So big I couldn't finish it all. 8/10

smash burger - Lewis' review: cheese, lettuce, tomato, pickle, onion. AMAZING and satisfying. Fries were hot and crispy. I would drive out of my way to get this again. Thank goodness I live near by. 18M/10

Chicken wings - My review: hot honey and lemon pepper. They were a bit on the small side, but MAN they are delicious!!! I got the dry lemon pepper seasoning, but Mr. Wiz was trying to convince me to get the sauce. I'm gonna do that next time. :0) I will surely order these again! 10/10

Gyro Pate - My review: warm, flavorful, and comforting. Rice was nice and fluffy, gyro was tender, salad was very fresh. 9/10

Mr. Wiz is a delightful person. It seems like he never meets a stranger. He took great care of us and we will be back again, not only to order more tasty food, but to see our new friend again, Mr. Wiz.“

“Happy to witness people who like families. 🥰 Excellent place to stop & eat for parents with littles. Good food. Great Service. Amazing gated playground. 🛝“

“My favorite place. Great beers, ciders, and food. but a special shout out to all the wonderful staff - past and present - that make it a special place! ❤️🤘“

“I was deeply concerned being from NJ and ordering pizza at midnight in Nashville but the pizza was quite good and the bartender was cool“

“Lexi, our server was delightful and efficient.. the carnivore pizza and greek salad were delicious! And the fella who seated us was friendly and polite. Great experience!!“

“Great food, excellent service!“

“Amazing staff, vibe and menu! Thank you TG Hendy!“

“My wife and I loved this place. We were greeted warmly, the service was fast, and the staff were friendly to both us and our son. We tried the pizza, breadsticks, and wings, and everything tasted great and came out quickly. The chalkboards built into the booths were also a great touch and kept our son entertained throughout dinner. They are very supportive of military personnel and offer a military discount, which we appreciated. We would highly recommend Brixx Pizza and will definitely be returning often.“

“Please! Please! bring Jamesia back to the bar area for the Hendersonville location! She is the best server and we miss her.“

“❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️Mazza Painting“

“We ordered a pie last night for delivery to our hotel room. It was one of the best cheese pizzas I had in a while, and delivered so quickly (less than 20 minutes) no complaints at all and we will order again next time we are in town.“

“Goodfellas Pizzeria in Nashville’s Gulch is definitely worth a stop! We had a great experience from start to finish. The pizza is exactly what you want from a New York-style pizzeria — huge slices, a nice crispy edge, plenty of cheese, flavorful sauce, and generous toppings. The slices are seriously massive, so you definitely get your money’s worth in terms of portion size.

The atmosphere is another big part of what makes this place special. It has a really cool, laid-back vibe that fits perfectly with the Gulch and Nashville. Everything felt clean, comfortable, and energetic without being too overwhelming. The music and overall setup made it a fun place to hang out and enjoy the meal rather than just grab a quick slice and leave.

The staff was friendly and welcoming, and the whole experience was easy and enjoyable. I also really liked that Goodfellas has more than just pizza, including calzones, subs, salads, and other options. And the Wiseguy Lounge hidden in the back is a really cool bonus if you’re looking for more of a nightlife experience after eating.

Overall, Goodfellas is a great combination of big, delicious pizza, huge portions, a fun atmosphere, and friendly service. Whether you’re visiting Nashville or you’re local and looking for a good pizza spot, I’d definitely recommend giving this place a try. Five stars from me!“

“Really, really good food and beer! Awesome clean spot!!“

“Great experience. Great food and amazing staff.“

“I order here pretty consistently and they have never gotten my order wrong despite always having several pizzas with different toppings each time.

When I walk in, I’ve never felt ignored or that the staff takes a while to get to the counter. It’s outstanding service every time. I truly think this is the best pizza in the area!“

“I had the privilege of eating at Jonathan’s in MT. Juliet. The food was excellent and so was our server Molly. I gave the restaurant 5 stars and would also like to give Molly 5 stars . We will be returning customers. Thank you“

“We got there within 40 minutes of closing (not busy thank goodness for us). We were served quickly. We had the Detroit pizza and it was fabulous. Food was great and the service was fabulous. We are only here for two days, otherwise I would definitely go again.“

“Friday night after a few drinks late night at some local bars and not wanting to drive far from our hotel, we ordered from here and LOVEDDDD it. Pizza was hot, fresh ingredients & we ate every single slice. To top it off they graciously added a 2 liter of sprite to our order that we didn't even order & let us use their restroom. That following Sat we decided to try something different on the menu & we still were more than happy. The small calzone was HUGE and full of ingredients but not too much. The cheesesteak hoagie was a great portion too. 4 people ate just those 2 things and we all we FULL! And again we were offered a free soda. We now all have this placed saved for our return to Nashville“

“This is one of the few places where I can justify an expensive pizza. Don't get me wrong, the price tag is intimidating. But the food is just so incredible. They also have an amazing, rotating selection of beers on draft, and the waiters/waitresses are very knowledgable of what to recommend based on what you like.“

“Love the staff at this location! They are always busy, but make you feel welcome. Best NY style pizza in town! I love to pick up a par baked pie to take home for dinner when traveling through that area.“

“I went to Mangia last night for the first time, and it was beyond expectations! The environment and service were both 10/10, and the food was off the charts incredible. *of note: I have issues with gluten and 90% of the menu was already gluten free. The gf pasta and bread options were delicious, and I didn’t feel like the odd one out at any point (because I could eat the same dishes as everyone else with a slight modification)! The team really does make it feel like you’re at a family event. The dancing mid meal is super fun and makes finishing the rest of the meal easier lol! 12/10 ✨ and I am already thinking about when we can go back 🥰🤣“

“Totally by luck, while returning to our airbnb we had a flyer in our door. Ordered our food and it came within time frame they quoted and food was EXCELLENT. We had pizza, lasagna, chicken cacciatore and desserts. They were all fantastic.“

“Amazing authentic wood fired Pizza! Great customer service. Highly recommend as a go-to place in Nashville.“