50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Old Hickory

“I've had a good time there the times I've been. They have a great setup, beautiful bar but their girls night out event was a bust and I don't like how they remove the reviews/comments. How are you supposed to give a honest review without it getting deleted...... Not real helpful“

“every since I first bought a Hunt Brothers pizza I was sold to deliciousness. I worked for pizza hut at the time and the second time I bought a Hunt Brothers pizza I told the clerks at the store the pizza to me is better than Pizza Hut. then I seen the sign in the window and found out Hunt Brothers has breakfast pizza and it's been a little over four years now and Hunt Brothers pizza is all I buy. what I love is taste, quality, price and fact the toppings don't cost extra. keep up the good work and keep the customers happy. Thank you Hunt Brothers.“

“WOW, This is one of the best kept secrets around. I've been living here for years and didn't know what I was missing. I will be going back regularly now.😃“

“This Dominos has been my go-to pizza place for probably 7 months at this point. I regularly get the pan pizza - meatlovers edition and me and my youngest son love it. They really do have something for the whole family and we order from there nearly weekly. I have to say, they don't always get the pizza perfect but 9 times out of 10 I don't even have to tell them. It's as if they intuitively know and I get an email that says "That delivery is not what we expected, let us make it up to you" and they do, with enough points to get a free medium pizza on my next order. You really can't beat that kind of service and suffice it to say they have won my pizza business!“

“Very good pizza. We got the Meat Lover and y’all.. it was so good! It’s just goes to show you that you never judge a book by its cover. Seemed like it was just stuck in the wall by a parking garage but it was so good. Very nice service. Handicapped accessible.“

“Stopped here on a whim and we will definitely be back! The specials were bang for buck. Even a normal slice of Pepperoni is loaded and massive! The salad was great, the pizza crust was stellar; light crispy, crunchy. We even thought the macaroons were great and worth every penny. Great service, fast, friendly, affordable and delish! Yum! Who knew Nashville has pizza like this??? Food: 5/5 | Service: 5/5 | Atmosphere: 5/5“

“So, I just had to share; I found this adorable pizza place! They've got tons of options, and honestly, every single one is a taste sensation - so fresh! It's such a warm, welcoming spot, and the staff are all about making sure you’re taken care of. And the bacon cheeseburger pizza? Hello, new favorite! Seriously, so glad this place popped up on my radar.“

“Fantastic food and service !“

“Best pizza in middle TN, hands down ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“After playing soccer at nearby Moss-Wright Park, we wanted to enjoy a family meal of pizza and other goodies. We drove by Jolly Ollie’s before, but it was shut down due to repairs from a tornado. I’m happy to say that it’s now open with great food, friendly service, and lively music upstairs in the bar. Yelp said that Jolly Ollie’s was open until 11pm, but the dining room closes at 10pm. We got there about 9:30pm, but Sydney didn’t turn us away. She was friendly and welcoming, and she was very attentive all night. We ordered an appetizer of fried mozzarella and the Southwest egg rolls. The mozzarella was crispy on the outside and gooey on the inside. The egg rolls were just as delicious. For our main dishes, we ordered a large pepperoni and a large meat lovers (aka Shipwrecked). I eat a TON of pizza, and the pepperoni pizza was one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had. Hands down. The sandwiches, pasta, and other menu items looked good. My son wants to come back for the baked ziti, and my wife wants to try the wings. If you like to play pool, sing karaoke, or want a stiff drink, visit their upstairs bar. Wide open space and well-lit. I hopped upstairs and the people seemed friendly and having a good time. Sydney told us that their outdoor patio has a bar and they have live music on the weekends. Highly recommend checking out Jolly Ollie’s. And when you visit, be sure to request Sydney. She’ll brighten your day with her positive attitude and excellent service.“

“We got there within 40 minutes of closing (not busy thank goodness for us). We were served quickly. We had the Detroit pizza and it was fabulous. Food was great and the service was fabulous. We are only here for two days, otherwise I would definitely go again.“

“We went today and Kayla was our server. She exemplifies what good Customer Service is. She was amazing in every way and we didn’t have to wait on a thing. We didn’t have to ask for refills. She was on top of service to the fullest with a smile on her face and delightful attitude. Food was amazing as always., melt in your mouth pizza. Garlic knots are perfection. Good large salad portions. This is the second time I’ve been but the first time I’ve taken my husband and he is absolutely in love with this place. The atmosphere is very romantic and private. It’s not loud. Good for families too. Hostess was nice on arrival. We will come back again and again and sending anyone I can tell, to this place. Thanks for another great meal, great service and experience.“

“Feels a bit pricey but the pepperoni slices were good - pretty thin with a nice ratio of ingredients. The large pepperoni are nice - as far as my pizza eating has led me, Pinky Ring and Five Points are the best in/around Nashville. The two aren't comparable at all, totally different styles of pizza. You could eat both back to back and be happy without feeling like you've had too much pizza.“

“Really, really good food and beer! Awesome clean spot!!“

“Great place to eat, good selection of beer and reasonably priced.“

“Was excellent food. Our server Crystal was amazing!!! Will definitely be going back for more. Highly recommend this place“

“Great food, friendly service, and the perfect late night dining spot.“

“This was my first visit, and I was definitely not disappointed! Started with a garden salad with Italian vinaigrette dressing. Had meat lasagna as a main course then a slice of coconut cake for dessert. The portions were very generous, and the quality was top notch. Our server was very nice and prompt; she never let our drink cups to go empty. I will definitely be back!“

“Had the ribs and collards yesterday evening , both were outstanding. Highly enjoyed“

“We stopped to have some cocktails mid day and cool off. Sam treated us like we had been friends for years. She was extremely friendly and had great suggestions. If you want to try a great place with a good vibe you found it. But you MUST request Sam as your server!!“

“Very good pizza! The fried pickles were just okay but I loved the pizza.“

“Clean and friendly pizza made just right I will be back five stars“

“Visiting Nashville for a show we had a lot of options. We decided to go here for lunch and so glad we did. The Old Fashioned’s are very good. I had the best, most authentic Chicago Beef sandwich (dipped, of course) and the deep dish pizza with sausage was incredible. Never had a crust that good. Everything is made from scratch and it’s obvious. Great service too! Very impressed!“

“We are from out of town and this place was really cool. Great pizza! Fun atmosphere! Great service! Would definitely recommend to anyone in the area or if you are traveling!“

“One of the best pizzas we’ve ever had! My husband and I stopped through TWICE because it was so delicious! Also, I am trying to recreate that Rock’n’Rita blackberry margarita…it was to die for! (Please send me recipe 🙏🏻)“

“Man very delicious!! Great customer service!!“

“Waiter was awesome and food was great as true to form for Mellow Mushroom. However we went to the second floor before rooftop which was empty and found an employee in a booth sleeping who told us that floor was close. Just came off as rude and unprofessional.“

“Friday night after a few drinks late night at some local bars and not wanting to drive far from our hotel, we ordered from here and LOVEDDDD it. Pizza was hot, fresh ingredients & we ate every single slice. To top it off they graciously added a 2 liter of sprite to our order that we didn't even order & let us use their restroom. That following Sat we decided to try something different on the menu & we still were more than happy. The small calzone was HUGE and full of ingredients but not too much. The cheesesteak hoagie was a great portion too. 4 people ate just those 2 things and we all we FULL! And again we were offered a free soda. We now all have this placed saved for our return to Nashville“

“Went twice while in Nashville and both times were a delight. Great staff and the pizza was phenomenal!“

“Great service and great food. Josh was The Best Server.“

“Out of all the places to eat on the streets of Indian lake, it will almost always be Brixxs! At home feel with attentive service. They always meet my diet requirements without attitude or ridiculous up-charges. A great place to grab a good lunch or have a pizza & drinks before a night out. I highly recommend👍“

“We ordered a pie last night for delivery to our hotel room. It was one of the best cheese pizzas I had in a while, and delivered so quickly (less than 20 minutes) no complaints at all and we will order again next time we are in town.“

“Read about this restaurant on Eater Nashville, so had high expectations. It mostly lived up to it. The Focaccia crust pizza is fantastic, especially topped with burratta. However, the fennel salad was a little bland and grilled dates ok. The restaurant was cozy and excellent service.“

“Great experience. Great food and amazing staff.“

“The best pork roll, egg and cheese on a hard roll. The bagels are great too.“

“We just ate here for lunch. We were working on the building and they offered us a pizza. By far one of the best pizzas I have ever had!“

“Love the staff at this location! They are always busy, but make you feel welcome. Best NY style pizza in town! I love to pick up a par baked pie to take home for dinner when traveling through that area.“

“Delicious and quick. Lots of flavor.“

“We got there within 40 minutes of closing (not busy thank goodness for us). We were served quickly. We had the Detroit pizza and it was fabulous. Food was great and the service was fabulous. We are only here for two days, otherwise I would definitely go again.“

“Amazing staff, vibe and menu! Thank you TG Hendy!“

“There was a very large crowd of us the staff was friendly and very helpful.“

“My favorite place. Great beers, ciders, and food. but a special shout out to all the wonderful staff - past and present - that make it a special place! ❤️🤘“

“the delivery was super fast and the food was delicious!!“

“Bartenders and Atmosphere was absolutely amazing. Bacon Mac Cheese pizza was to die for, Pepperoni pizza was really good, fresh slices until 5 am. Beer selection was one of the biggest I have seen, probably 50-75 choices with alot of local breweries featured. Jay was my bartender for most the night, dude cut it up with me and made recommendations, made me free like a local. Had outdoor seating with shuffle board and heaters. Best of all gaming, anything from Pinball too Arcade cabinets (Vintage and New), even had a big screen with Mario Cart 64 setup. Ernie's Boondocks below had pool tables also.“

“Had a pasta and pizza and they were both amazing. We are from Australia and found it hard to find a good restaurant in the Marina bay sands area and this did not disappoint. 5 stars“

“I had the privilege of eating at Jonathan’s in MT. Juliet. The food was excellent and so was our server Molly. I gave the restaurant 5 stars and would also like to give Molly 5 stars . We will be returning customers. Thank you“

“We met the owner, Pedro, who is focused on making an authentic Naples style wood fired pizza using quality ingredients imported from Italy. He succeeded. Our son started this pizzeria in 2011, he received a lot of recognition in major national and local media. His pizza was incredible. After he sold it in 2014, the quality varied with the subsequent owners. We were thrilled to see Pedro bring back the high quality pizzas that were envisioned at the beginning. Definitely give it a try if you haven’t had it before and if you had it under one of the previous owners, give it another shot, you’ll be glad you did.“

“A friend took me there for lunch today. First visit for both of us. The food was fantastic and we ended up bringing half of our dishes home. Priced very well and authentic Italian! Service was great and very fast! Highly recommend you give it a try!!“

“Had a lovely dinner time on a Tuesday night. The hostess was friendly and we got seated pretty much right away. We ordered the Salmon bowl with chicken noodle soup and Bison burger with jalapenos.
The food was superb! Generous portions, great atmosphere. We were able to hold a conversation without being drowned out by music. There were plenty of tv screens from different angles to choose what game to watch. Overall great experience, will definitely be back to try the prime rib.“