29 Best Italian Restaurants in El Paso

“😍 MONTELEONE’S RISTORANTE….. A place where you visit for the experience, stay for the food, and leave as family. If you’ve never been, or haven’t visited in years, this is the sign to head on over. You’ll find the crew working hard on Thursday-Saturday evenings from 5:00 pm-9:00 pm. We often hear the term “support local” and this place is a true definition of what supporting local means. Everyone that works here has their main jobs during weekdays, but three nights a week, they dedicate themselves to meeting everyone they serve. In between orders, the hustle and bustle of the night, and the sound of the kitchen bell announcing completed orders, the staff take their time to explain dishes and provide you with great service. Supporting local is more than just visiting an establishment, it is getting to know the people that live and work in your community. This is exactly what this group of hard-working people do. We’ve been to many local places, where the servers recognize us, and will remember our general order. But no other place takes the time to really get to know your story and allowing you to get to know them. We’ve sat through countless meals sharing conversations and stories with the staff that make this place what it is. No matter what server you get, you’re in for a treat. Julie, the dedicated and loving coach, whose career expands through retirement, and different schools; Robert, who has already retired but has continued to work with the community in insurance sales; and Audrey serving younger generations at UTEP. Then we have Laura (the owner), who takes so much pride in her restaurant, and the food that comes out of her kitchen. The sauces and dough are made from scratch daily. You can follow the menu or get creative and start adding toppings to your dishes. Whether you’re craving pasta, pizza, Monteleone’s rolls, or Tortiglioni (a.k.a. Tort) with more toppings than you know what to do with, you can’t go wrong with anything. We can’t forget sweet Mrs. B, who makes delicious cakes, and keeps busy helping Laura and the crew in the kitchen. On Friday and Saturday nights, you’ll have a chance to hear Julie belting out a song whenever a pizza is ordered, and all three nights hearing the staff offer up Mrs. B’s cake for dessert. If you visit on a Friday night, you can request to sit in the bar area and listen to David Huerta sing the night away, taking requests no matter if English or Spanish. The music at a perfect volume, allowing for enjoyment and conversation. This is the reason why I couldn’t think of a better place to spend my 40th birthday. Thank you to Laura, Mrs. B, Julie, Robert, Audrey, Frances, David and the rest of the crew for an amazing evening. David even sang three different birthday songs! Pick the night and visit, introduce yourself, and feel the love that this place brings. You’ll feel like a regular, even though it’s your first time. It truly feels like you’re amongst friends and family. Don’t forget to follow their Facebook page for any schedule changes, specials, pictures of item menus, or secret phrases for appetizers!“

“I stopped by Buon Giorno Caffè in El Paso, and wow—what a great find! 🤩The sandwich was absolutely amazing, packed with flavor and super fresh. The potato salad was just as impressive, creamy and perfectly seasoned. But the real standout was the dressing… it was so good! Seriously, I could put that on everything.

Great food, cozy vibe, and definitely worth a visit. Highly recommend!“

“Excellent service and the food is delicious!“

“I had heard wonders of Bella Sera so I decided to celebrate my B Day there. I highly recommend this restaurant. Food was delicious penne al salmone is now my new favorite. Our waiter JASON gave us the best service ever!! Will definitely be coming back often. Expectations were surpassed!!⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“100 % recommended my first time going and this bar tenfmder Jake was so kind and helpful explaining everything with respect and professional the food was good and the drinks were extra good I will defenetly go again thank u Jake“

“Olive Garden is like a traditional place in US. My first time in this place was like 25 years ago, last time was when they opened it in Mexico that was like a joke in many ways. Now, I returned in El Paso to discover nothing was changed, well, probably the size of the dishes which is now a little bit smaller than what I remembered. Tasting was the same, environment was the same, stick breads were basically the same... service was amazing. What I did not know was that they sing Happy BDay during special celebrations which was a great surprise for my wife.“

“Today I had the pleasure of attending a retirement party at Olive Garden on Woodrow Bean in El Paso, TX. We had an enormous group, and despite how busy and overwhelming it could have been, one our waiter DJ did an excellent job.

I could tell he had a lot going on, but he remained polite, attentive, and professional while taking my order and making sure I was taken care of. That kind of dedication does not go unnoticed, especially during such a large event.

Thank you, DJ, for your hard work and for providing great service under pressure. I truly appreciate it and hope to visit again soon and be served by you again! 🫶🏽💕💙“

“I love eating here, today went for a birthday celebration the waitresses Laura and her partner were very nice and very attentive with everything drinks, food etc. The receptionist upfront should be a little more friendly. Overall 10/10 thank you so much, definitely keep going back!!“

“genuinley Robert was by far the best waiter we've ever had. Me and my beautiful darling wife will only be coming here for him because oh my god was his service truly out of this world. He picked up on our vibe so well and he matched our energy. He brought out our order with such a glowing energy and we both needed that after a having a rough week. Please give him a raise as he deserves!!

And seriously, we'll be back just for him.“

“Food was good, bottled soda with ice but the bottles were warm. The restaurant is small so limited seating is available. You can bring your own wine bottles they do not serve alcohol. A little pricey for what you get but worth a visit over all.“

“very fast, food is really good would recommend on family night’s pizzas are a great size and service was great“

“Such amazing food, huge menu, great service and family friendly and warm atmosphere!!“

“great portions flavor able good great service“

“Such a nice place!! Stopped in for dinner on Sunday. Great Italian food, and the wine list is great as well! Manuel is very friendly and helpful. Can't wait to go back!“

“As the lunch place finder for a nonprofit organization, i went to Pasta Avanti and spoke with the owner Mario and asked would he open for lunch for us.
He readily agreed! What a delightful time we had! Food was wonderful, service was good. But the best was Mario's 87 year old mom singing to us!
We were a group of 45.
Mario.....thank you! The ladies loved you, mama and your establishment!“

“I wanted a perfect dinner experience with my great friend and where else to go to the same place I’ve gone for over 20 years!!! The food absolutely amazing and my servers were phenomenal! They actually put my leftovers away for me. Kept checking on our table. Great experience!! To think I’ve been coming here for years and still got the same experience!“

“The best pizza and spaghetti I have had in a long time! The meat lover’s is outstanding and spaghetti with meatballs has a unique taste…highly recommended! 🍕 🍝“

“A great Italian restaurant that lets you bring in your own bottle of wine 🍷! I think the simple menu highlights classic Italian cuisine and makes ordering easy. I tasted the spaghetti and meatballs paired with a Chianti Classico red wine to complement the dish. The atmosphere adds a level of warmth to the dinning experience.“

“Such a darling place with amazing food. Loved the location, the employees are so kind and prompt. My caprese salad was great and my pizza was delicious. My only complaint is the food ending after we ate it all. Keeps you wanting more. Thank you for such a special dining experience.“

“Simply Amazing! Johnny Carinos is back!
This is my second time back from about a 2 year break from Carinos. I want to be completely honest here. Food and service used to be just ok but not good enough to leaving me craving for more frequent visits. I was blown away by how much the quality of food and service had improved since my previous visits. I ordered the Jalapeño Garlic Tilapia and the consistency of the sauce, presentation, temperature and texture was just perfect. Finger-lickin good! Fried Calamari a must! Then after about 2 weeks decided to go back and ordered another favorite, the Skilitini Combo with added Capers and Artichokes. The skillet was super hot! The way it should be when the saute guy yells (Fire). It came out sizzling and filled the restaurant with an awesome aroma. Once again I was floored by explosion of flavors and different textures you get with the Skillitini. It really felt like an intimate moment as I digged into the Skillitini. Food service was on par with what you would expect from a top notch dinning experience. I would like to take a moment to recognize Alyssa ( The General Manager) for turning what was an ok restaurant into an exceptional one. Quality of food, speed of service, cleanliness, attentiveness have all now reached 5 Stars. I am a firm believer that recgnition should be given when deserved and she definitely deserves this and a raise lol. Ohh, and to the saute guy who made my pasta dishes, great job! This guy takes pride in what he does and you can taste it in every dish he makes. Thank you Johnny Carinos team.⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“First time ordering from here and I have to say Man the Chuco pizza 100/100 the chorizo and valentine sauce is amazing the garlic Parmesan chicken bite are amazing. Looks like we found our new pizza place!“

“I visited this place for the first time a month ago during lunch time. Regular menu prices are a little pricey but the weekly lunch menu offers are very tasty food choices.We paid $30 for a Pepperoni pizza, house salad and a drink for two persons ...our food was delicious. Great service ! We'll going back for sure.“

“What a staff of wonderful employees. They assist one another, and give the customers excellent service. As a businessman and retired educator, I know the importance of having a leader who communicates her expectations and is on the Frontline with helping hands. The menu is created with all palettes in mind. Ardivinos is a top restaurant in El Paso.
This evening I had a delicious sausage with anchovies pizza. Ardivonos doesn’t serve Bogle wines, so a suggested substitution with a glass of their house merlot wine was a soothing suggestion.
It is always a joy speaking with the staff as they provide a relaxing service, conversation, and a smile. Realizing nothing is perfect in this world, Ardivinos has established an ambience that relaxes the mind and soothes the heart for those of us seeking a wonderful ending to a hectic day. If you don't feel as though you don't want to cook, let Ardivinos serve be your kitchen for an evening. Don't forget to end the evening with their delectible Spumoni ice-cream.“

“Went today for some pizza and pasta a were greeted by the general manager Enrique. He was extremely kind and was conversing with us while making our food. He was extremely friendly and just made the whole experience even better. My husband and I over heard him talking to other guest and was just as kind. People like him are the reason restaurants are successful. Such a kind soul. Thank you Enrique for your kind service.“

“I consistently dine at this establishment for my midday meal and have always been impressed by the exceptional service provided. The staff consistently offers me a variety of options, with the most popular being the stromboli and pizza combination. While the prices may be slightly higher than average, I believe the quantity of food provided justifies the cost. Additionally, they offer fresh pizza daily. I highly recommend this location. Today, I was courteously served by Cecy, Jacky, and Ashley.“

“My experience there was sensational. Lately there has been such a relaxing vibe. I usually go with my wife super late at night for our weekly pizza ritual and always enjoy ourselves with immaculate food. The service here has always been on point. Congratulations on such a great staff.“

“My husband and I always visit this location and consistently receive excellent service and great food. The manager, Genesy, has always been attentive and courteous. We have only experienced a high level of customer service from staff members as well. Highly recommended!“

“Good pizza! Friendly and timely service!“

“Really great pizza and even better customer service. The staff was super friendly and made us feel welcome from the moment we walked in. The pizza was fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. You can tell they take pride in what they do. Definitely coming back!“