10 Best American Restaurants in Jefferson

“Austin Street Bistro offers an exceptional dining experience with exemplary food and service. The atmosphere is lovely, and the staff is excellent. Standout dishes include the bread pudding with maple brown butter sauce and other incredible options. The owner ensures high standards are met.“

“What a great selection of foods this restaurant/takeaway boasts. All meals are freshly baked on the premises, and the restaurant is so tastefully decorated. Great ambience. Toddler-friendly, to boot. Already looking forward to sampling the menu again soon :-)“

“1852 on Austin offers delicious food, great service, and a friendly staff. The boudin egg rolls and lobster ravioli are outstanding starters. The braised short ribs are fork tender and the chocolate peanut butter cheesecake is a must-try. Lunch menu is tasty but limited, while dinner offers more choices. A clean and tidy restaurant worth revisiting.“

“Carriage House Bed & Breakfast offers a relaxing stay with outstanding breakfasts and dinner options. The B&B features warm welcoming staff and comfortable rooms with firm beds. Guests appreciate the amenities, including free coffee and a cafe open all day. The property is clean and quaint, with easy access to local attractions. The food is exceptional, with a talented chef serving up delicious meals, including the popular S'mores near the fire pit. Overall, Carriage House Bed & Breakfast is a hidden gem that offers a memorable experience.“

“Haywood House Restaurant & Cocktail Bar is a unique spot with a cool antique decor. The angel hair pasta and shrimp scampi are delicious options on their menu. The building has a private table with a view down into a lit cistern, a bar area, and a cigar lounge upstairs. However, some aspects fell short for reviewers. The service was slow, possibly due to limited staff on a busy night. The seating arrangement was awkward, with a small drop leaf table causing discomfort for diners. Additionally, some menu items were unavailable, and there were limited gluten-free options. The food quality was decent but not outstanding, with tepid soup and disappointing tater tots. Despite the potential of the place, the overall experience did not meet expectations in terms of price, service, and food quality.“

“The KnightLight Tavern offers a cozy atmosphere with medieval decor and tapestries, serving good food and a wide selection of beers and wines. The menu features large portions, including popular items like the Camelot burger, cod, tater kegs, chicken & sausage gumbo, St. Patty's Burger, buffalo chicken sandwich, and lemon-pepper chicken with mashed potatoes. The service is great, with personal and attentive wait staff. Note that parking is limited to street parking in the historical district.“

“McGarity's Restaurant & Saloon Jefferson is a fantastic eatery with great service, margaritas, and food. The restaurant features a cozy ambiance with antiques hanging from the ceiling and an antique bar, complementing the town's antique shops. The friendly and helpful staff offer menu suggestions, and the food arrives quickly. Options include the shepherd's pie and chicken salad sandwich, served with a unique twist on the baguette. The serving sizes are generous, and prices are reasonable. The restaurant also offers live music on Fridays and Saturdays, making it a great spot to stay for hours. Overall, McGarity's is a favorite spot for food, staff, and entertainment.“

“Huddle House serves great food, with some staff providing excellent service, like Meranda and Angelica. However, some visitors experienced slow service, possibly due to understaffing. The restaurant has ample parking and is kid-friendly. While some customers had a wonderful experience, others faced issues with staffing and availability.“

“Auntie Skinner's Riverboat Club, located in a historic building in downtown Jefferson, offers a unique dining experience. The restaurant serves up good food, with notable dishes including hand-breaded Chicken Fried Steak with White Gravy and sautéed Cabbage, and Chicken Fried Chicken with real mashed potatoes and fried okra. The live music is usually enjoyable, and the atmosphere is cozy, except for the occasional disruption from smoking. The restaurant has some accessibility issues, including no handicapped access and stairways to restrooms.“