Custom Cakes near New Braunfels, TX

Art House Cakery Bakery • $
343 W Bridge St, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Custom 6 Inch Round Cake
Baby Shower Cookies
Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake
Sheet Cake

“This was our first time ordering with Art House Cakery. I live in Houston and placed my order online. The prompt communication and ease of ordering was greatly appreciated. I was able to pick up my order with no issues. I am so happy to have found a bakery with vegan options in New Braunfels. Our cake and cupcakes were so delicious! I highly recommend Art House Cakery for anyone looking for that extra attention to detail, special dietary options and/or professionalism that some big box/chain stores are lacking. This will be our go-to bakery for all of our future celebrations.“

4.9 Superb76 Reviews
New Braunfels Bakery & Cakes Bakery • $
1050 I-35 Ste 400, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

3 Leches Cake with Chocolate Slices
Assorted Sweet Breads and Pastries
Moreliana Cochinito Concha
Oatmeal Raisin Cookies
Cinnamon Tostadas
Concha Empanada
Relleno de Fresa
Birthday Cake
Mini Cookies
Custom Cakes

“I searched literally everywhere for someone who could make a sonic cake and the staff at New Braunfels bakery and cakes came through in the clutch with fees not only was it exactly what I needed and wanted but it was more than delicious I highly recommend this bakery. I’m not sure they know how to disappoint. Thanks again guys you made my sons day so much more special!“

4.6 Superb139 Reviews
Cakes Couture Bakery
2031 Central Plaza Suite 107, New Braunfels

“Thank you to Cake Couture for making a beautiful cake for our event. The cake was delicious, very moist, flavorful and the presentation was beautiful. They are so friendly and accommodating.“

4.5 Superb72 Reviews
Baskin-Robbins Ice Cream Shop • $
606 S Walnut Ave Ste B, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Oreo Cookies 'N Cream Polar Pizza
Banana Royale

“Delicious mint chip milkshake and outstanding service at Baskin-Robbins (31 Flavors)
I stopped by Baskin-Robbins, the classic 31 Flavors shop, craving a mint chip milkshake, and it completely delivered. The mint and chocolate chip milkshake was excellent from the first sip. The mint flavor came through clean and refreshing without tasting artificial or overly sweet, while the chocolate chips added the perfect bit of crunch and rich cocoa flavor in every sip. The shake itself was thick, creamy, and well-blended—exactly the consistency you want in a proper milkshake. It wasn’t watery or icy, and the balance between the cool mint and the chocolate pieces made it genuinely enjoyable rather than just another sweet treat. I finished the whole thing and still wanted more.
What elevated the visit even further was the customer service. The staff were friendly, attentive, and efficient. They took my order carefully, double-checked the flavor and size, and prepared the shake with care. The person behind the counter was upbeat and helpful, making the short wait feel pleasant rather than rushed. They handed it over with a smile and even asked if everything looked right before I left. That level of genuine, welcoming service made the whole experience feel more personal than a typical quick dessert stop.
Between the high-quality mint chip milkshake and the warm, professional customer service, this visit stood out. Baskin-Robbins continues to prove why it’s a go-to for classic ice cream treats. If you’re in the mood for a refreshing, well-made mint chip milkshake served with a smile, this is an easy recommendation. I’ll definitely be back for another one.“

3.8 Good120 Reviews
Naegelin's German Bakery Bakery • $
129 S Seguin Ave, New Braunfels

Customers` Favorites

Sweet German Pretzels
German Chocolate Cake
Chocolate Cream Puff
Miley Face Cookies
Danish Pecan Roll
Sausage Kolaches
Gingerbread Men
Big Sticky Roll
Fruit Kolaches
German Cookies

“We visited Naegelin's today while we were in New Braunfels. I used to live in NB (1959 to 1990) and grew up on their pastries. My brother was a baker their in 1960 and 1961, so there was always Naegelin's pastries to eat. Bear Claws were my absolute favorite. After 30 years, I couldn't wait! I ordered Bear Claws and 2 strudles, apple and cherry. I should have waited! The strudel was pretty good. the Bear Claws were very very disappointing. they lacked flavor and filling. The pastery used to be light and flakey. Not any longer, more like flat and tough. I hate to use the word "cardboard", but that kinda fits. Go for the Strudel, forget the Bear Claws. Childhood memories shattered again.“

4 Good538 Reviews
Emily's Cake House Custom Cakes
4601 Pebble Run, Schertz - 11.07 miles

Customers` Favorites

Congratulations Cake
Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake

“For our Anniversary in 2022, my wife and I decided we wanted to get a cake to celebrate. We both like old-fashioned butter-creme icing, and not that new light, marshmallow-ish stuff that bakeries put on cakes today. We wanted a layer-cake with thick butter-creme filling, as well as icing on the outside. Emily's Cakes came through for us. The cake we got was more than expected and was absolutely delicious! We're planning to order another one this year, if we haven't waited too late. We need it by Sunday of next week 7/14/24. Is that even possible?“

4.8 Superb68 Reviews
Destiny's Delights- Custom Cakes, Cupcakes, and More Bakery • $$
433 Silver Buckle, Schertz - 12.32 miles

“These cupcakes are the best! Especially the chocolate cupcakes. They are moist and delicious!!! The salted caramel should not be passed up either. They are moist, fluffy, and loaded with salted caramel flavor!“

4.5 Superb8 Reviews

Discover More In New Braunfels