13 Best Italian Restaurants in Tyler

“This place is amazing! I really love the bread and olive oil they bring to the table. The food is delicious, and the atmosphere is very nice, calm, and romantic. A great place for a date or to just enjoy great food. The staff is friendly and attentive, and Bernard is always making sure you're taken care of. My only complaint is that I brought my wife here on a date once, and now she just keeps wanting to go back!“

“My little one and I went to this amazing place a few weeks back.the food was amazing! The service was amazing! The owner again amazing! I cannot believe how I haven't ever tried this wonderful place out! Food was definitely made with a ton of love and I appreciate that so much! We will definitely be back! Thank you for the hospitality I appreciate you so much and so did my little one. ❤️“

“This is the first review I’ve ever given to a business, and it’s only because these 5 stars are so greatly deserved. I’ve been eating here for consistently over a year now and every time I walk in I’m greeted by the warmest, friendliest smiles. The service is unmatched, and it all starts with manager of this store, Luis. Seriously the best guy. A couple weeks ago my girl ordered online and I went to pick it up for her. Of course I didn’t check the bag first, and of course this would be the one time out of 1,000 the order was wrong. Disappointed, I called up there to see if they could just comp what they’d forgotten, but the Piada team took it a step further and refunded the entire cost of the meal (something they absolutely did not have to do.) This is the type of business you feel good about spending your money at, and overall there’s not a better bang for your buck as far as quality food goes in Tyler. Check them out, you won’t be disappointed“

“Love finding hidden gems like Bella Italian! My husband is a pizza fanatic and orders it everywhere we go! He said the pizza ? was as close to eating pizza in Italy he has had in The States. I had the pasta combo which literally had 5 different pastas, with plenty of sauce! Their marinara is PERFECT! Can't wait to go back and try the cannoli!!“

“Not crowded early Sunday lunch,but it got busy later. I'm told it's crazy busy on Saturday. The pizza was good, service was excellent. They add the gratuity to your check on groups don't really care for that. Overall it was a positive experience.“

“Wonderful local owned pizza / pasta restaurant. Probably the best tasting pizza in town. You can order by the slice just like in NYC. Large portions on pasta dishes. Don't forget the deserts, they're as good as most fancy Italian restaurants in NYC.“

“I'll give this Olive Garden a max rating because I have nothing against them. However, I have a lot against Olive Garden in general. I used to love going to Olive Garden because they had the best menu of any Italian restaurant, and had a wonderful vegetarian selection. Now it's the same ol' choices, there is no variability, the "new" menu selections are frequently recycled, and the flavor is no longer tasty.For this location at this time, our server was lacking and paid more attention to other tables and the atmosphere for the time of day (7-8pm) was much busier and chaotic than anticipated. I'm honestly at the point where I will refrain from attending future Olive Garden outings as it no longer interests me.Vegetarian options: The vegetarian options have greatly diminished over the years and are not clearly labeled. Our server was not helpful with providing information about possible vegetarian choices.“

“Once again food was amazing. Roma's starts you off with bread with oil and seasonings on the side. This time we ordered the mediterranean chicken salad and meat lovers pizza. We even enjoy the crust on our pizza. The ambiance is more low key with background music. Here on a Tuesday night so not so busy. Servers give the right amount of time for checking up on us. We would have loved it to have the salad before the pizza, so next time we will ask for it this way (only way I get the hubby to eat rabbit food ) prices are great, food is great and service is great. Definitely coming back as it's one of my favorite restaurants in Tyler.“

“I love this place. My friend Kay and I go once a week. At least. Tonight I called for a party of 7. Jennifer, Alena and Scotty went above and beyond on a Saturday night to get a table for us. The goods always remarkable. The service is even better than that. We LOVE Villagio! Note: photos from my nieces bday brunch a few days ago.“

“This is our go to pizza place. I also took my Dad here one time when he came to visit and he said “wow this is the most authentic pizza i’ve ever had in my life… and you can’t beat that price.” Needless to say, I love Little Italy. It is such a cute little restaurant that’s peaceful and the waiter we usually always get, is such a kind gentleman. Never disappointed here at little italy!“

“Olive to has wonderful soup and salad combos as well as excellent full meal dishes. My favorite is the chicken marsala followed up by the chicken calliente pasta as a close second. The servers are always attentive and friendly and the atmosphere is cozy and conducive to having a good conversation ?“

“It's my favorite Pizza Hut location in Tyler! Cleaner than the rest, and the staff are on the ball pushing those orders even on weekends. I've never waited much longer than 18 minutes or so from the time I order to the time they put it in my hands (I usually wait and/or carryout). My only criticism so far is the ease of getting in and out of the location on Broadway. It's kind of on a hill, easy to miss the turn if you're not paying attention, and you have to be real careful of the 50+mph southbound traffic as your leaving. Not going to knock them for that, but just be alert if you're visiting here during rush and dinner hours.“

“Bradley you were so awesome .I normally order to go and sometimes have to deal with attitude..Thank you for making the inside dining such a great experience..I wish you the best in school and hope you go far.Just in case you need to remember who this is, we were the two older ladies in the booth.Thanks again.Jackie“