9 Best Ice Cream Shops in American Fork

“It’s their hot fudge! Keeps me coming back!“

“I was craving some good chicken tenders and coleslaw. I remembered seeing this place and wanted to try it out. 10/10 in my opinion. The chicken tenders are so tasty and the sauces are all great. We tried bbq sauce, honey mustard and ranch. We also had the fries which were amazing! We will definitely be back to try other things on the menu and to try some of the custard. The price for 7 tenders, regular fry, coleslaw and 2 extra sauces came out to a little over 20 bucks.“

“Their ice cream is really good. They have evolved over the years since I was young to not just an ice cream cone shop. Their ice cream is pricey. They had plenty of counter help so that we received our treats quickly. Sadly, being a Saturday night, there wasn't enough seating for our party of 4. We enjoyed our treats in the car.“

“We partnered with Gooey Gourmet Brownies for a community interactive scavenger hunt this past weekend and had a wonderful experience working with the team. They were more than willing to collaborate with us and that is so telling with how much they care about their local community. Their customer service was awesome and you can tell how much they are passionate about what they do and their local community Please give them a try- SO YUMMY!!!! Thanks again to the Gooey Gourmet Brownies team!“

“Excelente calidad y servicio! Compré dos frappes, uno de Kit Kat y uno de Ferrero Rochelle. Ambos estaban riquísimos. Las chicas que me atendieron son muy simpáticas.“

“We give Eleanor's 4.5 stars. We got the cacao, raspberry and the salted caramel.

The salted caramel was very flavorful and would give it 5+ stars. It was so full of flavor, it was hard to believe it was dairy free! It tasted like frozen custard! The other two flavors were okay, but were not quite as flavorful.

I assume the coconut cream and habanero would both also be flavorful since they are scooped like the salted caramel.

The cacao and raspberry were similar in presentation to rolled ice cream, rather than scooped. 4 stars for these. I would think they would scrape the more flavorful ice cream since you can only eat a small amount at a time, so you could taste it even better, but maybe the texture of the scooped flavors would not work in the scraper machine.

Another reviewer talked about them only having three flavors late on a Saturday evening. We went late on a Saturday and they still had all the flavors available, so maybe the reviewer had the same misunderstanding as we had:

The cashier was sweet and helpful, but I initially misunderstood her when she said they only had coconut cream, habanero and salted caramel. I thought those were the only flavors they had, but those were actually the only flavors we could taste test because they were scooped. We couldn't test the other flavors because they are scraped.

I would recommend painting a lighter color on the walls. The store looked closed in the evening when it still had an hour until closing. We almost didn't go in.

Despite the small changes I would make, it was a great experience! If I didn't live so far away, I would return more often.“

“Great little cafe! The staff is amazingly friendly. The steak sandwich and tots were really good. Drink station has good add one for fountain drinks. It is a little cafe mainly to serve the staff working at USDC, but open to all. Very low cost.“

“Love the management! Love the service! Love the ice cream and chocolate the best. Yummmmm.“

“Raw vision is my fave. Orange, peach, pineapple, banana, carrot, ginger, agave. 👌“