11 Best Sandwich Shops near Payson

“Went here today with my sons. The service was absolutely amazing from the moment we walked in. The food was delicious! They were so insanely kind! They gave my boys both free chips and when we were finished eating outside he even came outside and offered them popsicles because it was so hot outside. Absolutely will be returning. These guys are fabulous!“

“I went to Jimmy John’s and ordered the Club Lulu, asking to add avocado and agreeing to pay extra for it. When I got home, I realized the sandwich didn’t have the avocado I paid for, nor did it include the bacon that’s supposed to come with it. To make things worse, I called the store to have the issue fixed, and they told me the manager would call me back — but no one ever did. That’s why I’m leaving this review.

Edited Review 12/15/2025: Manager finally reached out to me and we got the issue resolved.“

“Best subway sandwich I’ve had in a long time! The flatbread is typically very dry and crusty at subway, but this was very fresh tasting and soft, and the sandwich was very nicely assembled. Ordering through the app allows you to add coupons. It seriously was so much tastier at this location than in any of the most recent previous 10+ locations I’ve eaten it.“

“the Italian place is a great place for an amazing sandwich. reasonably priced and always delicious. I recommend the zues“

“I have been going to this Jersey Mike's location weekly for months now, and I am always impressed by how great my experience has always been. The staff is always quick and efficient, but also kind and patient. I usually get a confusing and overly customized order, but they are great at giving me exactly what I want every time. The restaurant is always clean, even when it's busy and there are tons of people there. There can sometimes be a wait, but only if you go at peak lunch and dinner hours. This is very much expected, but even if there is a wait it's never been very long. The one down side to this location is parking. If you go when it's busy the parking lot is very full and hard to find a spot. Luckily they also have a drive up, so you don't have to get out of your vehicle. Ultimately this is a fantastic place to eat with great food and wonderful staff!“

“I had a great experience at this location! I'm pregnant, and it's really great that they can heat up the meat for me when I am craving a sub! I got the number 8 and it really hit the spot. The team was all super positive and nice and helped me decide what to get since I had never been there before. It was slightly messy since I went in right after their lunch rush, but I could see people cleaning and working on getting the store back in good shape. It also didn't deter them from helping me and being patient with my pregnancy brain/indecisiveness. Will definitely be back!“

“The younger girl messed up my sandwich and it fell apart (it can happen, I totally get it and I couldn’t do it any better most likely). She apologized and the other lady gave us an extra 6 inch sandwich to make up for it. That’s what I call great customer service!“

“I normally do not have a problem with this store. I have ordered delivery from the app many times. last time I ordered I got a message saying something was wrong with my card. I got lunch so where else. I noticed a pending charge for them. I thought the charge would go away when they realized that they never made my order. nope I got charged for a delivery to I never got. I called be and talked to a nice in young man and he took my information and said he someone would be back with me. so far nothing. I feel like I got robbed. I guess I made a donation to them. I am don't know maybe business is bad so they need my money. lesson learned“

“The Jimmy John’s in Spanish Fork is fantastic. The food is always delicious. They are so fast at getting your online order ready to go. The employees are super friendly and very well trained. The place is always very clean. I can’t say enough good things about it.“

“This has to be the best Subway we’ve been to! Service was fast & friendly. The food was so fresh! I’m just sorry I didn’t take pictures. It was so good we eat our sandwich so fast. Thank you for a great lunch.

Parking: Parking was full. We had to park in the gas fueling station.“

“I stopped by here as I was in the area taking some pics. I had this place in my radar to visit. The gentleman behind the counter if you was chowder in a sourdough bowl come in Friday and before they sell out. Well I made it today and it was AWESOME. The sourdough was crisp and the chowder was AWESOME. The staff worked fast getting food out and they all worked well together. Definitely a place to visit again.“