10 Best Sandwich Shops near Payson

“They are awesome people! And Amazing food!“

“I went to Jimmy John’s and ordered the Club Lulu, asking to add avocado and agreeing to pay extra for it. When I got home, I realized the sandwich didn’t have the avocado I paid for, nor did it include the bacon that’s supposed to come with it. To make things worse, I called the store to have the issue fixed, and they told me the manager would call me back — but no one ever did. That’s why I’m leaving this review.

Edited Review 12/15/2025: Manager finally reached out to me and we got the issue resolved.“

“Best subway sandwich I’ve had in a long time! The flatbread is typically very dry and crusty at subway, but this was very fresh tasting and soft, and the sandwich was very nicely assembled. Ordering through the app allows you to add coupons. It seriously was so much tastier at this location than in any of the most recent previous 10+ locations I’ve eaten it.“

“the Italian place is a great place for an amazing sandwich. reasonably priced and always delicious. I recommend the zues“

“Good subs good food i’m definitely coming back to this place to eat“

“As someone with celiac disease, eating out can be stressful. The staff at the Spanish Fork Jersey Mike’s went above and beyond to make sure my order was safe. They used separate knives, kept everything on paper, and changed gloves to prevent cross contamination. I really appreciated their care and professionalism. I’ll definitely be back!“

“Amazing customer service and an even better experience! She was working completely by herself, but she handled every guest with kindness, patience, and a great attitude. Despite being alone, she worked hard to make sure everyone was taken care of.

Thank you so much for all your hard work and dedication! You deserve recognition for keeping everything running smoothly while taking care of everyone. Great job!“

“I normally do not have a problem with this store. I have ordered delivery from the app many times. last time I ordered I got a message saying something was wrong with my card. I got lunch so where else. I noticed a pending charge for them. I thought the charge would go away when they realized that they never made my order. nope I got charged for a delivery to I never got. I called be and talked to a nice in young man and he took my information and said he someone would be back with me. so far nothing. I feel like I got robbed. I guess I made a donation to them. I am don't know maybe business is bad so they need my money. lesson learned“

“The Jimmy John’s in Spanish Fork is fantastic. The food is always delicious. They are so fast at getting your online order ready to go. The employees are super friendly and very well trained. The place is always very clean. I can’t say enough good things about it.“

“Had a wonderful sandwich today. Thank you! We walked in only moments before closing and we’re so appreciative that you still helped us. We are from out of town but come up for our hair color appointments regularly and always want to stop by! Never been disappointed with my food or service here! A staple in my trips through! Thank you!!!“