“If you love cheesecake, VISIT. THIS. PLACE. Fresh cheesecake, not too dense but not too light, and great flavors. I bought 3 slices to take home and was planning to serve them to guests, but they didn't make it- they got devoured well before our guest arrived. The service was also prompt and friendly. A family member is supposed to stop by today and is traveling from the SML area- I really hope they are bringing cheesecake from SML coffee house with them!“
“I cannot believe this place only has 4 stars! The food is amazing, with an unbelievable gluten-free selection, the people are the nicest, and there is a sweet little gift store attached, with unique items to browse. Sadly, we only discovered the cafe on our last day of vacation. That day there was also an antique car display outside as well. Come up to Western NY and you'd have nothing but 5 star reviews.Dietary restrictions: Both gluten free and vegan offerings.“
“The food is delicious, the atmosphere is great, and the team is extremely friendly & professional!We're from NC, and SML is my family's getaway place. Ever since we found The Bagel & I, we try to stop in for breakfast every trip. My daughter has a gluten intolerance and they have gluten-free options for her. They get a 10/10 from me and I'll be a customer as long as they're there!“
“Great reasonable cafe for lunch. I've gotten their soup and 1/2 salad, sandwhich and salad add on. The cranberry walnut salad was great- lots of toppings. The loaded potato and taco soup are really good. I had a turkey club one time also. Coffee drinks are good. You can eat outside if you want facing the water or inside. Free wifi. The cheesecake desserts are great, and I had a sugar cookie once too. Reasonable price.“