21 Best Pizza Restaurants in Williamsburg

“Truly, one of the finest dining experiences I have ever had. Our waiter, Enes, was extremely knowledgeable and as passionate about the food as the chef who carefully prepared it. Everything was beautiful from the cozy interior to the plating. The portions we received were generous and filled the plate. You are likely to have leftovers to bring home. On a scale from one to 10 this spot is 100. PS. Save room for dessert.“

“Great Atmosphere!! Great Food!!“

“Definitely one of the BEST Italian restaurants I’ve ever been too! We are on vacation, and was blown away! The service, our waiter, and food was amazing! I highly recommend going here!“

“Are there any locals living in Williamsburg? I saw online that this place is very suitable for retirement life. Can anyone introduce it to me?“

“This is the best pizza I have EVER had !!!!“

“Had a solid experience with friends late at night here. Our order was a little bit messed up due to some understandable confusion - but they quickly gave us a free extra pizza to make up for it!

Very kind and hardworking staff here. Highly recommend them.“

“We’ve been here twice now and the food is truly excellent. My husband had a gyro, I had the chicken tenders. The second time he got a chicken kebab. Both times we got the fried mozzarella and WOW. Everyone who works there is super friendly and I can’t wait to come back and save room for cake. Their dessert case is calling me. No pics because we ate too fast.“

“Got a pie to go on 10/9. I requested the pizza made with less cheese, extra sauce and cooked well done. The staff working made it perfect! The best pizza by far in the area. I’m from Manhattan and if you want NY style pizza this is the only place around that deserves your money.“

“Best Pizza in Williamsburg Va!!! I drive to get pizza there weekly if not twice a week; takes me about 25 minutes to get there! The owner and his entire staff are just wonderful and friendly!!!! I feel like I’m family every time I go there! Thanks Charlie and all the staff!!! Alana“

“Anna's has been providing pizza at the 5k to benefit The Arc of Greater Williamsburg, a local nonprofit serving adults with intellectual and developmental disabilities, for many years. This year was no different - the team at Anna's showed up with the positive energy they're known for, smiles on their faces, and most delicious pizza we could ask for. Their kindness and generosity through this effort does not go unnoticed. People raved about how amazing their pizza is and more than that, how absolutely kind each person working was. THANK YOU, Anna's! You all are a wonderful asset to our community.“

“This is by far one of the best Italian restaurants I’ve ever been to! True authentic food. Wish we lived closer so we could go more often! Everything from the bread, pasta dishes, to the desserts are all homemade and SO good. We even had a musician come and serenade us! 10/10!!!“

“This is hands down my favorite restaurant in Williamsburg. Great authentic and delicious Italian food.😋“

“The pizza is phenomenal, and I'm from NY and hate all the pizza here in VA except this spot and one other out in the middle of nowhere.
With 2 exceptions, the staff here were all kind of flippant. Not rude or anything. They give of the vibe of wanting to get through their shift. The girl that greeted us seemed almost to not even really be there at all.
So why 5 stars for the service? Patrick.
I think he noticed my wife has some mobility issues, because he brought over or food and some of the shakers then engaged us with a cheerful attitude and I'm not just talking about as a staff member. The man engaged us as if we were friends he hasn't seen in awhile and was amazingly nice and made our visit go from a common place one to something outstanding. Thank you, Patrick! We appreciate you!“

“AMAZING!!!! 100% Excellent food and service. So much to chose from. Thank you for such a wonderful experience. The bathroom could use so.e TLC and deep clean.“

“I doorsah for a side job, I went and delivered a personal pan pizza and as the customer went to pick it up the box fell apart and her pizza went everywhere. We went back to pizzahut told them what happen and the they were happy to replace it.“

“Craft 31 is my favorite restaurant in Williamsburg, but this dinner in particular was the best experience we've ever had!! Our waitress was outstanding, and the manager was so kind. We dined in with our 1 year old baby, and the entire staff kept interacting with her and complimenting how cute she was. We felt so special and taken care of, truly an amazing visit. 10000/10!!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Great food and good service“

“Had a wonderful interaction with who I believe was the store lead on Nov 16. The store was busy however she had a contagiously positive outlook and with a friendly smile, was actively helpful with asking about customers orders, completing them and ect. Fantastic job!

This was the 4655 Monticello Ave # 107, Williamsburg, VA 23188 location“

“Best local spot in town! Go to for pizza“

“I ordered pizza for curbside pick up. I waited, watching pizzas being made and seeing young man keep touching his clothes (side of shirt) while he worked. Not clean behavior. I waited for over ten minutes and finally went in to pick up my cold pizza. So much for curbside delivery and the prepaid tip for that service….“

“I have to say, I thought customer service was dead when it comes to young people… David at this location was fantastic. He greeted me with a smile, and was very genuine. Asked me if I was on vacation, I said Yes and He gave me a $16 discount off of the $85 order. I was highly impressed. I was expecting to pay full price like always but it’s nice to know that customer service still lives.Thank you David whenever I’m in the area, I will make sure that I will come to your store to feed my family“