37 Best Pizza Restaurants near Yorktown

“Shout out to Jordan's Pizza for a delicious dinner tonight. I had one of those days where making a home cooked meal was the absolute last thing on my mind. Kids voted for pizza but I've been pretty unhappy with Marcos lately. Googled nearby delivery and their reviews seemed great. They're in Lackey off Old Willamsburg Rd. The pies were fantastic!I Big slices, New York style crust, and the sauce was perfect! Not too sweet and just the right consistency. 🤌🏻🤌🏻 We also got a baked ziti which came with a side salad and garlic knots. It was more than enough for two people to share and came to us nice and hot. We will definitely be ordering from them again!!“

“Placed an order late yesterday evening and waited for it to be delivered & we never got it. Came in today & Isiah turned our negative experience into a positive one. He was able to confirm the order was cancelled and he was able to make it for us, such a great gesture and excellent service, we appreciate Isaiah going the extra mile :)“

“This place has some seriously great food. The pizzas are the bomb 💣 😍. The sandwiches are awesome and im obsessed with their salad 🥗. There is so much variety on the menu, and everything I have tried is delicious 😋 so its hard to pick. I certainly wouldn't complain about that cause I know whatever I choose, will be good. This review is coming from a serious picky eater. I only eat at 6 different places in this state, and this is one of them. Im glad its right down the street.“

“As a frequent regular (probably more often than I should admit), I can confidently say the lunchtime pizza here is fantastic. The pizza is always fresh and hits the spot. I’ve also had several late-night deliveries, and the quality has been just as consistent.

Huge shoutout to Mike and John, who are absolute rockstars and always make the visit better. While every place has its off days, keep in mind that most people only post when they have a bad experience. My experiences have been overwhelmingly positive.“

“Our ladies group is returning again tomorrow for another delicious, hot fresh excellent choice of varied, authentic Italian food. The service is great. each of the dishes anyone had were excellent!“

“I love this domino's so much, the people are super nice in there. Ive waited for my food in there a couple times and had conversations with the cooks and people at the front and they were so easy to talk to and amazing personalities. I even asked them for suggestions on their favorite items to get and I got them, they did not disappoint by any means.“

“Most authentic Italian food for miles. 10/10“

“Best pizza and subs in town!“

“Food will speak for its self. Great authentic pizza. Dough is homemade and you can taste the work and effort they put into their ingredients. If you know and love what genuine pizza should taste like, this place is a must try. Great job guys! Keep up your hard work!“

“Love this place!!! Great food, great people, great vibes“

“Very first time ever at one excellent experience“

“Do not get the sample dozen box if you don't want to be plagued with learning that what you thought was your favorite donut is not because you've tried something new! If you don't like friendly customer service, don't talk to Mike. He will make sure to try and get you what you want and then some. And... if you like to search for donut filling this is not the place for you. It is not possible to not get some in every bite. If you are weak, bring a friend to help you carry these absurdly heavy, heavenly things. But if you do, you will risk having to share with them, so choose your person wisely. So bottom line that no thanks to you, I have found my new favorite donut shop ❤️ Well done guys! I'm so glad you are not on the way to my work as I would surely struggle to not stop there daily!“

“This restaurant has a great breakfast but what makes it great is Kim she goes above & beyond with the customers. You can have good food but the people make the place.“

“Been going here since I was a baby. Simple, reliable, and satisfying 🍕“

“Do not let the picture of the outside fool you, this place is fantastic. It is nicely decorated, offers excellent service, and the food had large portions and is extremely well done. We had a party if 7 and almost everyone ordered a different dish. Everyone enjoyed their food and a few people ordered dessert as well. The price is very reasonable, and I would highly recommend this place to anyone. We can't wait to go back.“

“love their pizza family specials. it's our go to every friday night :)“

“I haven’t eaten here since the newer owners took over. It is fantastic. Everything is fresh, the restaurant is clean and the staff is so nice. Please give them a chance. You won’t regret it.“

“Eating at a Vinny’s is like eating with family. Always delicious! Always fast! Always a friendly wait staff! Always so clean! Just like eating with family. We love Vinny’s!“

“Papa John's is my favorite fast pizza. I no longer live within 1 hrs of one, and definitely not within delivery distance. Thus particular one was cleaner than most, on my way elsewhere, and an apt reproduction of the company product. 100% of what you desire from chain pizza.“

“Tonight all our food was on point! Pan pizza, pasta, sandwiches, parm bites, lava cakes. Thanks for the hot n fresh food along with fast n friendly service Keith and Dominos Team“

“Felt like I was visiting “the good ole days” where people are friendly and serve great food. Unlike the chain restaurants of today. So refreshing!“

“The stuffed peppers are my favorite. with a fresh salad and a bottle of red. lasagna is second, always fresh and healthy portions. Pizzas are true Sicilian, don't forget the ancovies. Home made bread for the table, for the calzone and, pizzas made inda house, you can taste the difference from any other Italia resturant in town. Prices are extremely reasonable! Chicken parm, Meatball , Lasagna all made fresh inda house. Great choice of wines by the bottle (take home what you dont finish or the glass. Fresh home made desserts like Caramel apple bourbon bread puddin and NewYork deli style carrot and Cheese cakes too. Reminds me of my Mom's cooking. I've tried them all, my family and friends all love this place. Nicest staff in Yorktown. Call for Rita and book the back room for big family parties. Andrea has it all.“

“great food, fair prices, and quick service“

“it was not good at all. it was hard and cold. It tasted like old food. it is too expensive for the food to be like that.“

“I ordered pizzas from Cosco for my daughter’s bday. At the time of the birthday party when it was time to pick them up, they didn’t have a single one ready. I called this papa John’s and they had me 10 pizzas ready in about 20 minutes. I couldn’t believe it they saved the day. Thank you to you and your staff for helping me feed 20 hungry kids in so pinch. Great pizzas too, thank you !!“

“Tonight all our food was on point! Pan pizza, pasta, sandwiches, parm bites, lava cakes. Thanks for the hot n fresh food along with fast n friendly service Keith and Dominos Team“

“We do delivery only. The food never disappoints, but the drivers never pay attention to the instructions in the app. We ask them to leave the food at our door, and they always stand there until we answer. That will always be my only complaint. Everything else is good.“

“Stopped by to have a bite the strombollie was on point with lots of meat and cheese and little bread which is great most places skimp on cheese and meat cuz thay are making profit margins better but this was on point keep up the good work guys was also fast food was ready time in line 2 min faster than a chick- filet 😆 🤣“

“Since they have opened this location, we have eaten there almost every week. The staff are friendly and quick with orders. Everything we have ordered has been top quality, would be nice to have some pepperoni hot n' ready pizzas available but it's not going to stop me from coming back, that's for sure!“

“I doubt this review will be seen, but I must say that this is hands down the best pizza in the city of Newport News. The quality is always amazing and so is the service. What pushed me to write a review today was the interaction I had with one of the members of staff. I unfortunately forgot to ask his name but today (1/29/26 @ approx. noon) he wore a grey hat, grey sweater, and black pants. We had a very enthralling conversation about the Hello Kitty creator and general art things once he mentioned my hoodie. I hope that I run into him again. Amazing food and people working there 😊“

“Excellent Subs and service! 😎👍👍“

“Wonderful staff always friendly. Their services bar none the best!“

“I have been coming here ever since I discovered the good prices and late hours. The workers have always been very nice and the food has always been good to excellent. Is it the best pizza I’ve ever had? No. Is it the best I’ve ever had for only $10 though? It certainly might be. Highly recommend!“

“best place in town love the food drinks an the staff“

“awsome place to eat staff is friendly and efficient“

“Been ordering from Papa Johns for at least 20 years now. Can't get any better!“