20 Best Pizza Restaurants in Williamsburg

“One of the best meals I’ve ever had. This is real authentic Italian food.“

“We always eat here any time that we are in Williamsburg. I almost always have the same thing because it is just so damn good; hot pastrami sub and an order of fries. The sub bun is perfect and the pastrami serving is very generous and very flavorful and very filling too. The fries serving fills the plate and cooked just right. On our way back home, we stop by again and take a sub with us to enjoy that evening. This Deli has our strongest recommendation.“

“Definitely one of the BEST Italian restaurants I’ve ever been too! We are on vacation, and was blown away! The service, our waiter, and food was amazing! I highly recommend going here!“

“Are there any locals living in Williamsburg? I saw online that this place is very suitable for retirement life. Can anyone introduce it to me?“

“Went last night and the food and atmosphere were wonderful. The workers were awesome and super friendly.“

“This is the best pizza I have EVER had !!!!“

“Outstanding customer service, and delicious food. I’m so impressed! Cory and my Mom“

“Great place to grab a quick slice of pizza. I’m obsessed with the pickle pizza with hot honey (trust me, it’s life-changing) but I’ve also tried regular cheese slices and the garlic knots and everything has been consistently great. Staff is really nice too!“

“We visit Blaze Pizza often, and the service is always excellent, especially thanks to Antonio. He’s consistently helpful and professional. However, we’ve had a couple of negative experiences with newer staff members like Dom, who were unprofessional and disrespectful. Overall, Antonio’s dedication truly stands out.“

“Anna's has been providing pizza at the 5k to benefit The Arc of Greater Williamsburg, a local nonprofit serving adults with intellectual and developmental disabilities, for many years. This year was no different - the team at Anna's showed up with the positive energy they're known for, smiles on their faces, and most delicious pizza we could ask for. Their kindness and generosity through this effort does not go unnoticed. People raved about how amazing their pizza is and more than that, how absolutely kind each person working was. THANK YOU, Anna's! You all are a wonderful asset to our community.“

“This is by far one of the best Italian restaurants I’ve ever been to! True authentic food. Wish we lived closer so we could go more often! Everything from the bread, pasta dishes, to the desserts are all homemade and SO good. We even had a musician come and serenade us! 10/10!!!“

“This is hands down my favorite restaurant in Williamsburg. Great authentic and delicious Italian food.😋“

“What an amazing Gluten free menu! The best Gluten free Italian we have had in years! Thank You so much for such an amazing dinner.“

“I am a door dasher also and have been to every pizza hut location in williamsburg multiple times. the monticello/jamestown location is BY FAR the best run with the best quality food. The manager, April Lineberry runs a tight ship and it shows. This is the only location I've never had any issues with. Even for door dash, they don't keep us waiting long if they can help it and they do everything they can to make sure they get orders out accurately and promptly. We live in Lightfoot but always come to this location over the closer one!“

“Best local spot in town! Go to for pizza“

“We had a very big order tonight and the food was fresh and made with care. The presentation of our food was very nice. Our food taste very good. I did not get to see who cooked, but pizza huts owners need to NEVER lose them. They are the reason why Pizza Hut will always have a returning customer. Thank you for feeding my family with care!“

“Some of the nicest employees work at this spot! The food always comes out fresh and the workers really take time and care about the product. I know “it’s just a chain pizza spot” - but the workers really make the spot worth ordering here.“

“Craft 31 is my favorite restaurant in Williamsburg, but this dinner in particular was the best experience we've ever had!! Our waitress was outstanding, and the manager was so kind. We dined in with our 1 year old baby, and the entire staff kept interacting with her and complimenting how cute she was. We felt so special and taken care of, truly an amazing visit. 10000/10!!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“I have to say, I thought customer service was dead when it comes to young people… David at this location was fantastic. He greeted me with a smile, and was very genuine. Asked me if I was on vacation, I said Yes and He gave me a $16 discount off of the $85 order. I was highly impressed. I was expecting to pay full price like always but it’s nice to know that customer service still lives.Thank you David whenever I’m in the area, I will make sure that I will come to your store to feed my family“

“Great pizza, light thin almost flaky crust. Delicious. Didn't realize from website, no in door dining or table service. Only outdoor covered patio. Table next is had BBQ and brisket, claimed it was the best they ever had. We will be back.“