21 Best Pizza Restaurants in Williamsburg

“Are there any locals living in Williamsburg? I saw online that this place is very suitable for retirement life. Can anyone introduce it to me?“

“Definitely one of the BEST Italian restaurants I’ve ever been too! We are on vacation, and was blown away! The service, our waiter, and food was amazing! I highly recommend going here!“

“Sandwiches and all the food is so good. Family owned for many years. Quality never wavers! Prices have always been reasonable and you get a lot of food for your money!“

“We went today after the restaurant was recommended to us, and I’m SO glad that we did. This was the best Italian food I have had in a VERY long time. Everything that we had was absolutely incredible!! Highly, highly recommend.“

“This is the best pizza I have EVER had !!!!“

“The pizza is good, actually the food is good. What I don't like is being lied to. We ordered through Slice, and when my husband got home with dinner, we were short 1 slice of pizza. We called, the girl who answered said "That's what Slice told us, and what you paid for. You paid for 3 slices of pizza not 4. You're going to have to call Slice." We did, guess what, they record all their calls, and said they gave the correct order and will refund us the $7.00 plus tax on our order. SHAME on that girl, who flat lied. SHAME on her for not giving a rats fuzzy balls about the very people who help make her paycheck.“

“Happened upon this restaurant with my daughter when we dropped in to another local pizzeria nearby that was out of dough an hour before closing time. The staff here were super friendly and the pizza was amazing! We had to buy a bottle of their hot honey to take home, heaven in a bottle. Keep up the great customer service and serving amazing pies, Team Bellissimo!“

“Two sisters pizzeria is very good food and most importantly is Hallal food

I enjoy their company and the food very much

What makes them special
They can cook for you Pakistani and Indian food as well“

“March 2024
I used to come here at least once a month or so when I lived up the road in the Richmond area, so while visiting Williamsburg I was happy to come back after quite a few years. We even came here two days in a row for dinner. Everything here is wonderful, whether pizza, spaghetti, lasagna, bread, or desserts. You really can’t go wrong and prices are very reasonable.“

“We were meeting a family member for the first time and needed a place for several people. I called the manager with 2 days advance and he and his staff set up a private dining experience for us to enjoy this beautiful life moment. He personally checked in on us during the meal. We very much appreciated the special treatment he gave us for such a serious moment in our lives. The food was great also! Thank you to the staff for all that you did.“

“Well, apparently I’ve been missing out for the past 20 years! We’ve always gone to another Italian restaurant on the other side of town, but I’m moving soon so we decided to try out Antonio’s since it’s around the corner from my new home. WOW!! Talk about delicious! Seriously, we both said it’s our new favorite Italian restaurant in town. Can’t wait to go again!“

“Delicious pasta, cooked perfectly!“

“It's a trendy pizza place, that's nothing special, but the PIZZA IS DELICIOUS. Regular thin crust, gluten free crust, cauliflower crust, and keto crust. Vegan cheese and vegan meat. The menu is posted, but you can choose your own toppings. It's a touch pricey, but good enough that I go once a month.“

“Love the bartender Alisha“

“The beer options and food options were fantastic, our waiter was incredible and the atmosphere was great. The food was good, just lacked any impressive flavor (very basic tastes, but came out hot and fresh). The water tasted very off and unfortunately no bottled water was available (which was important to us after a full day at Busch Gardens). The kids food options were great and the quality of their food was fantastic.

Don’t recommend the “crab” & spinach artichoke dip. It’s basically just normal spinach artichoke dip with a fishy after taste, heavy on the artichoke & non-existent on the crab. Everything else was good though!“

“We were so excited that Daddyos introduced a plantbased (vegan friendly) cheese to their options so that we could enjoy their amazing pizza! And it was the best vegan pizza in Williamsburg! The crust was amazing and the vegan cheese was the perfect melted and tasting combo! If you are dairy free for any reason, the vegan cheese and veggie pizza at Daddyos was so good we can’t wait to go back!!!“

“Tonight was our second time coming to the Jamestown Pie Company and once again everything we tried was amazing! This time we had pizza, pot pie, and of course 3 different kinds of pie and a cup of ice cream! I highly recommend this hidden gem!!!“

“Had a wonderful interaction with who I believe was the store lead on Nov 16. The store was busy however she had a contagiously positive outlook and with a friendly smile, was actively helpful with asking about customers orders, completing them and ect. Fantastic job!

This was the 4655 Monticello Ave # 107, Williamsburg, VA 23188 location“

“I have to say, I thought customer service was dead when it comes to young people… David at this location was fantastic. He greeted me with a smile, and was very genuine. Asked me if I was on vacation, I said Yes and He gave me a $16 discount off of the $85 order. I was highly impressed. I was expecting to pay full price like always but it’s nice to know that customer service still lives.Thank you David whenever I’m in the area, I will make sure that I will come to your store to feed my family“

“The AC was working great. Ordered online to pick up on the way home. Got there and only had a few minutes wait. Burn your mouth Hot out of the oven.

Parking: Long parking lot in front of the building, might get a little walk in looking at the other places.“