26 Best Pizza Restaurants in Williamsburg

“One of the best meals I’ve ever had. This is real authentic Italian food.“

“Definitely one of the BEST Italian restaurants I’ve ever been too! We are on vacation, and was blown away! The service, our waiter, and food was amazing! I highly recommend going here!“

“We always eat here any time that we are in Williamsburg. I almost always have the same thing because it is just so damn good; hot pastrami sub and an order of fries. The sub bun is perfect and the pastrami serving is very generous and very flavorful and very filling too. The fries serving fills the plate and cooked just right. On our way back home, we stop by again and take a sub with us to enjoy that evening. This Deli has our strongest recommendation.“

“Don’t trust me, trust the parking lot. This place stays packed when the OPEN sign is on.

When you stop in, you’ll find a quick and fun atmosphere.

Don’t get the Bronx style tough! Save some for me!“

“This is the best pizza I have EVER had !!!!“

“best pizza in town“

“Are there any locals living in Williamsburg? I saw online that this place is very suitable for retirement life. Can anyone introduce it to me?“

“Went last night and the food and atmosphere were wonderful. The workers were awesome and super friendly.“

“This is hands down my favorite restaurant in Williamsburg. Great authentic and delicious Italian food.😋“

“This is by far one of the best Italian restaurants I’ve ever been to! True authentic food. Wish we lived closer so we could go more often! Everything from the bread, pasta dishes, to the desserts are all homemade and SO good. We even had a musician come and serenade us! 10/10!!!“

“My wife and I are constantly looking for somewhere good to eat and a little reluctant to try new places because so many are a disappointment i.e zoe's kitchen , sticks, noodles and company. And many more but blaze was a pleasant surprise....Daniel and the rest of the crew were very friendly...love the sauce and being able to choose the toppings which seem to be of a good quality including extra sauce...most pizza hardly has any sauce ..love the flavor from the brick oven...and the blood orange lemonade is really good and something different....really liked the overall experience“

“What an amazing Gluten free menu! The best Gluten free Italian we have had in years! Thank You so much for such an amazing dinner.“

“Anna's has been providing pizza at the 5k to benefit The Arc of Greater Williamsburg, a local nonprofit serving adults with intellectual and developmental disabilities, for many years. This year was no different - the team at Anna's showed up with the positive energy they're known for, smiles on their faces, and most delicious pizza we could ask for. Their kindness and generosity through this effort does not go unnoticed. People raved about how amazing their pizza is and more than that, how absolutely kind each person working was. THANK YOU, Anna's! You all are a wonderful asset to our community.“

“Absolutely loved our recent visit to Pizza Hut! The pizza was hot, fresh, and delicious with perfect crust and generous toppings. Excellent service from the friendly staff, fast delivery, and great value for the money. Clean restaurant and consistently high quality. Highly recommend — will definitely be back!“

“excellent service and super attention from our server Liss, despite the lengthy wait for entrées coming out of the kitchen . good teamwork by the front of house staff. Food was very good. Only the other concern would be the excessive noise level has ! It was extremely loud, cannot carry on a normal conversation . Poor acoustic buffering in dining room.“

“There are many tourist type restaurants that people will recommend you in Williamsburg and let me tell ya, skip it. Go to Dizzy Izzy’s where you will find a true family owned local spot near Jamestown beach. The owner was so nice and talked about his menu. He explained how much of the items are house made and/or made with imported ingredients straight from Italy. We had a couple subs on freshly made ciabatta bread that was so incredibly good. We also got some of the chocolate chip cookies and my goodness, one of the best chocolate chip cookies I have had. We will definitely be back to try some pizza soon!“

“Great Food - HUGE portions - Great waitress - our family was EXTREMELY satisfied! ⭐️ ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Best local spot in town! Go to for pizza“

“I’ve been there a couple of time in the past couple of weeks and the African American guy that is always at the register with locs (used to have a fro) always has the best service and attitude. Even when it was really busy one night and orders were backed up for an hour, he took care of everyone and made sure they were all good. This kind of customer service is rare now a days and I’ll continue to use this location and recommend it to others as well. Great guy you guys have on staff. I didn’t catch his name but he is tallish and wears a hair net as well.“

“Some of the nicest employees work at this spot! The food always comes out fresh and the workers really take time and care about the product. I know “it’s just a chain pizza spot” - but the workers really make the spot worth ordering here.“

“I have to say, I thought customer service was dead when it comes to young people… David at this location was fantastic. He greeted me with a smile, and was very genuine. Asked me if I was on vacation, I said Yes and He gave me a $16 discount off of the $85 order. I was highly impressed. I was expecting to pay full price like always but it’s nice to know that customer service still lives.Thank you David whenever I’m in the area, I will make sure that I will come to your store to feed my family“

“Could prove that my online delivery was confirmed and expected to be delivered to my door. Manager Jeremy stated that he could care less that I could prove it but ended up wanting to take care of the delivery service payment out of the delivery person's tip. I think that's horrible! Everyone deserves the money they earned because they worked hard for it. To just dismiss proof and is crazy! Just FYI, once I got the food, it was freezing cold and wasn't offered a receipt. Be warned. The John Tyler's Papa Johns doesn't look out for their staff nor provide customer service like it used to.“

“Been searching near and far for fried pickle spears and this place did not disappoint they were phenomenal. The sandwiches were great too i got a BLT the wife got the turkey breast sub and my 2 yr old got a grilled cheese it was all delicious.“

“Had a solid experience with friends late at night here. Our order was a little bit messed up due to some understandable confusion - but they quickly gave us a free extra pizza to make up for it!

Very kind and hardworking staff here. Highly recommend them.“

“Heather was fantastic. After a full day at a local park, we just wanted to eat and not worry about going back out after landing at the hotel. Stopped in for pizza and subs, the Big Boy is huge enough to feed a party of 4 alone. Dough was delicious, toppings were plentiful. Only thing I could say is the pie cuts were crazy, we had a good laugh.“