38 Best Pizza Restaurants near Poquoson

“Been going here since I was a baby. Simple, reliable, and satisfying 🍕“

“awsome place to eat staff is friendly and efficient“

“best place in town love the food drinks an the staff“

“Wonderful staff always friendly. Their services bar none the best!“

“Always love coming here. Went recently and the bartenders were phenomenal.“

“Amazing pizza! Great wine! Great vibe! They’ve truly put together an amazing atmosphere. We’ve always loved coming here!“

“Best food ever! Thanks for keeping the great food coming during covid19“

“Great !!!!! I <3 Sals NY Pizza!!“

“They really have good food options and my favourite is the lamb over rice“

“Very first time ever at one excellent experience“

“We had a fun birthday party! I did not have to organize anything!“

“just visiting. Fantastic! Michters 12yr . Baja Tacos. The Big Chop. Trish at the bar all for the win“

“I ordered a chicken Philly, and it was made exactly how I asked. I requested the onions to be well done, and babyyy—they understood the assignment! My salad was super fresh and green, not that iceberg lettuce, which I really appreciated. The staff was very friendly, and I like that the owner always speaks when you come in—though a smile would make it even better. Overall, I really enjoyed my experience and will definitely be back.“

“Five Stars ⭐️ -Small storefront location but has Wonderful food and very pleasant staff. Plenty of seating inside.“

“I've been comming here since 08, I went in yesterday and I was 2 dollars short. When I went to grab my credit card. The gentleman said no don't worry about it. I was so grateful he even gave me a free 2 litter. Small business like this is what this country needs!!!!! Always will be a customer.“

“Carry out today not the best. Went through a spell a while back and stopped going for a while. Hope today was just off. Will try again best week“

“Great customer service and pizza. Been going there since they opened that location. Love their Roma crust topping!“

“Wonderful service and great food! Today was our first visit but we will definitely be back.“

“Family restaurant, the best service you can get and the food is delicious. You get an amazing experience for a really good price. I totally recommend this place, the best Italian restaurant I tried in Hampton.“

“First time, husband got spaghetti w/ meatballs. I got pastrami hoagie. Took a house salad, cheesecake and canolli home. Food is fantastic, good service. Wish they had booths and the place felt warmer. Single tables all around felt out of place for an Italian Restaurant with good food. We will be back though“

“i love coming here every friday! the pizza is always fresh, hot, and so freaking delicious! taylor always goes the extra mile and is so helpful and kind. i couldn’t recommend this place more!“

“As of yesterday, I was a first timer....we ordered the baked lasagna and a steak n' cheese sub. The food was DELICIOUS, and arrived in a timely manner, still warm,, and packaged nicely....we are ordering the baked lasagna again tonight, and trying the pizza....I highly recommend this restaurant, and have started spreading the word....also, warm and friendly customer service, which can be truly hard to find.“

“Eating at a Vinny’s is like eating with family. Always delicious! Always fast! Always a friendly wait staff! Always so clean! Just like eating with family. We love Vinny’s!“

“This Marco's is a hidden gem! I had no idea they had seating! It was so nice and clean, with music playing. And the pizza is always amazing 😋 Love the hot honey pepperoni! Jazz was super welcoming, we had a great lunch date and will definitely be back!“

“I have to give the biggest shoutout to Mama Rosa’s Italian Family Restaurant They deserve 100 stars. We held a private gathering there on March 9, 2026, after a funeral, and they treated our entire family with so much love and care. Anthony was amazing from start to finish, staying in contact, checking in, and making sure everything went smoothly. The whole family and staff were just as kind, welcoming, and attentive. We had over 75 people, and everyone raved about the food (which was delicious!) and the service. They truly went above and beyond for us. After the event, a few of us stayed and talked with their Nona (Mima). She is one of the warmest, sweetest souls I’ve ever met. We shared stories and hugs, and it meant so much. Mama Rosa’s is a treasure. If you’re thinking about going — GO! Don’t think twice.“

“I work here, and I enjoy serving my customers“

“Placed an order late yesterday evening and waited for it to be delivered & we never got it. Came in today & Isiah turned our negative experience into a positive one. He was able to confirm the order was cancelled and he was able to make it for us, such a great gesture and excellent service, we appreciate Isaiah going the extra mile :)“

“This place has some seriously great food. The pizzas are the bomb 💣 😍. The sandwiches are awesome and im obsessed with their salad 🥗. There is so much variety on the menu, and everything I have tried is delicious 😋 so its hard to pick. I certainly wouldn't complain about that cause I know whatever I choose, will be good. This review is coming from a serious picky eater. I only eat at 6 different places in this state, and this is one of them. Im glad its right down the street.“

“The stuffed peppers are my favorite. with a fresh salad and a bottle of red. lasagna is second, always fresh and healthy portions. Pizzas are true Sicilian, don't forget the ancovies. Home made bread for the table, for the calzone and, pizzas made inda house, you can taste the difference from any other Italia resturant in town. Prices are extremely reasonable! Chicken parm, Meatball , Lasagna all made fresh inda house. Great choice of wines by the bottle (take home what you dont finish or the glass. Fresh home made desserts like Caramel apple bourbon bread puddin and NewYork deli style carrot and Cheese cakes too. Reminds me of my Mom's cooking. I've tried them all, my family and friends all love this place. Nicest staff in Yorktown. Call for Rita and book the back room for big family parties. Andrea has it all.“

“I ordered pizzas from Cosco for my daughter’s bday. At the time of the birthday party when it was time to pick them up, they didn’t have a single one ready. I called this papa John’s and they had me 10 pizzas ready in about 20 minutes. I couldn’t believe it they saved the day. Thank you to you and your staff for helping me feed 20 hungry kids in so pinch. Great pizzas too, thank you !!“

“As a frequent regular (probably more often than I should admit), I can confidently say the lunchtime pizza here is fantastic. The pizza is always fresh and hits the spot. I’ve also had several late-night deliveries, and the quality has been just as consistent.

Huge shoutout to Mike and John, who are absolute rockstars and always make the visit better. While every place has its off days, keep in mind that most people only post when they have a bad experience. My experiences have been overwhelmingly positive.“

“Great product, great price. The staff is friendly and efficient, and the lobby is very clean. I will be coming back here quite often!“

“My order today 893558856 was delivered extremely fast by a super kind driver! Thank you!“

“Got a flyer in the mail, and I want to support a locally owned business, so decided to try them. I've only been there once, and I only had the pizza (ham and pineapple, meat lovers). I thought the pizza was on par with Poppa John's. To me that says a lot because Poppa John's is my favorite. The prices are comparable to the big chains. Took about 20 minutes for my order. I'll definitely give them another try.“

“I needed to find a caterer for my classes 50th reunion. Mose worked with me to select a menu that was perfect and met our every need. Classmates are still telling me how much they enjoyed the food. Thank you to the entire Vinny’s staff for doing an exceptional job for us!“

“The last time I tried a place like this was Blaze Pizza in 2017 back in California and it was good. I was craving pizza tonight, but not your regular kind. I ordered here from grubhub and got an 11 inch thin crust with varying toppings. And let me tell you, it was DELICIOUS. Next time I'm getting take out, I'm getting from here again.“