Italian Restaurants near Middlebury

Costello's Market Seafood • $$
99 Maple St #12, Middlebury

“I wish I could give out a rare 6 star review. Today, my friends and I stopped in for an early lunch and were blown away by Costello’s.

To begin, the restaurant/market offers a welcoming and warm vibe with plenty of selection of wines, pastas, oils, treats, and deli selections to regularly purchase at any time. Things are clean, well organized, and presented well.

The service was absolutely exceptional. The host was exceptional in her service and friendliness. It is rare I do this, but I need to go out of my way to say just how much she made my day from how friendly and professional she was. She handled a very busy lunch rush with style and grace; effortlessly.

The food was sensational. I got the brisket, one of my friends got a Cuban, and one got a big salad. All were absolutely amazing. Fresh ingredients. Flavorful and thoughtful combinations, and perfect execution. The menu is extensive, and excellent. Their seafood options are very strong as well. Thank you to my man in the back. You make amazing food!

Overall if you need a great place that has you covered with the nice red wines, deli selections, pastas, sandwiches and fresh ingredients then stop by today! Because of your service and how delicious the food was, I will be sure to come back again. Thank you so much. You have a wonderful business. We will be back again!

- T“

4.7 Superb121 Reviews
Green Peppers Restaurant Pizza • $
10 Washington St #3, Middlebury

Customers` Favorites

Half Pepperoni Half Works Pizza
Breaded Mozzarella Sticks
Meat Lovers Pizza
Z Special Pizza
Pepperoni Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Burger

“Amazing food great service. Went there for Mother’s Day had an amazing waiter..“

4.1 Good152 Reviews
Paddlers Pub American • $
937 W Shore Rd, Salisbury - 8.5 miles

Customers` Favorites

Angler's Platter
Drunken Mussels
Spinach Salad

“Our experience at Paddlers Pub was great We went 3 times during our vacation! It's convenient, amazing views and super friendly staff. Like most places around the country right now they seemed short staffed, but that's understandable. The food was really good...the shrimp & spinach salad was fabulous, I ordered all 3 times. That dressing, so good! My family loved everything they got (except the pizza, skip that). The drinks were cold and they have great options for being the only place to get one. Have to give a shout out to the guys running the marina too, they were so accommodating and friendly. The whole atmosphere was just warm and welcoming. We can't wait to return!“

4.4 Superb35 Reviews

You May Also Like