Seafood Restaurants in Middlebury

Costello's Market Seafood • $$
99 Maple St, Middlebury

“Do not sleep on this place. I had a pate sandwich that I cannot stop thinking about. We also shared a more traditional Italian that was equally as good. We got Bolognese and fresh pasta for dinner along with mini beef Wellington, all made in house and ready to bring home, which were also amazing. I've been looking for a decent sandwich in Vermont and this far exceeds decent.“

4.9 Superb28 Reviews
Fire & Ice Steak House • $$
26 Seymour St, Middlebury

Customers` Favorites

Maple Bacon Cheeseburger
Slow Roasted Prime Rib
Candy Cane Beet Salad
Maple Old Fashioned
The Bar Room Steak
Maple Creme Brulee
French Onion Soup
Champagne Chicken
Woodchuck Salad
Moose Pub Wings

“From out of town. Back Again after a few years. We really missed this place. We were here for Eclipse week. Everyone in my group were amazed by the huge charm of the place with small cozy cubbies, small rooms, 1 table corner. So rare. An ICON of Middlebury. Be sure to save room for complimentary chocolate milk from a local farm. (That's great! Who does that?) The best!!. Do not miss this place. You find good food and a fabulous place to eat it.“

4.2 Good106 Reviews