26 Best Ice Cream Shops near Bainbridge Island

“Awesome ice cream, great service. Not a whole lot of seating, but worth a walk to if you are taking a ferry ride and going to stop for a treat.

My kids did not like the cookie cones. They were way too thick and hard to even eat, we ended up throwing that part away.

Dietary restrictions: Dairy and vegan options available.“

“Generous portions, friendly and clean atmosphere, and really yummy ice cream.“

“Amazing service and delicious sandwiches!!! Highly recommend!“

“It was my birthday and I ordered a split scoop of two seasonals and it was amazing. The scooper was so nice and gave it to me free of charge! Made my day! I’ve always loved going here, and I try to make it down here at least one a month to try the seasonal flavors. Fantastic Service. She was so sweet and engaging! 5 stars!“

“What a great, local establishment. You can’t go wrong with any of the sandwiches (the ham salad and the Irish breakfast sandwiches are my favorite). So many flavors of ice cream...all homemade. Locally made chocolates and an amazing assortment of European treats. The owners are so sweet and kind and their staff is always friendly and serves with a smile. Highly recommend (and take a half gallon of ice cream home with you)!“

“Was excited to see you at Celebrate Woodinville and after enjoying a Forest Berry cone even more excited to you opening in Woodinville at the Schoolhouse District.“

“We had a blast today!!!🍨🍦“

“My wife and I decided to visit this place after grabbing a bite nearby a few minutes away. We drove past it a few weeks ago during our first trip to West Seattle, and we were excited to come back on our next visit. The ice cream was delicious, and they had good options for my wife, who is on a gluten-free diet. Overall, it was a wonderful way to celebrate our anniversary this past Sunday.“

“Seattle Sorbets is hands-on my fave sorbet! It's DELICIOUS and I love knowing I'm supporting a locally owned business! Every flavor, from champagne orange to raspberry merlot, is delectable. The perfect treat on hot and cold days alike.“

“We booked Nutty Squirrel to cater our wedding dessert in May, and we were so happy we did! The cart was adorable, the staff were friendly and attentive (even suggesting that my husband and I pose for a picture scooping the gelato, which is precious), and the gelato was absolutely delicious. We are still getting comments about how much people loved having the gelato cart there -- people flocked to it and went back for seconds. We would highly recommend booking Nutty Squirrel for your event!“

“This is THE best beach food you’ll ever have. Creative, flavorful, modern eats. The view and the owners can’t be beat. Sandwich and poffertjes were amazing as always.“

“2 years ago due to health I became a pescatarian and look for quality vegetarian, vegan options. Of the many things I miss at the top of the list was a good pepperoni pizza. I have tried all vegetarian, vegan versions. Last night my son and daughter-in-law brought me to MOTO. I ordered the vegan pepperoni pizza. The first bite made me literally want to cry. This was the best pepperoni pizza of ANY kind I have eaten in my considerably long life! Thank you Lee, Nancy, and the entire MOTO crew! I cannot possibly provide a high enough recommendation, this is the alpha and omega of pizza!“

“I have no idea why this place doesn’t have more reviews or higher ratings because this was hands down the best shaved ice I’ve ever had. I’ve been to countless spots from Hawaii to California, and this easily makes my top five. The shop owners were incredibly kind and still welcomed us even though they were closing in five minutes. The texture of the ice was perfect, and the toppings were super generous. I wish I lived closer because I’d be here every week.

In the photo I got the mango shaved ice bingsu. So so good!“

“Just tried Acme Valley for the first time. It is easily the best ice cream I’ve ever had and I hope that our local Whole Foods continues to carry it! Well done!“

“5* good service nice people“

“Generous portions, friendly and clean atmosphere, and really yummy ice cream.“

“best yum chocolatly goodness in my mouth yum goopy yum

Vegetarian options: only vehicles vegetation

Dietary restrictions: high protien

Parking: very handy and handsome vallet

Kid-friendliness: no kids

Wheelchair accessibility: i very mych dislike the ramp“

“great coffee and great service!“

“This place is so cozy and vibe-y for a sweet treat after a long day! The staff is friendly and welcoming, and offer samples if you aren’t sure about what flavor you want! I definitely recommend the matcha, aztec chocolate, and banana/cake ice cream! (i forget the actual name, something with pudding?)“

“Gracie always makes the best lattes! She’s able to customize a drink to the exact vibe I’m going for that day. Her latte art on this oat milk latte is beautiful, too!“

“this is the best ice cream I've ever had and I'm not an ice cream person but I am now!!!!! dark elf and berry battle are amazing 👏“

“I ordered the "Ring of Fire" sandwich online and picked it up. The order was ready on time, and it tasted delicious. The chedar jalapeños bagel paired well with the siracha mayo, turkey, and bacon. Will definitely be ordering this sandwich again.“

“😋 some good tasting 🧁 deserts“

“My mom and I stopped by for a quick lunch and found their environment somewhat vintage and charming. You get to enjoy the breeze off the water, outdoor seating, fresh air, and friendly employees. A simple menu that is tasty, albeit minimal.“

“This cool little mom & pop burger and seafood joint with great food at a reasonable cost. Plus they got ice cream which is nice bonus.
I'm not sure if mom and pop have any employees, I've only seen what I assume is a husband and wife duo knocking out some delicious food.
If the sun is out and/or it's the weekend, it's probably going to be busy, otherwise food comes out fairly quick. If I don't stop for a bite, I'll usually grab a cone and a coke.“