24 Best Pizza Restaurants in Bellingham

“Great atmosphere, friendly staff, very popular. but don't order a pizza! worst I ever had. should have taken more note of all the great reviews - not one about a great pizza. To be fair all the pasta dishes looked exceptional.“

“Great pizza great sandwiches the best hospitality always will be a customer!!!!❤️“

“The best pizza you can eat is at Natalinos!!!! I recommend the California -I couldnt get enough! my whole family fell in love with the pizza and we will be back!“

“We ate outside on the patio while the street fair was going on. It was a lovely day. Highlight of my meal was the Pear Elderflower Collins. Very delicious. Pricey food for what you received, though the food was good. We had some dietary restrictions due to allergies, but Ayla, our server corrected the mistake just in time! The Cure Square Large Pizza was the favorite. I would come back again.

Parking: Sometimes you get lucky and find a free parking space, like we did!

Wheelchair accessibility: The streets can get steep. I had a knee injury and it was a challenge walking. Steps lead up to the restaurant, not sure if they have an easier access. Parking is very limited.“

“SO delicious!!!
We got the Plant-based Tikka Masala pizza and were pleasantly surprised with not only how well the flavors tasted in pizza form, but also with how good the plant-based toppings tasted. The spice level was also perfect; a medium was hot enough to taste, but mild enough not to light my tongue on fire.

The only cons are that it is a little spendy and the food does take a little while to prep and cook. HOWEVER, I do not feel like we waited too long (as someone who's worked in pizza before), and I appreciate being able to order an entirely vegan pizza with so much care put into it, so the price was worth it.

Highly recommend trying (*￣∇￣*)“

“This place does pizza so differently from other spots in town and it's AWESOME! Love that you can either get a whole pie or individual slices and love how fun the different menu items are. I never would have thought to put HUMMUS of all things on a pizza, but their hummus + goat cheese pizza is easily one of my top 10 things to eat here in town. Also, they have a baller cocktail menu and the crew there is always so welcoming and fun to visit with. 10/10!“

“The food here is outstanding, so very delicious! The staff is also outstanding, very friendly and attentive. There is a beautiful outdoor area to eat and it was wonderful. It's wooded around it with lots of birds, excellent bird-watching. I highly recommend this place!

Dietary restrictions: The gluten-free pasta is always so good, you cannot tell the difference. And they are very conscious of cross-contamination. It's wonderful.“

“Been going here since it was still pizza pipeline. Always fond memories. Excellent beer selection and I love the pizza. Only downside is the owner is a bit of a weird guy. Tends to make women a little uncomfortable. Nothing major, just throws off those creepy vibes pretty hard.“

“They have so many fun options for pizza, sooo delicious. We had trouble choosing between 3 awesome looking ones and the waiter told us we could split a pizzas down the middle and get two! Turned out amazing, best of both worlds and the atmosphere is amazing. Food also came out pretty fast and drinks looked really good.“

“Fantastic pizza and atmosphere! Chicago Tavern style pizza has made its way to Bellingham and I couldn’t be happier!“

“This place is lowkey a silent sleeper because I feel like more people should know about how awesome Greene's is! Breakfast, lunch, dinner; they're all an option! Great pizza and delicious breakfast/brunch options! Love that they're in the part of town that's nestled right between south/central Bellingham (aka the Sunnyland Neighborhood), and everything on their menu is a hit. Menu Faves: Biscuts & Gravy, Breakfast Burrito, Sunnyland Scramble, Chicken & Waffles, Huevos Rancheros“

“What can I say? We went in for lunch expecting a typical pizza joint....were we ever mistaken. We ordered several appetizers to try as much as we could for lunch. Everything was elevated just that right amount. Calling this Sliced is doing the restaurant an injustice. We will definitely be back. Salads, brushetta, kids pasta, risotto, and meatball sliders were simply delicious. Looking forward to date night with my wife.“

“The fellow who made my pizza yesterday (August 31st at about 5pm) did an excellent job. When I said extra pineapple, he DID NOT mess around! Great service from the whole team. I drive in from Canada to get MOD pizza because this is the closet location to me in Vancouver.“

“I love getting pizza from this place. Being a college student, you can't exactly afford a $40 pizza which is one of the only ways you'll get a better pizza. So coming here is a good choice. It's a good deal and the pizza is pretty good too.“

“Created my custom pizza perfectly, unlike other pizza places. I'm lactose intolerant so I get pepperoni pizzas without the cheese, which is surprisingly hard to get these days. Only ever had one wrong order and they fixed it immediately. My grandma says their sauce causes a little more heartburn than other pizza sauces, so eat in moderation if you're prone to heartburn.“

“I want to honor and thank the man at Bakerview Papa Murphy's on Tuesday, August 20, 2024. I ordered a $13.99 pizza over the phone on that date. I wanted a couple of extra toppings, but the person on the phone assured me it would still be $13.99. When I got to Papa Murphy's to pick it up, it rang up over $19.00. I told the man at the counter I thought I'd been told it would be $13.99, but I apologized, telling him that I'd been feeling very scattered lately as my mom had just passed away. He turned around, took the pizza, handed it to me & told me to take it. I insisted on paying for it, but he insisted and told me that his grandfather had recently passed away too and that he had the authority to do this for me. I did not get his name, but I was absolutely overwhelmed at such kindness. Thank you so much to this person. Please be assured that I will pay this kindness forward someday.“

“This place used to be a vibe. You come in drunk and needing a slice and you could always count on different options every night. I was sad to be greeted by a screen and to see there wasn’t any fun combos. The pizza came out so hot, we couldn’t eat it for good while. Overall sad to see this place lose its touch.“

“We are long-time customers! Convenient way to have a pizza night... order online, pickup when ready from the 'to go' rack (staff is super friendly), grab a salad kit next door from Trader Joes, come home and bake, and "DINNER's READY!" :-) All is good, including my budget!

Dietary restrictions: The gluten free pizza is very good!“

“First time visiting this place. Almost would say it a hidden gem. It's kind of out of the way of moat conventional eatery or brew pub areas. Was pleasantly surprised at the large selection of beer not just in their enormously large coolers but also on tap as well. They also have pizzas on-site that are extremely tasty. If you have not tried it out yet, you should.“

“Ordered the Philly Cheesesteak pizza with Spinach and feta bread sticks. It was delivered so fast and it was still hot. Very fresh and delicious ingredients. I’m traveling and have to say this is the best dominoes I’ve eaten so far!! Great job team!“

“Cozy quaint place, definately the tastiest pizza I've had since getting here to Bellingham. There are a couple of fun arcade games. A new one with hundreds I think of games within it, like Galaga, Pac Man, Donkey Kong and the like. Analog games on the shelves too, I Love that.“

“I've been a customer for 10 years. Many people worked here, but I do not remember any occasion to be unsatisfied by their work or attitude. Always respectful, smiley, friendly. Of course happened minor mistakes like a wrong sauce, but fixed momentarily. One time needed to wait 20 minutes longer but I saw those orders occupying entire desk. They do their best to make all customers satisfied. Drive through could be a little better, sometimes a delay about a couple minutes before asking. Delivery - no complains. In the waiting area inside a little weird feeling due to architectural decisions, like too tight and hard to hear and see if your order is ready. One thing I observed recently and do not like - the tips request during online purchase. How can I make a decision if service has not been provided yet?

Parking: About 6 spaces in front and usually 2-3 on left side.“

“Extremes was just steps from the Holiday Inn Express! Food was excellent and service from Ryan “Scooter” was amazing!!“

“i asked for no dairy on my breadsticks, and they also kindly left me a note ,mentioning tht the side of icing with cinnamon sticks i got, has dairy in it! <3 super thoughtful, i appreciate the thoroughness and care. kind service & very quick delivery .xx

Dietary restrictions: the manager told me they take allergies very seriously!:) things being handled with attention is so important to having returning customers! ~
—the cinnamon sticks are vegan and the breadsticks can be, if you call and ask for it to be made dairy-free. (they remove parmesan topping) <3“