50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Newcastle

“Great food and beer... amazing service!“

“I keep going back to this location, even though it’s a couple miles further. The pizza toppings are always generous and I always get a greeting even if I’m coming to pull my app order off the rack. I will continue to do business with a location that shows they really want to earn my business.“

“We ordered an extra large pizza and was on our way to pick it up. Unfortunately, as we got onto the freeway, the car overheated. After dealing with that fiasco, we were very late to pick up our pizza. When we got there, we apologized and explained what happened. The kind staff offered to remake our pizza for us free of charge! Unable to wait, we started devouring the pizza in the car. It’s phenomenal! Absolutely wonderful! The funny thing is, they actually gave us the “old” one by mistake and gave us the other pizza. We ended up with 2 extra large pizzas and very happy tummies. Thank you for the great customer service, delicious pizza and turning our horrible day around. We’re certainly coming back for more! ❤️“

“This New Castle location is the best Mod experience that we have had. I don't normally do reviews like this but, we are huge Mod consumers with one only a couple of minutes from our house that has disappointed to many times. New Castle is going to be our new regular Mod stop even though it is about 20 minutes away.“

“Authentic, fresh, and entirely delicious. The homemade cannelloni pasta noodles and filling were absolute perfection! Fantastic marinara! And the pizza… amazing. So much for leftovers! And I haven’t even mentioned the kindness of all of the staff. Can’t wait to come back to this gem!“

“Love the Jazz vibes, the artwork, and the people. Solid and creative pizzas, but the shining star is their bartender/mixologist. Unpretentious, but maybe the best cocktails in a multiple mile radius. Would definitely come back again for the mixed drinks.“

“Great service and clean environment and the customer service was top notch i 100% will tell people about this place the food was OMG so good best pizza in salem dallas and Monmouth/independence“

“The service is excellent and the ambiance can't be beat for an outdoor street side restaurant. The food is the real attraction though, ESPECIALLY on Sundays when the offer their special 18" New York Style pizza which I can say is on par if not better than some of the best NY Style Pizzas that even NY City offers!!!“

“Super fun place with hospitable fun staff! The staff are absolute troopers and super ninjas with entertaining personalities. And the food was 10/10 stars, absolutely delectable and I wanted to basically lick off my plate haha. You’ll need to be patient because they’re understaffed (not their fault, it’s the same as many other places!!!). 100% worth the wait. Great atmosphere and well decorated. located by a beautiful park with pretty old growth trees.“

“We ate at the Bellevue restaurant! We are truck drivers and go all over the country. This is the BEST Pizza we have ever had! We ordered the Agog Primo with roasted garlic. The crust was perfect crispy and light! BRAVO!! 5 Stars“

“Amazing find on the way to SeaTac. The fusion idea works great and the sauce/crust/toppings ratio was perfect on our vegan pie. We got the samosas for breakfast before our early flight since everything at the airport will be closed. We'll be back every time we have a flight and highly recommend visiting this Best of 2025 Google Review awardee.“

“Waiter forgot to put in one persons order but there was enough food without it“

“Omg fave new pizza spot. Ordered cheeky chicken ranch pizza & bbq wings. Omg delicious flavors that melt in your mouth from the first bite. They provided an extra bag with additional condiments. It's thoughtful because not every restaurants includes them. Forget any chain pizza make this your new spot. Won't regret it. Plus the delivery person had such a great smile and attitude. Thank you for excellent 1st time customer experience. Will definitely be ordering in the future and referring ppl here.“

“We went there by a friend recommendation and I couldn’t believe we just discovered this place. All their pizzas are freshly baked. I especially like their Indian style pizza. Best in the town. The place is not that big. Only couple tables to dine in. It does take about 20mins for pizza to be ready. I would order early if you don’t want to wait there.
The owner is super nice and helpful. My kid fell asleep while we were eating there. He was very patient with us and offered to heat up the pizza when he saw my son woke up.
This is a great local place that we’ll definitely come back more!“

“The pizza, beer and service is 👌“

“Delicious and fresh food. Great wait staff too. Highly recommend it!“

“Mercato is one of the best pizza spots in the Bellevue/Seattle area. The pizza is incredibly soft and light, and it doesn’t feel heavy at all — likely due to the high-hydration dough, which makes it easier to digest.

We tried the margherita and mushroom pizzas, and both were really enjoyable. Overall, it made for a great date-night experience. The restaurant itself is very small, probably around 10 tables, which gives it a cozy and intimate vibe.

Reservations are definitely recommended, so be sure to book ahead before you go.“

“Things are more expensive than I remember so don't get desert, technically it's not good anyway, but everything else is awesome or delicious still.

Vegetarian options: I ate here as a vegetarian. No problems with my stomach.“

“Amazing local pizza place! Authentic food, fast service and a nice vibe!“

“Everything tastes awesome and the people are nice.“

“Great place pizza is amazing, and garlic twists are recommended 100% good prices and the staff are very nice people just great place overall“

“I love Pagliacci pizza. It's quick, you can buy either by the slice or a whole pizza. Perfect if you want a quick bite. It's thin crust and one of the best pizza chains in the Seattle area. It's more of a deli than a restaurant. Great, affordable food with a very casual ambiance.“

“Such a good atmosphere! Ben is the nicest person ever and the food is amazing! I personally recommend the pesto pizza🤍“

“My new most favorite, store front, local owned business! I love the salads, the lasagne and the baklava! Thin crust pies are so affordable with FRESH cut veggies 😋“

“I was picking up an Uber eats order and was feeling hangry.. Harris was so kind to me and gave me something to drink, it was so nice I almost jumped over and hugged him! This review is for the service only and the atmosphere. Harris(I think this was his name) was so kind that the next time I order pizza, I will go here because this kind of kindness is rare nowadays! Thank you Harris and see you soon! From Manuel, your local UberEats driver.“

“Don't write many reviews but I felt the need to give this place its credit the tandoori pizza very good crust is crispy pizza not sloppy an droopy and very flavorful I got mozzarella sticks as well those were aslos exceptionally flavorful even the marinara tast flavorful and different from what ive experienced at other pizza spots give it a try i dont think you'll be disappointed it was kinda worth the lil wait as well boss man looked lil tired so I said its no rush but I am happy with the food for sure thank you guys you did well“

“Great spot! Enjoyed Happy Hour very much. Aperol Spritz, Margherita Pizza, Arugula Salad & House Red Wine all great! Service was excellent and attentive. Will be back for sure.“

“My Margherita had beautiful leopard spots, fresh ingredients, and the service was top notch. I look forward to visiting again.“

“I've had pizza from here a few times. Generally a little greasy, but what pizza isn't? Always tasty, and the staff are always friendly. The mall itself can get a little hectic. Look at this beauty of a pizza though! IIRC the name was pesto carofioso?“

“love this place the guys are super cool and the pizza is bomb. you can buy it by the slice and the slices are huge. one of the last good value lunch deals out there“

“I’m from NYC and honestly this place scratched the itch. Very good pizza and the best slice I’ve had since I moved to Seattle - the pepperoni was amazing and they have fountain soda which is a huge plus. If you’re looking for a NY slice away from NY I highly recommend“

“This is a clean and modern location that also has some nice outdoor seating. They'd rather you use a card instead of cash; there's sign on the door that says so. The people who work there are nice. They have beer but it's in cans and they serve it in plastic cups. The pizza is good, especially fresh out of the oven, but it is a bit on the greasy side. Maybe that's just me since I always go with pepperoni. Pagliacci's gets bonus points for having anchovies. I went with a whole pie but next time I'll hit the slice bar. That looked really good. About 5 bucks a slice, so four of those would be cheaper than a whole 11'' pie.“

“Great people and delicious food“

“First time at Cascadia in Rathdrum, amazing service, super clean, pizza was delicious and we loved the crust. We loved how convenient it was to get forks, plates and other items. Was just a great experience. Definitely will be back“

“I have been a long time customer since 2013 at this location. I have had 3 of my kids work there over the years.
It has been really slipping today.
I called my order in for incan make sure they know what I want. Today I asked for extra pineapple and lil to no sause ( it doesn't go over well with my tummy)
Usually no problem but these lasted few times have been very under par.
So please let's get everyone on it. I would hate to go to the one in Fairwood.
Thank you for your time.
The prices are so high. Makes it hard to spend money when this keeps happening.“

“We were visiting Seattle from New York, so we searched on Google and found the best reviews of Shahana Steakhouse. We decided to stop by for the Ramadan Buffet (we visited a couple more restaurants in Seattle), so the best Iftar buffet and the out-of-class service in the Seattle area is here, with excellent customer service and a perfectly managed buffet. I noticed they were crazy busy on weekdays. The restaurant was full of people, and there was a long line; the staff served dates in the line and continued filling the dishes with food, even for families that were joining very late. Everything was fresh and warm, including their delicious pizza, fried chicken, and tikka boti. I loved Shahi Tukray; you must try it if you are there for a buffet. They even served the food at the tables for the customers who came in later. They came to us twice at our table to serve the food. Everything was very well set up, and there was fantastic management. I am going there for suhoor/breakfast and will let you all know about the homemade parathas and omelets. Stay tuned.“

“This location is tiny, so it's best suited to takeout or delivery. With that said, I go out of my way to come here. I have to eat gluten-free (I don't want to) and their gluten-free pizzas are delicious. The rest of my family can eat regular pizza and they assure me that it's their favorite pizza place, hands-down.“

“i had an amazing experience at papa murphy's at 4350 ne 4th st suite c, renton, wa 98059. josh and kiana helped me with my pizza around 7:30 pm and they were fantastic. super friendly and made sure everything was perfect. the pizza was delicious and so easy to bake at home. highly recommend this spot for great service and tasty pizza!“

“I stumbled across this place while walking around University Village Christmas Shopping and ordered a deep dish to go. They had simple and straightforward directions for baking the pie in the oven at home. Wow! This one of the best pizzas we had since relocating to Seattle. A definite must try if you haven’t already.“

“Extremely reasonable prices, it almost feels like I'm scamming them. Got the largr tandoori chicken, paid about $20 including tax and tip. My friend recommended this place to me and I love it. Especially because they're open so late, I work the night shift so its hard to find GOOD food thats open. Eleven out of ten 11/10 amazing. Domino's, Pizza Hut, and Papa John's literally could NEVERRRRR EVERRRRR“

“02/28/25 Brandy was helpful with question for website ordering 1/2 & 1/2 pizzas

02/14/25 We followed the correct cooking instructions this time for the stuffed crust and it was way better than the last time!

12/20/24 next time we will follow cooking instructions better“

“Wonderful to have pizza al taglio in the neighborhood! I’m not aware of any other restaurant in Seattle that does this style of pizza. I came equipped with an actual Roman, and his verdict was “buona.” The pizzas are large enough for 2. The service was fine.“

“I remember coming here once and maybe it just didn't leave an impression at the time, but upon revisiting I cannot express how good the pizza is. You'll have to try it for yourself. Sure the pepperoni may be on the greasy side, but do NOT let that stop you from trying this pie. The sauce is what ultimately left the impression for me. It was sweet in all the right ways a red sauce should be. Staff was great and extremely helpful when it came to making choices. Big kudos.“

“We ate at the Bellevue restaurant! We are truck drivers and go all over the country. This is the BEST Pizza we have ever had! We ordered the Agog Primo with roasted garlic. The crust was perfect crispy and light! BRAVO!! 5 Stars“

“Great and healthy pizza. Love the crust! This is my third visit in one week after tasting my first MOD Pizza last week. I have to order one for my wife since she loves thin crust pizza. The taste of you pizza suit us best since it is not too salty and overwhelming. Will definitely try the rest of your menu soon.“

“It’s true what they say. This gets close to east coast pizza. Don’t mean to compare, but that’s my frame of reference for “good” pizza (Deep dish doesn’t count, get mad). They shine on their own. They have something special in that sauce and dough. You will not be disappointed.“

“We love this place and haven’t had anything we didn’t like!! Great food. However….. make sure you dress warm… they have blankets you can throw over you but it is still pretty chilly in there.“

“Update I appreciate the response and I think the first time I came was just a bad busy moment. Overall I think this place is great. Still hard to find parking tho.

Needs 3 more workers. Way over worked. Asked me to use the app when I called. Got here on time. Still not even close to ready. It’s a shame.

Ultra gentrified. And now it’s too confusing. Where do I get my food. From Jack sprat? From the pizza place?“

“We ate at the Bellevue restaurant! We are truck drivers and go all over the country. This is the BEST Pizza we have ever had! We ordered the Agog Primo with roasted garlic. The crust was perfect crispy and light! BRAVO!! 5 Stars“