15 Best Pizza Restaurants in Renton

“love this place the guys are super cool and the pizza is bomb. you can buy it by the slice and the slices are huge. one of the last good value lunch deals out there“

“I was picking up an Uber eats order and was feeling hangry.. Harris was so kind to me and gave me something to drink, it was so nice I almost jumped over and hugged him! This review is for the service only and the atmosphere. Harris(I think this was his name) was so kind that the next time I order pizza, I will go here because this kind of kindness is rare nowadays! Thank you Harris and see you soon! From Manuel, your local UberEats driver.“

“I have been a long time customer since 2013 at this location. I have had 3 of my kids work there over the years.
It has been really slipping today.
I called my order in for incan make sure they know what I want. Today I asked for extra pineapple and lil to no sause ( it doesn't go over well with my tummy)
Usually no problem but these lasted few times have been very under par.
So please let's get everyone on it. I would hate to go to the one in Fairwood.
Thank you for your time.
The prices are so high. Makes it hard to spend money when this keeps happening.“

“Great tasting pizza! Did not disappoint! Great delivery service too! I ordered a bunch of pizzas for our boys soccer team and they were kind enough to honour the online discount in person as the website wasn’t working at the time. Thank you!“

“i had an amazing experience at papa murphy's at 4350 ne 4th st suite c, renton, wa 98059. josh and kiana helped me with my pizza around 7:30 pm and they were fantastic. super friendly and made sure everything was perfect. the pizza was delicious and so easy to bake at home. highly recommend this spot for great service and tasty pizza!“

“We flew across the country to see our daughter who currently lives in WA, and the first food we ordered was Smoking Monkey in Renton. Delivery was at least 25 minutes past the stated time, the potato skin app my daughter ordered wasn't included, and our large pizza was too doughy to eat. We realized the drinks were missing too but my family member was able to run outside and catch the driver before he left as they were still in the vehicle. We immediately called and we were told we would be getting a refund for the skins and one pizza, and nothing has happened. I have also emailed several times. This occurred on Aug. 8th. Very disappointing!!“

“Everyone there is super nice and they have great food the cook and the waitresses are super friendly and the regulars that go in are also super friendly and will chat with you definitely recommend going there“

“Next time you decide to have papa Murphy's you gotta try subbing out there red sauce for the garlic white sauce...... Yummmmm..... Mmmmmmmmm...... My new favorite on almost any pizza, ( personally I wouldn't try it on the hawaiian,but that's just me) it's delicious ?!!!!

Vegetarian options: Vegetarian options available ?

Kid-friendliness: Has mini ? pizzas in its own little cute cardboard pizza box?“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Round Table Pizza will always have my heart. I’m in Manila now and honestly… who do I have to kill to get an RTP here? 😩

Even in a slightly strange location (corporate mall vibes), the pizza still slaps. Quality cheese, real toppings, that classic crust—and they even brought back the buffet, which is legendary behavior.

This is exactly why people need to support high-quality pizza joints in the U.S. Too many places like this have closed, replaced by cheap, fast pizza made with fake ingredients and zero soul. RTP proves that quality still matters.

If you’ve got one near you, don’t take it for granted. Go eat there.“

“Great local spot, haven't ever had a bad meal --- from breakfast to burgers to pizza. Yum!!!“

“Lol this is fat lol“

“This is one of the most amazing locations Olive, Christian, & Zoi are beyond friendly. They are always smiling and bringing great energy. The store is clean. I can tell they take pride in their jobs. Love this location and the team.

9.16.25 update
I cannot add a new review. So big up to Mario and crew. I’ve been studying and starving. They really came through with the customer service and speed.“

“I was trying to put an order in for the same pizza twice and accidentally added onions instead of olives. I went inside to see if they could change it, even though it was already in the oven!! They had no problem remaking the pizza I actually wanted!!! Thank you so much!!“

“Really nice early dinner with the Family. service was top notch as was the food. Gustoso.“

“Standard little Caesar’s location. Little run down and dingy. Seems to be a common theme in the 1/2 doz I’ve visited

Food was ready around the time it was promised.

Didn’t see a single person when I walked in. Entered my number, picked up my pizza and walked out.

Pizza was good though. I did reheat it in the oven for 5 min at 350.“