16 Best Italian Restaurants near Sumner

“There were four of us for lunch. The atmosphere is Italian and casual. Unfortunately, the background .music is not in the background, making it difficult to talk. I asked the staff to turn down the music, and they did a bit, but loud music is the norm here.
I ordered the Mistra salad, and it was good. However, the housemate dress was BAD. Seemed to be almost exclusively olive oil. They did bring a ranch, which was fine. I paid an extra $6,50 for a small chicken breast, which had good flavor but was pretty dry.
My wife had tomato basil soup and 1/2 turkey panini. She said her food was very good. The servers were excellent and a bright spot in lunch.
We will probably come again at some point.“

“We found Aversano's during COVID times and haven't gone anywhere else locally for Italian fare since. We love them - the food is always good and there is always lots of it. We love picking up and eating in the comfort of our home however, we enjoy going in as the the feel of the restaurant is like being at home!“

“Our neighborhood go-to for a reason. My wife and I live nearby and Verrazano's has become one of those places we just keep coming back to. It's the kind of Italian restaurant that feels like a real find — upscale enough for a special evening but comfortable enough to be a regular.

I always order the spaghetti and a Caesar salad, and both are consistently excellent. The spaghetti is classic, done right, with generous portions. The Caesar is crisp and well-dressed. And don't skip the grilled garlic bread — it's incredible. Simple dishes, but that's where you really see the quality of a kitchen, and Verrazano's nails it every time.
The drinks are a highlight too. I'll usually have a Manhattan and an Old Fashioned over the course of dinner, and the bar does a great job with both. My wife rotates between a Moscow Mule and a glass of Browne's Cabernet, and she's always happy. It's a well-curated cocktail and wine program that doesn't get enough credit.

The views of Puget Sound and the Olympics from the deck are a huge bonus — especially during golden hour. Add in attentive, personable service and a warm atmosphere with white tablecloths and you've got everything you need for a great night out.

If you're in the Federal Way area and love Italian food, don't sleep on this place. Five stars.“

“good food and service from regular menu. for brunch the mushroom fritata was a bit disappointing. it lacked mushrooms and presented as more of as potato dish than a fritata“

“Best service and most fun in a while. Kellie was our server in south hill. She was so much fun pointed out a better deal for a dinner to take to our elderly neighbor and liked my boyfriends jokes.“

“Delicious food, great happy hour and such a nice server“

“Mama Stortini’s has amazing service. Our server Gabe was awesome. The food was wonderful. Justine the manager came over and introduced herself to everyone and wanted to make sure we all had everything we needed.“

“33 years ago, my new wife introduced me to Vinces. In her previous marriage, Vinces in Renton was the family go to. One bite of Vinces pizza and I was hooked. The only negative is Vince's pizza has spoiled me to every other pizza place in the area. Vinces pizzas are Neapolitan style......much, much better (in my humble opinion) than any other pizza's. Vince's is the place our family always meets for special occasions. We have always been treated very well. My 9 year old grandson told me Vince's pepperoni pizza is his favorite.....it happens to be my favorite too. Writing this I'm starting to crave a pizza! Their other menu offerings are equally excellent. A year or so ago, we stopped for lunch. Out of the blue, I ordered one of their Italian Hero's. I will say it was the absolute BEST Sub/Hero/Grinder I had ever eaten. If you have not been to Vinces, so yourself a favor and try it. You might find you have a new favorite pizza/pasta place. A++“

“What a great place to eat and be merry! Service and food were top notch! With a very comfortable positive atmosphere and good company it's really hard to beat! Will do it again for sure!! Enjoy it for your self soon, you won't be disappointed!!
SkottySez“

“Food is amazing, I had the Wild Boar Bolognese and it was really good“

“Loved the amazing service and high quality to brick oven that Zach’s mobile truck was able to provide. Can’t wait to try out more!“

“I use to come here many many moons ago and it was always good then most of them all closed an I had for gotten about them. But rediscoverd Pizza Pizza after we moved back from Eastern WA. Hands down best pizza spot on the south end! It's a little more pricey then your big chain joints but worth it. This is now our go to pizza place. I can't speak to the atmosphere as I have yet to dine-in but it seems like a nice chill place. Pizza crust is soft, chewy, and crispy. No skimping on the toppings or cheese which we love and appreciate. Our bread sticks were a bit in the dark side for our last order but it was a highly busy game day buy I still can't complain it was good and the kids still ate them.
Side note to the ranch lovers.....the ranch is a YES lol if you know you know.“

“food was delicious and the service was great.“

“Best pizza in town. 5 stars out out 5 stars.“

“Ate here the other day. Their pizzas are very good. A little pricey, but generally worth it. What I do not understand is their pricing. We ordered a Daily Double: any 2 pizzas for $28. But on the receipt it says $28.98. Huh? was there some fine print somewhere that I didn’t notice and was not brought to my attention by the host? The pint I ordered was listed as $8 on the menu, but I was charged $8.28. Same with the salad. What the menu showed as $8 was actually $8.28. Can anyone explain this to me? It was generally a good experience, you do have to place your order at the window and go pick it up like at a fast food joint. So the service was lacking. But doing it yourself saves on the tip. I just don’t understand the pricing.“

“The reheating of the food in the microwave makes the dough taste funny almost inedible.
I travel the country this is the only one I have been to that uses the microwave for reheating.
The boss Lady has made sure I'm taken care of thank you for making things right“