18 Best American Restaurants in Baraboo

“This is my favorite restaurant! I love the home-cooked food, the pie, and fresh squeezed orange juice. Whenever I have family and friends visit, I take them there. Serving breakfast until 2pm is great so we don’t miss all of our breakfast favorites, especially the cheesy hash brown casserole.“

“Best food in Baraboo (tied w/ Cheeze Factory). Something for everyone including vegetarians and pescatarians like myself. Brilliant specials/dessert, amazing service, warm inviting/relaxed atmosphere“

“Ate here Friday evening for our Anniversary Dinner. Table was ready and waiting for us. Service was great, atmosphere wonderful with dimmed lighting and candles on the tables. The food was 👌, no complaints. So good! The drinks were delicious. Recommend the maple old fashion. They have the drink recipes in bags for purchase as well. We took home the maple old fashioned bag and made them last night.“

“I was very disappointed in the fish sandwich I ordered last night. The bottom of the bun was so soggy it fell apart and was unable to be eaten. The fish it's self was cold. Not a good experience. I wish I had taken a picture.“

“Stumbled across this gem as we were shopping in the area. Delicious food, clean & fast, friendly service. We had spaghetti and a cheeseburger; very happy with our selections!“

“I had an issue and the owner Brittany followed up and made it right :) very happy with the service“

“Wonderful Friday night fish fry. Excellent salad bar, full service bar, friendly staff, generous portions of blue gill and perch and the full rack of ribs was done to perfection! The view over the Baraboo Golf Course is topping on the cake! One note... if you want to eat on a Friday night you'll need a reservation!!“

“Fun environment, great service & delicious burgers!“

“It was a pretty penny for a shake. They really hyped up the waffle shake and it was okay. I would not get it again. The mug is kind of cool I guess as a souvenir, but a chocolate shake without all the stuff and it would probably have been better than what. This was an interesting idea and concept but just wasn't that “

“I just had to take a moment to rave about one of my absolute favorite spots: Mac's! If you haven't had the chance to experience this culinary gem, let me tell you, you're missing out on something truly special. First off, let’s talk about the mac and cheese. I mean, it’s not just any mac and cheese; it’s a creamy, cheesy, dreamy bowl of goodness that warms your heart and soul. Each bite is a perfect blend of pasta enveloped in a rich, velvety cheese that just beckons you to come back for more. Whether you like it classic or want to spice it up with some tantalizing toppings, Mac's has got you covered! Honestly, if I could eat this every day, I absolutely would. Now, let’s not forget about the Melts! These delightful creations are like a warm hug in sandwich form. The crispy exterior gives way to a gooey, cheesy interior that just melts in your mouth. Each Melt is crafted with love and packed with flavor, making it impossible to resist. I often find myself daydreaming about my next visit, already planning which Melt to try next. I genuinely feel like I should be their spokesperson at this point because I am always craving Mac's! No joke—if you were to ask me what my top recommendation is for anyone visiting the area, Mac's would be at the top of my list, hands down. It’s the kind of place that feels like home, where you can gather with friends and family over delicious food and create unforgettable memories. The atmosphere is always buzzing with excitement, and the staff are incredibly friendly and attentive. It’s clear that everyone here is passionate about what they do, and that makes all the difference. Whether you're dining in or grabbing takeout, the experience is always top-notch. So, fellow food lovers, if you're looking for a place that serves up ridiculously good comfort food, look no further than Mac's! Trust me; your taste buds will thank you.“

“First time trying Culver since they don't have that in the city. The commercials are right! Their burgers are amazing. From my parents to my kids, they all love them! Definitely recommended! No pictures because we were really hungry lol 😆“

“The BEST food in town. Stopped in today for lunch! Outstanding! I would highly recommend. Amber has an excellent menu, and fresh choices. 5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️stars!“

“Very good food. If you are in the area go! Mushroom Swiss and bacon cheese burger was great!!“

“I love visiting this restaurant when I’m in the dells. Whether it’s for the food, shopping or just the experience with staff. I have never had a bad meal, the service has always been great and the shopping in retail is always a treat. I highly recommend.“

“The staff is amazing and make you feel like family! Food is absolutely delicious. Atmosphere is homing, so I give the overall experience amazing! Once you become a regular or Star working here, you become part of the family! Can't wait for our family to continue growing!!!“

“they give you new York strip instead of rib eye,and say it's the same .NOT even close.. we had a digger for a waitress. how about crackers for your soup ? it did not get any better. this place used to be really good ,they overcooked the prime rib or I would of had that“

“Quiet evening on 2/19 for some pizza, melt burger, and Greek wrap (which was unique and great). Food was hot, fast, and kids liked their pizza better than Buffalo Phils. Good service. Easy and accommodating if staying at Wilderness/Glacier Lodge. We also were the only ones there for a bit so our order was processed right away.“