11 Best American Restaurants near Poynette

“Great staff, food, and atmosphere! A true Wisconsin family owned gem!“

“I was at Anchors the night people came in to redeem a $25.00 pull tab for the second time. The pull tab was already registered and paid out. The people must be really hard up if they are dumb enough to try and redeem the card a second time. Look out local bars, they may try it at your establishment also. So sad. Good thing the workers at Lakeside are being thorough. The criminals should be charged with attempted theft!!“

“We reserved and held our son's rehearsal dinner in the dining room. The staff did an excellent job! They were so efficient and accommodating! The food was great! The pricing more than fair! Highly recommend! Thank you so much!“

“First time trying Culver’s, and if you’re traveling through an area that has one, I’d honestly recommend stopping at least once to try it out. It definitely feels a bit different from the typical fast-food experience, with a much larger variety of burgers, sides, desserts, and frozen treats available.

My spouse and I tried the Swiss Melt along with their limited-time burger offering. Taste-wise, both burgers were actually pretty good. I’d personally rate them around a 7.5/10 for flavor. The only downside was presentation. When the food came out, it honestly did not look very appetizing visually, probably closer to a 4/10 on appearance.

The fries were also extremely salty, so if you’re watching your sodium intake, that’s something to keep in mind.

Now for the highlight: the desserts. I had the salted caramel milkshake, and it was absolutely delicious. Easily the best part of the meal and something I would definitely order again. Their frozen dessert menu alone is worth checking out.

The restaurant was very busy, which usually says a lot about local popularity, and service moved along well despite the crowd. Overall, a solid experience and a fun stop if you’ve never tried Culver’s before.“

“Even with a completely full bar, the bartender, Madison, stayed calm, efficient, and on top of everything. Drinks came out quickly, orders were accurate, and she still made everyone feel welcomed and taken care of. It’s impressive to see someone handle that level of volume while keeping such a positive attitude. Great service and great energy — definitely one of the reasons I’ll be coming back!“

“Best little hometown restaurant. I ❤️ it. So glad we found it.“

“Great food, great service, reasonable prices, and friendly staff!“

“great little bar with a home town feel.“

“The food is amazing for such a cheap price. Haven’t found prices this good anywhere in the area. Very friendly place with a nice atmosphere, 100% recommend trying this place!“

“Be it food or service both are top notch.“

“My family and I come here around the holidays every year and we’re always taken care of. We have three households, 11 kids total, basically a circus, but Kyle and his team are always friendly and extremely accommodating. Thank you, A&W for making our dining experience special each year.“