19 Best American Restaurants in Middleton

“We've eaten here several times and it's terrific! It's off the beaten path in the middle of a residential block near the intersection of University and Parmenter in Middleton. Good food, big portions, friendly crew. They probably have something you'll like . . .☺️“

“awesome cheese curds and everything else!!!“

“We LOVE this restaurant. We make sure we stop every time we are in the area. We especially love the cinnamon roll pancakes, the homemade toast, and the hashbrowns--delicious! The portions are huge, too. You will not leave here hungry. I also love diners with old-school atmosphere and this place hits the mark. Today we tried three of their baked goods, and the cream cheese danish was phenomenal. It's always packed (others think it's delicious, too), but we've never waited long for a seat. It's just all-around fantastic.“

“I visited for my first time last night. Service was excellent, attentive but not overly so, and the food was on point. There are some great things happening in that kitchen—everything was delicious! Thanks for a memorable meal and a fabulous first impression!👏🏽“

“excellent food friendly service!“

“Great service after the late Badger game! Burgers were delicious and manager staff were so friendly! Thanks to the kitchen crew for making those last two burgers of the night! �“

“Great food. wings, burgers, pizza. Has won Best of Madison. Wonderful atmosphere. Highly recommend.“

“Great food! I order for lunch all the time and their pot roast is so good. Best mashed potatoes around. Their staff is super friendly, helpful and delivery is prompt. My food is always hot when I get it. The added bonus is how reasonably priced their food is. Definitely a place to check out and help to support your local small businesses.“

“Great service! Friendly staff! Wonderful food! Neat and clean environment! Awesome prices!“

“Delicious food, wonderful staff & yummy desserts! Try their homemade soups!“

“If you appreciate history and the beauty of old stonework, you have to visit this supper club/bar. We went last night with my family to celebrate our anniversary. Perhaps a late reservation time wasn't the best idea as the prime rib was gone, in other words, it must have been good. Lovely staff, plenty of seating, so charming how it was decorated in a simple, yet engaging style. My family thoroughly enjoyed their entrees. I had the shrimp and scallops which were perfectly cooked. The only comment I would like to recommend would be a salad and bread included with the meal. My pasta was a bit on the salty side and those inclusions would have made the meal much more palatable. Oh, and I also would like to mention the mixologist as the drinks were unique, delicious if you can say that about a drink, and a great conversation point.“

“Great place to watch a packer game around the holiday. Friendly staff and reasonable prices. Will be back.“

“Friendly locally owned place. One of the oldest buildings in Middleton. Ambience is a bit like drinking in your crazy uncle's basement (i.e. the furnace is in the middle of the room) with strong drinks and good food.“

“Great service. Excellent selection of beer, both can and tap. Our food was very good. Can’t wait to go back!“

“Great service in a very cozy atmosphere. Good mixed drinks and a delicious white cheddar mac & cheese!“

“Great place run by really nice people.“

“Each visit was between the hours of 1:00pm and 6:00pm.

We’re new in town and have visited this bar three times in 1 week. Cindy is fabulous! She will order what she thinks you should eat…LOL. She mistakenly ordered us the ribs and fries basket on our first visit, and they were great! Ribs fall off the bone and fries hit and crispy! That prompted us to visit a second time for a corned beef sandwich (not a Reuben which could be mistaken for Ribs) and a hot Turkey and Swiss. The third visit was a BLT that we split. Definitely filling.

We have found our go to bar in town for watching sports on the tv. If you like to play, there are two pool tables, and two electronic dart boards. Wednesday night in the summer is sand volleyball. Maybe some other things too, but that’s all I know.

Good drinks, Good food, Good Times!“

“I was thinking this Tanners was the same kinda like the one I love in Appleton Wisconsin. I ordered the taco salad but it wasn't in the shell, it was basically a taco appetizer. The beef was little to not much and dry and the dressings offered was not enough for the salad. I enjoyed the service we got, but less again the taco salad was a disappointment. But the onion rings are awesome.“

“it was very nice and relaxing. very clean dining and bathrooms. polite employees and pretty good prices. We enjoyed ourselves 😊“