34 Best American Restaurants near Cross Plains

“Our group tried The Hilltop Supper Club last night and I loved it. We sat at the bar while waiting for our table. I had a sweet brandy old-fashioned. The bartender was friendly and prompt and my drink was excellent. The hostess sat us at our table and our waitress arrived promptly to take drink and appetizer orders. I highly recommend the cheese ball. It's the size of a softball and filled with a variety of herbs. Creamy, flavorful and served with several dozen Townhouse crackers. We also had the dynamite shrimp. They have a very mild kick from the mayo sauce. I'm not a mayo fan and this did not change my mind, but those of us at the table who like mayo thought they were good. For dinner I had the perch fish fry with potatoes au gratin. My first bite of the potatoes was cheesy goodness. I really, really liked these. One of my dining companions felt like there should have been more and I would certainly have eaten more, but I thought the portion size was good. There were six perch fillets. The perch was delicious. I would have preferred a lighter batter, but I would definitely order this again. For dessert a couple of us ordered ice-cream drinks. They mudslide and the salted caramel. Both was creamy and delicious and I would highly recommend either. I would happily return to the Hilltop. Great experience.“

“Swung through for a late lunch with a small group and couldn’t have been more happy with the experience.

Comfy seating, quick service and delicious food. Patty melt was phenomenal as was the turkey avocado club sandwich, which featured a huge slice of house smoked turkey (not the usual soggy deli meat you find elsewhere).

Would visit again. Very excellent on every level.“

“I would recommend Milwaukee Music Festival in the future and beyond. That would be awesome. I'll give you a 10/10.“

“A huge shoutout to the Cross Plains Culver's team! We were there when the storm sirens went off today. They were so kind and helpful when we all had to go into the basement. We learned there are only a few Culver's that have basements! We waited out the storm and staff was super friendly to my 3-yr old during what could have been a scary experience. When the storm passed they all jumped back into action helping customers and making food. I'll be back thanks to the kindness of the team.“

“We went to Buck & Honeys for brunch yesterday and it was FANTASTIC. The menu offered so many options, something for every craving! Our server John was so friendly and attentive! If you haven’t yet, give it a try! We can’t wait to go back!“

“Hosted a birthday lunch for 24 in the private dining room. Staff was super accommodating and helpful both in planning and day of event. Allowed us in early to decorate and even offered to cut cake and take group photo on deck overlooking the golf course. Everyone enjoyed their meals, even our picky vegetarian!“

“We've eaten here several times and it's terrific! It's off the beaten path in the middle of a residential block near the intersection of University and Parmenter in Middleton. Good food, big portions, friendly crew. They probably have something you'll like . . .☺️“

“We had an absolute blast here with our dogs! The covered, dog-friendly patio was perfect—especially when it started pouring rain. We stayed completely dry and were able to enjoy our visit without missing a beat. The staff were some of the friendliest people we've ever met and made us feel so welcome. We happened to visit while Wish Upon A Wiener was hosting a pop-up, and it was incredible! The hot dogs were huge, absolutely delicious, and have officially become my new favorite. This place is an absolute must-visit, and we'll definitely be back!“

“Delicious food and inviting staff“

“I stopped in for the Wednesday Night Wing Special (10 wings for $10!!) and was NOT disappointed! I'm not usually a fan of smoked meat but they knocked it out of the park with these wings! The wings were a mix of drummies and wings and they were a lot larger than I expected based on the price! Such a great value!! They also have very fun and friendly staff, too!“

“Great food. wings, burgers, pizza. Has won Best of Madison. Wonderful atmosphere. Highly recommend.“

“Friendly! Fast service! Good food!“

“Disappointed with the Jägerschnitzel, but the atmosphere and Fish Fry are top notch. Been here multiple times and will continue to frequent this restaurant.“

“I visited for my first time last night. Service was excellent, attentive but not overly so, and the food was on point. There are some great things happening in that kitchen—everything was delicious! Thanks for a memorable meal and a fabulous first impression!👏🏽“

“my husband i get fish every friday! love the shack!“

“Great service! Friendly staff! Wonderful food! Neat and clean environment! Awesome prices!“

“Stopped in for supper on Friday night. It was close to 8:30 by the time we got there. We both had the deep fried cod. It was outstanding !! Still had the salad bar full, fish was lightly breaded and great service as usual !! Great food and drinks. Highly recommend the prime rib on Saturday night as well. 😋😋“

“The BEST hamburger I have ever had! One night was talking about it in my sleep to my husband! LOL! We live 2 hours away and will make the drive again and again!“

“Super friendly staff, quick service and delicious food.“

“We attended a family birthday gathering of about 28 people. Check this place out! Friendly great service with awesome food menu & bar. I highly recommend!“

“Favorite place to eat!!!!! Thanks for many awesome experiences“

“Fish fry was great. Had shrimp and cod combination grilled with Cajun seasoning and the cheesey potatoes were delicious!“

“I love the food, the atmosphere, and the choices. The home brewed Root beer is second to none.“

“Great food, great staff, nice atmosphere!“

“I like all the different custard flavors. The meals are great. The customer service is Top.Its a friendly and comfortable atmosphere. Very Clean. Don't have to wait long at all for your meal. They are on Top of things! A+++ for sure!!!“

“10/28/23 After attending our our Grandson State Honors Concert stop in to eat. Great service and food. Group of 6 and all enjoyed our food.“

“Great food with large portions, affordable prices and friendly staff make for a real home spun atmosphere. I would definitely recommend giving it a try!“

“It was an easy choice to pick Stone Porch Alehouse for lunch with a friend. Ordered the Nashville Chicken sandwich which was absolutely delicious and hit the spot, the seasonings were spot on and it was fried perfectly. My friend ordered a cheeseburger and fries and hers looked delicious too! Shoutout to Chef Jacob and waiter Cody. I asked Cody to pick a surprise side with my chicken and hers picked the cornbread (Yum!). You can’t go wrong with anything on the menu-it’s all mouth watering and generous portions! I just wish they offered roasted Brussel sprouts! We’ll be back soon!“

“Friendly locally owned place. One of the oldest buildings in Middleton. Ambience is a bit like drinking in your crazy uncle's basement (i.e. the furnace is in the middle of the room) with strong drinks and good food.“

“Great service. Excellent selection of beer, both can and tap. Our food was very good. Can’t wait to go back!“

“Great service in a very cozy atmosphere. Good mixed drinks and a delicious white cheddar mac & cheese!“

“I was thinking this Tanners was the same kinda like the one I love in Appleton Wisconsin. I ordered the taco salad but it wasn't in the shell, it was basically a taco appetizer. The beef was little to not much and dry and the dressings offered was not enough for the salad. I enjoyed the service we got, but less again the taco salad was a disappointment. But the onion rings are awesome.“

“The service was the best. Araceli was amazing server , help us with everything we need , the best GF menu I had so far .. I recommend this place very clean classy .. Barb the manager came and checked on us to make sure we had everything we needed .. very happy and I’m definitely going to be back soon“

“it was very nice and relaxing. very clean dining and bathrooms. polite employees and pretty good prices. We enjoyed ourselves 😊“