Jimmy John's in Baraboo

“Great sandwiches, of course. Loses 1 star because of a small gripe: My pickle is never cut the way I want it. Also, most times I get carry out, so the cleanliness of the store is a non-issue, but it is often a little dirty (just like, leftover crumbs on tables, nothing obscene).“

“I moved to Baraboo a little over a year ago. I really like this Jimmy John’s. They have always gotten my orders right. Everything is always good. Sandwich’s are always fresh.
I have ordered by phone and picked up my order to go and I have sometimes just dropped in and got a sub and ate maybe half of it at the store. I never have had any problems with any of my ordered. I don’t like Mayo or oil. So I always order without those two things. They always have gotten my orders correct for me or for me and my wife. The store is always clean on the inside. They make up the sandwiches pretty freaky fast. I would recommend this place. I saw some negative reviews and that’s u fortunate. But like I said my experiences have always been positive. When I am in the mood for a sub- this is my go to place!“