Jimmy John's in Madison

“Girl, with all the piercings, kind of gave me a hard time because I walked and chose to do a mobile order while I was already there. The app doesn't give a description of what's in a sandwich, so I went to the store first to read what they have in it. The food was good, the dining room is super tiny. Seating sucks. I guess cause it's downtown.“

“Best Jimmy John's in Madison!!! Always been so helpful to our student organization, and Coach and Gabe were especially helpful tonight as we ran into a little issue before our big meeting! They saved us and were so kind about everything. Coach and Gabe are the best, plus they make incredible sandwiches :)“

“A huuuge tip of my hat to Sandwich Superstar, Caspar Uy. He came up with a few "specialty" menu options that make this Jimmy Johns unlike any other in the city and allow for ingredient combinations that I may not have thought of. Vegan options as well!EDIT because I had more time to sit and write this:I've stopped in a number of times as this is a very convenient location to visit while I'm on the job. Recently, however, I've had additional reasons to stop by: Caspar Uy and his clear love of his job. Caspar started sometime this year, and every time we meet, I've left with a smile. He personally hand-crafted a "secret menu" featuring different ingredient combinations that are not all featured on the main menu, This really spices things up and keeps each JJ's visit fresh and enjoyable. He even came up with Vegetarian and Vegan specific sandwiches in addition to the omnivorous ones. He truly goes above and beyond ANY "fast food" employee I have ever met, and is more "there for the customer" in every regard. More than just taking my order, he makes me feel seen, heard, and respected, and it's hard not to notice his dedication to service and wonderful attitude in turn. SERVICE= 1000 stars. Get this kid a raise/promotion STAT

Vegetarian options: Jimmy John's has a lot of veggies to choose from“

“5 stars!! Ive dealt with some frustrations at other Jimmy John’s locations but the experience I had either was 2nd to none. Never met a staff that was so welcoming and excited to be there. Brett in particular greeted me and my wife, and confirmed everything we ordered, and my wife is VERY particular on her order being correct. This location was very clean, easy process, and different from what I’m used to. Not usually compelled to leave a review but this definitely deserved it. Thank you Brett & staff for all you do! Jimmy Johns is lucky to have you“

“Staff was friendly and dare I say "freaky fast"!!

Good sandwich and after 2pm got the combo (Chips and drink) at no extra cost. The BBQ chips are Jimmy Johns branded as are all of there potato chip bags. I couldn't tell the difference from Lays chips, they were great.“