9 Best Pizza Restaurants in Baraboo

“I'm up from Knoxville and the hotel recommended this place. I went the last two nights and the burger was good but the Philly steak was incredible! Staff was helpful and pleasant. You won't be dissatisfied... And it's so inexpensive it's ridiculous! Beer burger and fries only 14$. I couldn't believe it. I'd spend twice that in Knoxville.“

“Absolutely the best Italian!!! We will be telling everyone!“

“As a true Long Island New York transplant to Wisconsin I can always count on consistent fresh hot beautiful pizza that tastes like it came from my neighborhood “Pizza Stop” on Long Island! Thank you for being in Baraboo Wisconsin!“

“Two guys running the place the evening I was there and both very friendly and accommodating and although they did start making the wrong pizza because the name of the pizza was very similar to another one but they immediately offered to make me the right one. And offered to let me have an additional topping with a coupon I had which they certainly did not have to do. But that was just a very nice added bonus. Very cheesy and delicious. I never had a pizza there I didn't like. And the big bonus for some of us people is that they do take food stamps! That's a big bonus, especially for people who are really just scraping by! Wish I knew I was going to be making this review. I would have taken pictures“

“Best breakfast in Baraboo! Tasty, thoughtfully prepared, large portions, friendly staff what more could you ask for?“

“Being completely honest my family has always been a Domino's Family but thanks to Chloe's great customer service in assisting us in flavorful recommendations and the freshly prepared perfectly cooked pizza, pasta, wings and breadsticks we have officially converted!“

“never had a bad pizza and it's better and cheaper than a frozen pizza“

“We went to the pairings dinner April 29, 2025 This event was amazing!!!! Food was excellent, the wine delicious, and the beer was refreshing. So well put together! Can’t wait for the next one!“

“We visited this location during a Friday night dinner rush on 7/19. It was quite busy and the staff was busting their backs to keep up. Although it was so busy it was hard for them to keep up (I’ve def seen way more staff in busy locations like this one so maybe something to consider) they all seemed to keep a smile on their face and were very polite. The variety of pizza was lacking due to so many customer orders on the bar. I think pizza ranch needs to address their special orders policy during such busy hours (maybe limit it if possible). Anyways overall good experience!“