24 Best Pizza Restaurants near Deforest

“Be it food or service both are top notch.“

“Went in tonight at a little after 5pm to a completely packed store. Must have been 10-15 in line ahead of me. Two workers. Sounds like a complete disaster, right?Nope. These two were on top if it. They kept everything moving, and after a little while the manager showed up and hopped right in to help out.It took about 20 minutes to get my pizzas, but I have no complaints. I was very impressed with how well the manager handled everything, and the three of them cranked through the pile of orders while still remaining friendly, courteous, and professional.We don't eat here super often, just because there are plenty of other pizza places that do the cooking for you, and when I'm hungry, I don't want extra steps. But I've never been so impressed with a crew before, and we are definitely going to make this a frequent stop.Keep up the excellent work!“

“Wanted to pay it forward with a complement tonight! Shout out to PizzaHut tonight. From the gentleman who made ordering fun over the phone, to the young woman working the counter who was busy as heck but doing it with smile on face to the manager (i think), they all went above and beyond. That place was hustling tonight and even though they made a slight mistake (easy to do when busy and my order was kinda complicated) everyone was great and more than happy to fix it. This kind of customer service makes my heart happy and we don't see much anymore. Keep up the great work team.“

“OMG we had a rip snorting time at the ski hill and were starving. My daughter came up the the wonderful idea of grabbing some pizza and having a milkshake. So we stopped at this location and did exactly that. Lisa knocked it out of the park with great service asking how we were feeling today. Then she made one of the best milkshakes ever!!! Yummy! I highly recommend this spot for a nice and convenient stop for some great tasting food!!!“

“My family and I come here around the holidays every year and we’re always taken care of. We have three households, 11 kids total, basically a circus, but Kyle and his team are always friendly and extremely accommodating. Thank you, A&W for making our dining experience special each year.“

“We love bringing out of town friends to Sal's. We had the Valentine's menu and it was the best food we've had in years! Tameka was amazing and the food came out so quick. Clean plates all day!“

“BEST PIZZA I have ever had! They have great burgers soup, salads, appetizers and pastas too. Definitely coming back.“

“Great pizza. Perfectly charred underneath. Some of The most flavorful pizza sauce I’ve had in Madison. All around delicious“

“great stuffed zaaa thank you“

“I recommend Anna Pizza if your in the area. I myself have problems with my stomach and have to be on a KETO DIET and I order a very thin crust. I may not eat the crust but there topping and cheese are so delicious and good and they don't bother my tummy either. I think it's because they must use real or high quality products. I love there Pizza. I myself give them 5 stars.“

“I’m so thankful I discovered Zoe’s! It’s like having Ian’s pizza but with way better crust. 🤣❤️ I get my nails done in Waunakee and my nail girl told me about this place. Bet I come here every time I get my nails done! Today I had their special - chorizo - and when I say it was BOMB I mean it!!! This pizza is so dang good, and every flavor I try has been consistently delicious. 🍕 😍 lunch prices are amazing too! I highly recommend giving this place a try even just for a slice.“

“the chicken dinners in the tiramisu“

“Absolutely wonderful pizza! Highly recommend the Barbie! Now my Friday night go to. No cooking at my home on Fridays 😊“

“I have always liked pizza from Rocky's. Even more so that you can get a slice quickly, eat it and get back to what you were doing. The breadsticks also are very good so as far as a quick pizza place this does a good job.

The staff member that we encountered was not super friendly and did seem as if she would have rather have no one show up.

Overall the food was good and we needed something quick. This was both of those things.“

“Excellent pizza, we’ve never had a bad experience (ordering more than just pizza), and we’ve been 10+ times!“

“★☆☆☆☆ – Consistently Disappointing Experience Disappointment every single time — whether dining in or ordering delivery. The food quality is consistently poor, and any time you try to offer constructive feedback, the owner, Adam, becomes defensive and dismissive. Instead of addressing concerns, he’ll tell you that you “don’t know what you’re talking about” and promise to refund your order — a promise he never follows through on. This is by far the worst Glass Nickel Pizza location I’ve experienced. With so many better pizza options in Sun Prairie, I regret giving them multiple chances. Do yourself a favor: reheat a frozen pizza. It’ll taste better, and you won’t have to deal with Adam’s attitude.“

“Stopped in for a slice. Great customer service great price for good ol zaaa“

“For what it is, MOD works. It will never be five star dining. Pizza quality varies depending on who is making it. It is usually pretty fast, and tastes all right. There is better pizza in town, if you want great pizza. If you just want a decent lunch, this is where you go.“

“Wow I’m amazed at how this location has improved over time! Josh was amazing at taking my order and honoring an older coupon! Delicious supreme pizza goes well with garlic sauce! Very clean and accessible location! I’ll definitely be back again!“

“What a great little hidden gem! Great drinks, gourmet food, amazing staff and we even got to meet the owner, Steve! Very friendly atmosphere. We will definitely be back!!“

“Dough Boy’s is top notch. We ordered on 1/3/2026 and asked for a 5:00pm delivery. Their delivery was right on time and the 3 pizzas were hot and ready to enjoy! Their tavern style pizza and caramelized pepperoni option was fantastic! 5 stars ⭐️“

“Always loved Papa Murphy's Take and bake! They get my order right every time, and our prompt for my pickup time. My favorite is the hawaiian, plus mushrooms.... YUM!
I can get two 16-in pizzas for about $30, that's a deal!“

“Best food around! There isn't a better burger in town! Don't get me started on the shrimp - to die for!“

“This is a highway stop location with a mini-food court that has Rocky Rococo, Cousins Subs, and A&W. I love Rocky Rococo pizza. I had a sausage and pepperoni super slice. Very delicious. The service was quick. There was ample dining tables available. The area was very clean.“