23 Best Italian Restaurants near Menomonee Falls

“This is our favorite Fish Fry in the area! (And we've tried a lot of fish fry's :) The Pizza is also really good! We love their thin, crispy, crust! The wait staff has always been friendly and hard working. It's hard to beat Pepino's.“

“Maria was such a sweetheart , she so kind , thoughtful , grateful and amazing she kept checking up on us asking did we need something getting us refills without us asking js thoughtful of her to do that the food wasn’t bad i js didn’t like the shrimp scampi bt evt else was fire !!! SHOUT OUT TO MARIA FOR BEING THE BEST FOREVER THE BEST SERVICE merry christmas to maria !“

“Even though the Pewaukee location is closer to my house, I order from the Menomonee Falls restaurant because the food and service I much much beter.“

“Our third time and the anniversary couple's first time (55 years!) and we were all thoroughly impressed! The food is so authentic - better than any dish we had when we visited Italy! Made with love and fresh ingredients, served by staff who care, and presentation and waitstaff well worth the price. This is not inexpensive, but for any meal with ambiance, and never disappointing, I recommend it highly. Five star everything. We cannot say enough. Thank you for contributing a wonderful Italian option in Tosa area.“

“Cannot say enough about the food, the staff and the ambiance. Whether it is pregame, post-game, special night out, day drinking and dining or late night cocktails and dinner after a late flight this place never, ever disappoints. Its been that way for years and hope it never changes.“

“the.everything but anchovies thin crust, I have eaten it here fo'r all 48 years, Mike“

“Great food!!! Fast service!“

“Staff was very attentive. Food was fantastic. My only complaint is the price, but you certainly get plenty of food for what you pay.“

“Classic Italian done right!“

“Great discovery of a great pizza place!“

“Absolutely fantastic. I ordered on a whim , en route home from work. I never heard of the place before , but it slapped harder than nonna with a hot spoon. The food was ready before the pick up time. And it was phenomenal. Would smash again. Definitely. 🤌🏻🤌🏻“

“Mariana was one of the best servers we have ever had. She was very cheerful and on top of everything. We were celebrating my husband and son's birthdays and she made it extremely enjoyable. Please give her our sincere gratitude for a wonderful evening!“

“Our food came out timed with apps and entrees. Fresh and hot. Exavion was a superb server meeting our needs and friendly with smiles. Our apps the lasagna rolls and fried mozzarella were delicious! Entrees of shrimp scampi and eggplant parmigiana were wonderful! I am new to the area and I will be back!“

“Food was phenomenal!! The atmosphere is lacking. A day of touching up paint, stain, chair nicks and deep cleaning would go a long way for minimal cost and effort. You would have thought it would have been done during the COVID-19 shutdown.“

“Visiting family in Milwaukee and they recommended coming here for the fish fry. Fish was delicious. Pieces were smaller than I expected but they were really good. They give you a bread basket as well which they refill when empty. Only hiccup was the service seemed a little slow considering they were very busy but the waiter was very polite and courteous. Overall I enjoyed the food and service“

“We were in Wauwatosa to avoid the craziness of Milwaukee and stopped by this little bar - Club Tap. Our neighbors at the bar counter ordered the CHEESIEST pizza that I’ve ever seen in my entire life (I’ve seen a lot of pizza) from you guys and we HAD to go next door and get some of our own. The small town vibes of this pizza place are wonderful. It’s so cute, authentic, DELICIOUS, and worth every penny. Thank you Lalli’s for your service. I don’t know who Lalli is but I’m sure he/she is/was great.“

“January 16, 2026. Just had a wonderful experience at Balistreri’s. There were 4 of us having the BEST PIZZA EVER! This is our go to pizza joint…all the way from North Carolina🤣🤣 (a joke). But my review is mainly regarding our awesome waiter, Ricardo! He was so pleasant and fun and played along with our joke! He showed that he truly enjoyed his job….what a joy!“

“The food is AMAZING. Extremely cool atmosphear especially after their remodel/addition they just did. The real fireplace is a nice touch. I recommend the pizza and garlic bread but have had their steaks and sandwichs too and have been very happy with them.“

“Please install an Aeration Iron And Sulfur Filter in your drinking water line!!
My family really love the food and the atmosphere. Honestly the best Italian I've had. It's just the water tastes bad. Our house had the same issue (we live EG).We love coming to this place. I'll gladly install it for you for free..“

“Fantastic pizza - always - hot, delicious, done the way you like it - near the 'hood' and on-time - small place - but thin crust is on FIRE!!!!!! Awesome - recommended highly by those that tried it - many times.“

“Second review! OMG absolute perfection again!!!! Ordered another deep dish last night and the pizza was literally perfection!!!!!!! WE WILL BE BACK!!!!!

Wow do they have delicious pizza!!!!!! Had a large gathering and had many pizzas to pickup at 4:30 today. Everything was literally done to perfection. And I HIGHLY RECOMMEND the Chicago style pizza!!!! First time having their pizza but it sure won't be the last!“

“Ordered catering dishes and pizzas. I worked with the owner to order and everything was so phenomenal. The penne pasta delicious. Breadsticks are outstanding. Baked chicken was some of the best. Perfectly seasoned. And of course pizzas are always awesome. My gusts couldn’t stop telling me how good everything was.
Thank you!!“

“A friend and I ate here a couple afternoons ago and wow was it to die for. Ever since new management took this place it has been spot on. One of the best Stromboli’s I have ever tried. The staff was also super friendly. I would for sure recommend this place to anyone.“