Pizza Restaurants near Merrimac

“We were there on Saturday, busy but well maintained and great customer service. We ordered a deep dish pizza that was... omg delicious 😋. Also a great thing to add and my favorite, LIVE MUSIC. our very own Doctor Dale will be there Aug. 17th. Yeay!“

“The food and service were great. Love the mix of cocktail and wine options. Love the playlist and the place is incredibly clean.“

“This was our first visit, and overall it was a solid experience. The bartender/server was friendly and attentive the entire time. The atmosphere is kitschy and fun, though the decor feels a bit unfocused. The space was also dimmer than expected given the number of windows. The menu could use stronger color contrast, as everything blends together in low light and makes it harder to read. I eventually noticed the small table light, which helped, but clearer design would go a long way. Having napkins already at the table would also be a nice touch. We started with the Warden bites, which were flavorful and satisfying. The Reuben was generously stacked with corned beef and had a good amount of cheese. It leaned a little wet and slightly saltier than expected, but still enjoyable. The tots were crispy and well seasoned. The only minor drawback was a faint fryer oil taste on both the tots and the bites. The fish tacos, which come as three, were good overall. The fish was slightly overdone, though that worked for her preference. A sauce on the side would really elevate the dish. The Bloody Marys were tasty, and splitting a Blue Moon rounded things out well. We’d come back, especially to check out the dollar wings on a busier night and see the place with more energy. For an appetizer, three drinks, a sandwich and tacos, our bill was $60.00 which is a tremendous value.“

“As a true Long Island New York transplant to Wisconsin I can always count on consistent fresh hot beautiful pizza that tastes like it came from my neighborhood “Pizza Stop” on Long Island! Thank you for being in Baraboo Wisconsin!“

“Always a fun time. Have not tried the pizza but I hear it's the best. We go to the Gem every time we visit Baraboo, great place to chill and have a drink. Bartenders are very friendly. You don't want to miss this one if you are in town.“

“Thank you for accommodating our party of 20 last night! Totally impressed with the food & service!! Highly recommend!! 🎉“

“We love the pizza and up until yesterday 4/22/22 we encountered the first time the sausage was not the same. We think it was precooked and what was great tasting sausage before turned out to be totally different in taste. Only other explanation is a new sausage supplier. We will order only pepperoni in the future.“

“Created a pizza. Nice to have customized options fie crust choice, type and amount of sauce, and amount of toppings.

Tried Ceasars salad. Appreciate choosing low calorie dressing and ability to have a dressing packet to determine how much to put on (instead of having dressing on the salad).“

“I just wanted to say thank you to PJs for the delicious food we ordered tonight. It saved me from heating up the house on a very hot day. Also, you have the best group of kids working there! EVERY time I call or order in person they have been nothing but kind, polite and pleasant. Keep up the good work!!!“