27 Best Pizza Restaurants near Baraboo

“Absolutely the best Italian!!! We will be telling everyone!“

“All the reviews are correct! This place is off the hook! ! This place is great based on service- quality of food- quantity of food- and service. They just do a great job here all the way around. If you are with family and or friends, and say you came into town to take in the attractions like the circus, don’t run off… like seriously treat yourself to a great place. The food prices are very reasonable- the service is great- the staff is very professional and kind. If you ask for advice on what to order and they all know their menu… the pizza is amazing. The burgers are fantastic. The French dig is very good. If I were to recommend something I would say either the bone in or boneless wings, and I would recommend their french dip sandwich. The fries I believe are homemade? If they aren’t, I just know they are awesome.

FYI, my phone took a crap so I lost a lot of my photos/ next time I go here I will get pics posted along with this review.

Until the next review,
Steve-O, out!“

“As a true Long Island New York transplant to Wisconsin I can always count on consistent fresh hot beautiful pizza that tastes like it came from my neighborhood “Pizza Stop” on Long Island! Thank you for being in Baraboo Wisconsin!“

“Went to “Tour of Italy” wine dinner tonight, absolutely fabulous! Thank you was a great experience!“

“Hey hi ooo uh hi r go ouo I vhi hi Gus“

“I’m not sure if this is the right location, but if there is a Chloe here, who unfortunately had to help out at a Madison location this past weekend, this review is for her.

The Madison location is an absolute nightmare, but Chloe did amazing under so much pressure and did an absolutely wonderful job after being talked to so poorly by other customers. She had no control over their complaints, as it was all about the manager and kitchen staff who all just walked out I guess?

This location is 100% better simply because she’s there. I trust that a good worker like her comes from a good team, so this store much have a very pleasant staff.“

“Great pizza great kicken.“

“never had a bad pizza and it's better and cheaper than a frozen pizza“

“Best pizza - period. Don’t believe me - prove me wrong.“

“Just ate there with my family, the pizza was hot and good. I ordered a salad and that was fresh and delicious. It was a big salad. Also, the service was great!“

“We were there on Saturday, busy but well maintained and great customer service. We ordered a deep dish pizza that was... omg delicious 😋. Also a great thing to add and my favorite, LIVE MUSIC. our very own Doctor Dale will be there Aug. 17th. Yeay!“

“Been living here for 10 years and always drive past by until last night I gave a try it out. It was great food and owner is awesome too!! Yes I had to wait my food longer because there’s big group of party and it’s worth the wait. Will definitely come back again.“

“Fun family dinner spot for the young kids. We had salmon, steak, and burgers and all of us were pleasantly surprised.

Yeah, it feels like a family trap at first with the heavy moose theme, but the food far surpassed the expectations! Must wear the provided moose antlers to complete your family vacation.“

“Our son is obsessed with trains so we had to stop by to check it out. He is absolutely obsessed with this restaurant now! The burgers were just okay, my mom enjoyed her salmon and I really enjoyed my chicken Alfredo. We ordered their kids drinks in their special souvenir cups and all 4 kids loved that!“

“We were looking to try a new pizza place in The Dells and we were staying at the hotel across the street. The staff was super friendly and gave us some suggestions. Our Chicago style and sausage pizza were amazing!! Super friendly staff and quick service. We will definitely be back for more!!“

“My bartender Tiana was awesome! I Never waited for a drink! 5 Stars!“

“The food and service were great. Love the mix of cocktail and wine options. Love the playlist and the place is incredibly clean.“

“I ordered a couple pizzas and an order of wings on a Friday night. The wait time was about hour (as I expected). Order arrived right on time, the wings were EXCELLENT even after being packaged up and transported and the pizza was hot fresh and very tasty. Service was friendly and even carried it into my condo. Definitely will be coming back.“

“great place to stop when we are out boating. Super sad they no longer carry Sassycow ice-cream. 😢 please consider switching to an ice-cream brand that is corn syrup free. Friends with allergies can no longer enjoy ice-cream with us because of the ice-cream brand change 😞“

“Got a pizza here for lunch 9/7/24, it was so good and hot, a nice amount of cheese. So we got more pizza for dinner, they recommend I wait the 10-15 since I was there as if I wanted it brought to us it could be an hour. (Dinner rush I get it). But yes very nice 2 1-topping pizzas and a 2 liter for $37 is a great price. Thank you! (Was more than enough pizza for 3 adults and a child.)“

“Great food and atmosphere! We got to look around a bit and hear the unique history of the three buildings!“

“This is now one of our favorite restaurants when in the dells. Love the atmosphere live music and of course the food is superb and large portions, you won’t leave hungry! Can’t wait to try the pizza next time.“

“Ok but it’s AUG 18th… Dells is busy, especially late at night…..So closing at 9? A group of 10, plus my groups of 2 and a group of 4 showed up around 8:45 💁‍♂️ Seems like a lot of money thrown out the window“

“Been coming here for years. it's the best!!! Great food!“

“Wonderful food and service! Love that you serve Icelandic Haddock! The best!“

“After a long day at the waterpark, we loved having a delicious Italian sit down restaurant inside Kalahari Resort! My girls love pizza and pasta so this was PERFECT!

On the day we went, no reservation needed and not crowded at all, we got seated right away. My girls and I ordered pepperoni pizza, shrimp scampi pasta, pasta bolognese, and margharita pizza. Everything was so delicious! The sauce was rich but not too rich, LOTS of shrimp and beef, so flavorful and so delicious! The pizza was 12/10–we love the crust on it and you can tell it was super fresh! The pasta noodles—were very fresh and I could tell it was handmade! My mom got a salad with tons of fresh olives and greens—it was flavorful and delicious. Their potion sizes were also very decent.

We came back the next day for pizza and pasta to go on our drive back. Overall, highly recommend and would definitely come back again! 🙌“

“I enjoy that they have a super thin crust that still tastes good. They also have a stuffed cheese bread that is amazing and even warms up good the next day.

Overall this is a typical Domino's but they do make a good pizza.“