27 Best Pizza Restaurants near Baraboo

“Absolutely the best Italian!!! We will be telling everyone!“

“Get the Sicilian style pizza with the works!!!! You must eat the pizza. The rest of the food does look good but the pizza wins hands down and I’ve driven 2 hours for it. Place is cool with exposed brick. Lots of table space. I’ve only sat at the bar and it’s nice too. When it’s busy expect a little wait for food but nothing bad. Plenty of tv sports at the bar. Servers are attentive and friendly. But seriously they have the best pizza I’ve ever eaten.“

“As a true Long Island New York transplant to Wisconsin I can always count on consistent fresh hot beautiful pizza that tastes like it came from my neighborhood “Pizza Stop” on Long Island! Thank you for being in Baraboo Wisconsin!“

“Went to “Tour of Italy” wine dinner tonight, absolutely fabulous! Thank you was a great experience!“

“Hey hi ooo uh hi r go ouo I vhi hi Gus“

“Got a pizza to go the other night. Very good. I picked it up and didn’t have it delivered. Whenever I have gotten food here it is always good. Always hot and fresh. I like getting their wings from time to time for something different. The apartments where I live in Baraboo had a movie night and we were to bring a food or snack item to the movie. I brought some cheese bread and a pizza. It was a hit. Can’t go wrong with this place. I have gotten food here many times and they are very consistent. Always hot and fresh. Always very good. Highly Recommended.“

“Great pizza great kicken.“

“never had a bad pizza and it's better and cheaper than a frozen pizza“

“Best pizza - period. Don’t believe me - prove me wrong.“

“Been living here for 10 years and always drive past by until last night I gave a try it out. It was great food and owner is awesome too!! Yes I had to wait my food longer because there’s big group of party and it’s worth the wait. Will definitely come back again.“

“We were there on Saturday, busy but well maintained and great customer service. We ordered a deep dish pizza that was... omg delicious 😋. Also a great thing to add and my favorite, LIVE MUSIC. our very own Doctor Dale will be there Aug. 17th. Yeay!“

“Just ate there with my family, the pizza was hot and good. I ordered a salad and that was fresh and delicious. It was a big salad. Also, the service was great!“

“Fun family dinner spot for the young kids. We had salmon, steak, and burgers and all of us were pleasantly surprised.

Yeah, it feels like a family trap at first with the heavy moose theme, but the food far surpassed the expectations! Must wear the provided moose antlers to complete your family vacation.“

“This place is wild. Was brought by a friend and had no idea what was waiting for me. From the outside it's just a typical bar and grill. But the inside is essentially a giant Lego theme park, from Star Wars to Lord of the Rings to Taylor Swift. The fact that your food is delivered by model train seems the least fabtasticsl. Food is perfectly mediocre but the service is great and the atmosphere is truly one of a kind. We'll be back next time we're in the area.“

“My bartender Tiana was awesome! I Never waited for a drink! 5 Stars!“

“I ordered a couple pizzas and an order of wings on a Friday night. The wait time was about hour (as I expected). Order arrived right on time, the wings were EXCELLENT even after being packaged up and transported and the pizza was hot fresh and very tasty. Service was friendly and even carried it into my condo. Definitely will be coming back.“

“The food and service were great. Love the mix of cocktail and wine options. Love the playlist and the place is incredibly clean.“

“We were looking to try a new pizza place in The Dells and we were staying at the hotel across the street. The staff was super friendly and gave us some suggestions. Our Chicago style and sausage pizza were amazing!! Super friendly staff and quick service. We will definitely be back for more!!“

“great place to stop when we are out boating. Super sad they no longer carry Sassycow ice-cream. 😢 please consider switching to an ice-cream brand that is corn syrup free. Friends with allergies can no longer enjoy ice-cream with us because of the ice-cream brand change 😞“

“Got a pizza here for lunch 9/7/24, it was so good and hot, a nice amount of cheese. So we got more pizza for dinner, they recommend I wait the 10-15 since I was there as if I wanted it brought to us it could be an hour. (Dinner rush I get it). But yes very nice 2 1-topping pizzas and a 2 liter for $37 is a great price. Thank you! (Was more than enough pizza for 3 adults and a child.)“

“This is now one of our favorite restaurants when in the dells. Love the atmosphere live music and of course the food is superb and large portions, you won’t leave hungry! Can’t wait to try the pizza next time.“

“Great food and atmosphere! We got to look around a bit and hear the unique history of the three buildings!“

“Ok but it’s AUG 18th… Dells is busy, especially late at night…..So closing at 9? A group of 10, plus my groups of 2 and a group of 4 showed up around 8:45 💁‍♂️ Seems like a lot of money thrown out the window“

“Been coming here for years. it's the best!!! Great food!“

“Wonderful food and service! Love that you serve Icelandic Haddock! The best!“

“We came here after spending a full day taking advantage of excitement in the resort and it was exactly the kind of dinner we needed! We started our meal with the mozzarella and the frozen raspberry cocktail and both were perfect openers. We followed that up with the stuffed shells and the fettuccine alfredo with shrimp and both were perfectly prepared as far as cook and sauce goes! Sortino's does table side parm like other Italian restaurants but what sets them apart there is they left the grater at the table so we could go back and add more cheese if we wanted, which was great. We finished off the night with taking the cheesecake and canolli to go, which we happily enjoyed in our room once we had digested some of our yummy dinner. Our advice is if you want a quieter/emptier restaurant, stop by for an earlier dinner (around 5-5:30), as when we were leaving it was starting to get more packed. But we agreed we will be coming back in the future, even if we're staying off-site!“

“I enjoy that they have a super thin crust that still tastes good. They also have a stuffed cheese bread that is amazing and even warms up good the next day.

Overall this is a typical Domino's but they do make a good pizza.“