Restaurants near New Glarus

“Amazing experience. The food was so incredible, homemade crust and authentic New York style flavors! The family that owns the restaurant was beyond kind. Appetizer, pizzas, and desserts. No complaints! Makes us wish we lived closer.”

“What a fun place to enjoy friends and family!!! Super clean and super fun!!! Great food and entertainment!”

“Apple Bread/Pffernusse Cookies/Bienestick Tort”

“great place with great food!!!”

“This place has a really warm and friendly atmosphere AND incredible cinnamon rolls and other stuff! The staff is excellent. Cool art and stuff. Bicycle friendly! Def gonna crush a Pumpkin Bar next time!”

“Just a nice small local bar with great burgers.”

“Fast, friendly service! The best cheese curds I have ever had!”

“We absolutely LOVE Kennedy’s! We discovered this place when we moved to New Glarus in December of 2016. Sheri makes THE MOST DELICIOUS sandwiches and she and Kennedy, her daughter, always give my son special attention. Again, GREAT burgers and sandwiches and the BLT is the BEST; tons of bacon that’s well-cooked!”

“We had our rehearsal dinner, wedding and reception at the Fest Haus this past Saturday and it was perfect!! Kennedy is absolutely amazing, she helps with every detail and makes sure everything runs smoothly. The bartenders, Jada and Brenna, were great as well. I would recommend the Fest Haus to anyone looking for an event space!”

“Currently, under construction at the main site- use the Riverside location for The Best Beer in Wisconsin! You can’t beat the tasting room & souvenirs. The staff was helpful and friendly! Very worth the stop!”

“Very cool experience. Good food. Would come again. $10 for a spotted cow seems a little high considering it's made down the street. Other than that - 5 stars.”

“We have had the best experiences every time we have gone to the New Glarus location. Not only has the food been phenomenal, the staff has been tremendously nice and has gone out of their way to make sure we are well taken care of. Well done!!”

“The sandwiches are really tasty, and go well with the beers on tap. It's so nice to see so many locals supporting Puempel's. Between the food, friendliness and the vintage decor, it's a great place to stop for lunch, whether it's for the weekend or just for the day.🙂🍻”

“Great service and awesome food. I came there with my family and we were pleased with how good the food tasted and the quality of the food. We will definitely be back if we're up this way!”

“Good times were had by all.
Stopped to grab a bite to eat inbetween jobs, had my usual foot long sweet onion chicken teriyaki on herb and cheese. Toasted.
The sandwich was made exactly how I like, and didn't have to repeat myself for anything, perfect.
10/10, would go again.”

“Best Culvers I have ever ate at. Nice employees and excellent food”

“I love this place so much! The owner is as sweet as her pastries! Wide variety of pastries, coffee, and they’re very patient for my indecisive little one and I. Everything is reasonably priced for how delicious the food and coffee is. Couldn’t ask for anything better! 💕”

“Whoever was cashier 5/8/25 was very nice and polite around 5:30 when I was there today.”

“A fantastic venue for LIVE MUSIC in a scenic spot! Plenty of space to enjoy a delicious drink and bite to eat with a friendly atmosphere. Chairs, picnic tables, permanent campsites for rent… all along the shady trees of the Sugar River. The staff is top notch and worth celebrating!”

“Wonderful little saloon. A must visit in my book. Nice atmosphere, wonderful owner, great conversations, extended menu choices, great food. The list goes on and on.”

“third generation family business”

“My first time just passing through was amazing. The bartender was this really nice lady but can't remember her name for the life of me. Guess I'll have to go visit again. The customers there made me feel welcomed even as an outsider.
The gentleman I sat next to was a nice guy and we were talking l I ke we knew each other for years. I'll definitely be going back here soon.”

“Amazing cocktails in a perfect location! Lori went above and beyond to help me host a surprise birthday party and even bartended the event herself. She is so knowledgeable and so much fun to be around! Do not miss My Tipsy Gypsy on your next trip to Paoli!”

“We've been twice now. Once for great thin crust pizza and again for the Smash Burger. It was caramelized all around including the cheese. Sautéed onions on top. There's nothing like it in Belleville, New Glarus or Monticello. Two great experiences even with construction going on. Exciting to have this new option.”

“Awesome prime rib sandwich! Only downfall is that it’s so far from my house to get another one.”

“Great service and great food, cozy, friendly atmosphere!”

“Love everything about this place-the atmosphere is cozy, the staff is attentive, knowledgeable and kind, and the food is delish! The Fish Platter on Friday nights is like non-other! It is divine and a perfect “share” for a dinner date. The menu changes weekly, and they make different foods on different days-just like home. Sign me up to be a regular!”

“Nice atmosphere.. Good service everytime I visit! Nice hometown Bar with a friendly crowd to hang out with!”

“Best burger around”

“Quaint, quirky & quiet bar, a good place for conversation, or to play cards! Limited, but (at least recently) reliable hours. Sometimes has a home-cooked dinner option (besides the frozen pizzas, etc.). If so on your visit, I'd recommend trying it. I've been pleasantly surprised each time. Reasonable and good (but not extensive) local beer options. Great little local one-man establishment.”