39 Best American Restaurants near North Prairie

“We were passing through the area and randomly picked sideliners, definitely a good choice! food was amazing, I haven't had a place hit the spot like sideliners. service was good. drinks always topped off, food came out fairly quick which was surprising for how good it was. everything my family picked was great. sooner or later I'll make the 2hr drive just to eat there. highly highly recommend. and the price for 4 of us total wasnt bad either, especially for the quality of our meals.“

“was here for a craft fair. great friendly area with delicious food! definitely coming back!“

“Mobley burger is a favorite of mine, as well as the cheese curds!“

“cute, cozy atmosphere with great food!“

“Probably the best coffee I had in a long time It's Stone Creek offee and it is amazing. The food was delightful and will have us coming back for more soon!“

“Beautiful, relaxing place even when it’s busy. Cocktails are very nice on and off the menu! Cheers!“

“Excellent food and service. Revere’s is our go-to place.“

“We celebrated our wedding and retirement at Knuckleheads last Saturday. Had about 100 guests. Scott and his crew were amazing. They made planning and set up very easy. The food was amazing. Everyone loved it! The girls behind the bar did a fantastic job taking care of our thirsty guests. We got several compliments of how great a place Knuckleheads is. Thank you for everything!“

“Food took a little while longer than usual to arrive at no fault of the server, but everything was delivered together, hot, fresh and delicious! Fish fry was awesome with the perfect balance of crispy crunchy outside, cooked to perfection... without it being too over or under done like happens with many other places.“

“Our new favorite place to go! Friday fish is amazing!! Best potato pancakes around. Friendly service with a ton of laughs! Can’t wait to try the broasted chicken, it looks delicious! Can’t beat $2 Tallboys either. I highly recommend this place!“

“The food is consistently excellent and the service is great.“

“A treasure to find this place. Great food. Great atmosphere. Great service. We will become weekend regulars and want to try just about everything on the menu. The Patty Melt was the best we have ever had anywhere!“

“Great place to stop at and enjoy a nice cocktail with good company 😁 From the other Tiffany and her Mom“

“Food was above average , a little pricey for sides. Must say though it’s the first time I’ve been hit with an up charge for the olives in my martini. Really???“

“My 7 yo daughter and I stopped in today grab some lunch for the first time. Our server was Christina and she was simply amazing! We never had to request for a refill and she made sure we had everything we needed. She offered helpful suggestions, too. Children's menu was great with lots of options and the menu has lots of variety as well. I did get the Artichoke dip which was the best I've had. 10/10 and we'll stop again when we're in the area.“

“The young people that work in this store are always so pleasant, friendly and kind. Great work ethic! It’s really a pleasure to stop by and grab something to eat or drink. Thank you!“

“Shanahan’s has been my favorite place to treat myself since we moved to Mukwonago. I had to give up dairy several years ago temporarily and that was how I found them but I continued to visit when I discovered that everything is delicious! Recently I treated myself to a GF/Vegan Key Lime pie, which I had never tried. “Regular” key lime pie is one of my favorite desserts and I’ve never had a GF/vegan version. It was the best key lime pie I’ve ever had anywhere! My kids saw the GF/vegan label and said “eh no thanks mom” but when I opened the box they changed their mind. That pie didn’t last 24 hours in our house! My go to drink is their Azteca but their oat milk chai is also delicious! Oh and if you’re looking for catering, try them! We had a small meeting catered about a year and a half ago where people from all across SE Wisconsin attended and I still get comments about the food from Shanahans!“

“I was in town for a training over the weekend and was told about the Friday Fish Fry at the American Legion. I am a Legion member and decided to check it out. You will get no better service, atmosphere, food, or drink! This post made me feel right at home for the entire evening made me glad I stopped in and gave me pride in that veteran community! They are an open post so anyone can partake, but do not miss out on this great gem!!!!“

“The service and staff are extraordinary. Always in a great mood, always happy to help.

Vegetarian options: Its butter burgers, egg based custard, and deep fried cheese curds. Vegans know there is nothing here for them....“

“Read reviews and went. Excellent service and food. Will be back!“

“Best evet“

“We’ve driven by this beautiful home many times, and we decided to stop for lunch. The owner Christine was very knowledgeable about the meals and healthy choices. Very personable, inviting and enjoyed hearing more about the home. We will stop for breakfast soon!!“

“They charge a credit card service fee. Terrible! It’s already $40+ for a small piece of chicken and risotto. Very basic and over priced food. The chicken was extremely moist but salty. Almost as if they soak it for days in a salt brine.

The portions were also on the smaller side for the price.

Top notch balsamic glaze.

The decor and atmosphere also does not warrant a $50+ a person meal. For instance, the tables were sticky and the waitress was wearing shorts.“

“Oh my gosh this was an amazing good food and service was good too“

“Hands down the BEST bar in Mukwonago!! The food is amazing, they always have great deals, the service is spectacular 👌 and not to mention all the patrons are so friendly I became friends instantly with alot of regulars and I always feel welcome 😀 ps-Christy and Bre are my favorite bartenders but I have yet to meet everyone else still.“

“great place good food we came into town hungry the cook was still around and made us a pizza after the kitchen was closed for a couple hrs..the bartender is a sweet lady the customers we met were nice.stop in get a drink and some food“

“Amazing staff, food and drinks!! Be careful the chicken sandwhiches are addicting and definitely the best in the area!“

“good service and good, we will be back.“

“Living only several miles from the Suhmer's Motel in the Town of Eagle, and the apparent very nice rustic accommodations as per the photos, me and Sally will visit for a weekend relax getaway, now that the Confederate flag has been removed from the front walkway. This is most appreciated...“

“Absolutely amazing workers and management!!! Cooks mixed up mine and my bf sirloin liking and I'm not a fan of bloody meat. The manager was called over and he got me a new one. I was just expecting the sirloin but no he came out with all the sides that came with it and boxed it up for me. Our waitress was amazing and very understanding and very polite and told me it was okay as I am not one to complain about my food!!! Totally will be back and recommending this place!!!“

“I ordered the fish and shrimp combo, and man let me tell you, it was outstanding! I had the fish blackened Cajun style had them dust some Cajun seasonings on the perfectly fried shrimp. I thought I was in Florida. If you know you know!“

“Overall great place. Knew previous owners before the current but I am happy the vibes are still the same! Minor difficulty to get to the ramp if cars are there if you are wheelchair-bound or using a stroller. Still great! Love the food and ice cream!

Parking: There is only 3 or 4 parking spaces before the signs of tenants parking which is only 2.

Kid-friendliness: Kid friendly. Great to bring kids for ice cream

Wheelchair accessibility: There is a ramp for wheelchair access however cars aren't super mindful of it so you might have difficulty getting to the ramp.“

“Had take out tonight. One of the best burgers we have had in a long time. We will be back!“

“was a fun place. we will be going back“

“We love going to the Sunset Grill in Pewaukee. Great service, and even better food!“

“We had a party of 25 for a private 70th bd party at the Delafield location. Great communication from my 1st contact, great waitstaff, food and drinks. We were not rushed and enjoyed a perfect experience. Thank you, Delafield Water Street Brewery.“

“Great Food and Awesome service.“

“We have been to Lucky Chuckys a few times. Great food. The service is not good. Issues were taken care of but should not have happened in first place…quality control. Need better training. Tried giving it a few chances but probably won’t be back. Service to us is very important. So many other places to go that have good food but if service is bad.“

“Friday fish fry was delicious! And Kelly the bartender was amazing. New to the area and we will definitely be back!“