Buttermint

$$$ • American, Cocktail Bar, New American

Hours:
4195 N Oakland Ave, Shorewood
(414) 488-2587

Customers' Favorites

Buttermint Reviews

Restaurantji Rating
4.3 (302)
Restaurantji Rating

This place is really fun! Casual art deco digs and a creative and engaging menu. We loved all of it! The Staff were superb, and the best bathrooms maybe ever. My only complaint was ALL the dishes were salty, like really salty. Even my salad. I didn’t really mind but, it was a bit much after a couple of course.I look forward to trying the other restaurants from these creators!

Restaurantji Rating

Went here for fish fry on Good Friday - a lovely experience. Had oysters and deviled eggs as apps - delicious! The fish fry was great - special shout out to the haddock and the potato pancake!

Restaurantji Rating

Classy place with swell food and delicious cocktails. Partner had the medallions and shrimp. I had the seared scallops. Both were...good/decent, but we'd like to come back and try something else. I felt the risotto was overly salty against the already-naturally salty scallops, so it weighed the meal down. Curds and pretzel loaf were yummy, but the loaf tasted more like rye bread than pretzel, and we asked them to remake the curds because the first order wasn't right. Server...read full review

More Reviews(370)

Ratings

Hours

Monday 4 - 9PM
Tuesday 4 - 9PM
Wednesday 4 - 9PM
Thursday 4 - 9PM
Friday 4 - 9PM
Saturday 4 - 9PM
Sunday Closed
Updated on: