Colony House Restaurant
$$ • American, Cocktail Bar, VegetarianAbout Colony House Restaurant
Customers' Favorites
Ishy Ishy Friday Night Fishy Beer Battered Cod Fish Dinner
Beer Batterred Cod Friday Fish Fry
Beer-Battered Baby Walleyed Pike
Hearty Artichoke Cheese Dip
Alaskan King Crab Legs
Chocolate Walnut Pie
Homemade Crab Cakes
Oysters Florentine
Stuffed Flounder
Chicken St James
Colony House Restaurant Reviews
470 ratings
Share your opinion about Colony House Restaurant
My husband and I have enjoyed our dinners here for 45 years. Similar menu and same receipes. We celebrated our wedding rehearsal dinner here. Our favorite restaurant for our anniversary and birthdays, the best restaurant for Friday fish fry in the state of Wisconsin!
An absolute BON APPETIT experience. Highly recommend!
Despite new ownership this place remains as excellent as it’s always been. Our servers Kelly and Aiden, on top of the food and drinks (!!!), made our evening so wonderful.
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 4 - 9PM |
| Wednesday | 4 - 9PM |
| Thursday | 4 - 9PM |
| Friday | 4 - 10PM |
| Saturday | 4 - 10PM |
| Sunday | 3 - 9PM |
.jpg)
The Colony House Restaurant is a popular dining destination known for its welcoming atmosphere and affordable prices. The prime rib has received high praise for its delicious flavor and generous 20 oz portion, available at a reasonable price. Many customers enjoy the variety of options on the menu, including the Stuffed Filet and Salmon Oscar, alongside appetizers like crab cakes and baked escargot. While some have noted that the twice-baked potato and riblet appetizer may not be the freshest, the flavor is still reportedly enjoyable. Although the steak options have received mixed reviews, the drinks are said to be reasonably priced, with the exception of non-special drinks. Vegetarian options and accommodations for dietary restrictions are available upon request. It is recommended to make a reservation, ideally calling at least 2-3 days ahead, as this establishment is a popular choice for many. The service is often highlighted as exceptional, with servers like Patty receiving praise for their attentiveness. The dining experience is enhanced by the restaurant's ambiance, which is cozy and well-spaced, allowing for enjoyable conversations. The dessert selection, including crème brûlée and chocolate cake, adds to the overall satisfaction. With reasonable pricing for the quality and quantity of food served, The Colony House is a great choice for a nice dinner or date night, and many guests express their intention to return.