35 Best American Restaurants near Williams Bay

“The grilled chicken sandwich had absolutely no flavor. Prices are okay I won a 50 Cent drink during happy hour. The chicken sandwich needs work on the flavor and the fries tasted like they were coming out of old grease. Bartender was awesome working in a lot of pain and did a great job superfriendly“

“Our first time visiting and on a cool, overcast, and off season day, but we were still able to sit on the heated outdoor patio and take in the lake view. The staff was extremely pleasant, the food was pretty good, and the drinks were belly warming! Id love to come back and experience this place in the height of summer season, I'm betting it's a real hoot!Parking: Parking is a bit strange here honestly. We arrive off season and could park pretty much out front of the pier side entrance, but there are only like 2 spots out there generally and we just got lucky. When we asked the wait staff we were told that in season there is a shuttle service that transfers diners back and forth between a remote parking lot and the restaurant. They also offer valet. I'm sure it works for them, but how much traffic do I miss by not having readily available parking for the uninformed passer-by?Wheelchair accessibility: Entrance and some seating was easily accessible, but there were raised platform areas and unique urinal configurations in the men's bathroom that might made it challenging.“

“Great diner! Excellent food - all the favorites (Denver Omlet, pancakes, French toast) you would expect from your hometown diner plus some surprises (potato pancakes!!). The service was great even though it was packed. There is counter seating and table/booth seating. If you’re coming on a Sunday morning, bring your appetite and a little patience. It’s well worth the wait!!“

“This restaurant does not take reservations. We came at 630 on a Wednesday and had to wait 20 minutes for a table. The view is lake Como is mesmerizing. Once we were sat our waitress Sam came over immediately and got us cocktail refills. She was an amazing waitress. I had the filet mignon which was cooked to my liking with the corn fritters which were so good. I was told the ribs were fall off the bone. It was my friend's birthday and he got a free cheesecake with a candle. Definitely a fun supper club to try. They have fish fry's on Wednesday and Fridays!“

“Chef Kim Buyse delivers insanely beautiful flavors, stunning plating, and perfect execution in the seven course offering. What he is creating is special and I cannot wait to see him continue to develop his voice through his food in the months and seasons to come. This may be the blossoming of a new center of haute cuisine in the Midwest, and the potential to be Michelin-star worthy down the line. I can't wait to come back!“

“I think I've found the hidden gem of Lake Geneva! Not only does Barrique possess awesome views of the waterfront, but its ambiance and dining experience were top-notch. Food was excellent and portions were very large. Tasty cocktails, too--especially their Old Fashioneds. Wanted to give a special shout-out to our server, who was incredibly friendly and attentive to our party's needs. All-in-all, would highly recommend this restaurant!“

“It is worth the wait, understand this restaurant is very popular.When it is full,sometimes the food quality drops a little,ex: fries may need to be cooked a little longer or maybe you asked for ranch and got ketchup. Politely,ask and the waitress and kitchen make up any slips in the order.“

“My daughter was in town for a short time on 03/3/24. Over half of their patrons were from Illinois. Much like our gas prices, cheaper for them, but not for locals. I haven't bought gas in Walworth for over 5 years. Fuel is cheaper in every other Wisconsin town I go to. And in like, every other diner I've been in is MUCH LESS EXPENSIVE! Walworth is more expensive then Lake Geneva, that's sad CAN YOU SAY GREED!Parking: Only about 42 spots close. More avaliable in lot over blocks away.“

“Greenie's is the best... great food, beautiful golf course views and the best staff ever. Every single one of the waitstaff, the owner, and the kitchen staff are awesome. They make you feel like family. We love it here and recommend it all the time. Fish Fry Friday is one of the very best in the area.“

“Started off our weekend trip to Lake Geneva by sitting at the bar and it didn't disappoint. Our bartender was nice and friendly - the drinks were great too! The restaurant and bar is very large so I could see this place getting packed and just a good vibe. The food was good and hit all the spots too! The sweet potato tots were sooo good and I loved my nachos!“

“We are big fish fry fans so this place came highly recommended. They did not disappoint at all!! My daughter had the AYCE chicken and I had the fish. I had to stop after 6 pieces or risk being rolled out by Vanessa, who was our incredibly attentive server. The place was packed and the service never staggered. Highly recommend bringing your stretchy waste pants!“

“We had an amazing breakfast at Tana’s Family Restaurant today! Our 17 month old has a severe egg allergy and from the waitress to the cook they were more than accommodating. My daughters meal was made first and our server was AMAZING. So friendly and my daughter loved her. She made us feel like we were dining at home. 5 stars!“

“I was pleasantly surprised how delicious their burgers were for a smaller dive type bar! We got the bacon cheeseburger deluxe and mushroom Swiss deluxe for pick up. They were both cooked perfectly and we loved how much lettuce tomato pickles onions they put on them. Also the variety of sauces is intriguing for dipping. I'm excited to try some others next time and maybe a wrap next time. Pickup was smooth and the bartender was very nice, I would recommend calling rather than ordering online. I definitely recommend giving them a try for a great juicy burger!!“

“The best fish fry around! We were first time visitors and we will be back! “Bug” as they call her is the best waitress….made us feel at home so be sure to ask for her. Why aren’t more places like Pirates Cove? Everyone in their from staff to a patrons were the friendliest people!“

“Stopped for a quick meal passing through Walworth. We all got burgers and were not disappointed. The signature cruise in burger was excellent - albeit a little messy with the yummy sauce dripping into your hand. The fries were hot and fresh and crisp. The place had a homey feel - comfortable and tables not too close to each other.“

“Is it wrong for a senior to use the word 'cute' for a facility? I truly love places like this one that are slowly fading away. You can see the history of this establishment. The 2 women working here really do take care of their patrons regardless if they are regulars or new such as myself.But the real star is the food. As simple omelet that really tasted excellent. Every part of the omelet made it great.“

“I had a burger, a bacon Smashburger with everything on it with fries. And it's the best Burger so far in Geneva. Don't quote me on that, but it was damm good with no seasoning and Pepper Jack cheese.Kid-friendliness: Plenty of seatings, low people Present at the time.“

“I’ve been to hoops a handful of times. Usually we’re skipping through town on the sleds, or grabbing a quick bite to eat. Today I stopped in with my kids and I must say the food was absolutely Devine today. The creamy chicken poblano soup was to die for, I would literally sell my soul for the recipe! Please make that a weekly soup and keep up the great atmosphere and food!“

“My friends and I stayed at Lake Lawn Resort recently for a conference. We decided to get dinner at Waterfront. The place was busy but we were seated right away. The waitress was great and checked in often. I ordered the Friday fish fry which was tasty and very affordable. I reccomend checking them out if you’re in Delavan!“

“They have a full menu but we went only for dessert and landed on delicious ice cream and yummy donut type things called widgets. We dipped the widgets in chocolate ice cream and it was almost a DIY churro thing happening. It's drive through or walk up only. Super clean space when we were there which seemed early in their season. Plenty of staff to get the orders out quickly. Recommended to us by someone who grew up in Walworth!“

“Great burgers and amazing cheese curds. Went on a very busy Saturday night and they only has one server, a bartender and a bus boy for the whole place- they were trying their best but really need more staffing. Would eat here again, just maybe not at a peak time“

“Bulk ordering ‘His,’ ‘Hers,’ and ‘Our’ favorite cookies worked our exactly how we wanted it to. We packaged them up with baggies from Oriental Trading Company, labels from Amazon, and custom stickers from Etsy. Everyone loved the to-go cookies!“

“Chuck has not lost its touch still delicious. Still good crowd was watching the football game. In the atmosphere was breathtaking. It was that's pretty cool. They also have golden tee. The new version, I tell ya. I was there immediately good times and fun. Please stop by. I had a Gyro and it was a little salty. But after a few beers you can't tell.“

“We always enjoy going to the Turf Smokehouse. The food is always good, the staff is friendly and knowledgeable. Peter makes the best mocktails for me and is always fun. We enjoyed having Vee as our server at our most recent visit. And of course, the view is beautiful.“

“New owner took it over in 2021 so dont have to worry about those orher comments with previous owner. I think its funny...some of the comments with food.... they NEVER even had on the menu! Also going through changes yes i seen there was a period of going through new barteders . Great and friendly service. Love going Wednesday for bingo, wings, and dinks! So friendly and welcoming. GOOD FOOD!“

“Luis’s is such a gem in Lake Geneva! We order carryout several times a month and our favorite items are the burritos and tacos- all of the meat options are delicious (barbacoa is a favorite) and the portions are generous with rice, beans and excellent tortilla chips as sides. The menu is large with many options and the remodeled restaurant is fantastic! Consistent quality and reasonable prices. Only suggestion is to be open more weekdays for dinner during your winter hours- we’d be there even more!!“

“We were seated upstairs where it is much quieter than the main floor. The service and food were excellent, as always. I especially enjoyed the beet salad. This is our favorite place to bring new friends for a great meal. We're never disappointed!“

“My Ribeye was cooked to perfection. My husband ordered the Friday Fish Fry, and had half fried half baked Cod and loved it. The potato pancakes were great as well. Our service was great!! Emily was our server, and Mackenna was our bus person. The GM came over to our table, and welcomed us, and made sure everything was to our liking. The new Village is stunning, and the most beautiful restaurant around here. The Village is exactly what we needed on Lake Delavan. Thank you Thank you Thank you!!“

“Last minute New year's Eve we went to this bar. It's got two pool tables, 2-3 dart boards. Very spacious and the bartender was amazing. There's also a quarter machine and a pinball machine. It was a very good time. I definitely recommend going here if you want to have a good time with good people.“

“Nice small town restaurant. Free street parking. I had the Western Burger with tater tots and it was a very good tasting burger. The menu was not extensive which is good when you have ADD but there wasn't a lot to crave either. The waitress was very attentive and overall customer service was very good. I didn't try the fish but it was a thumbs up for my partner.“

“This place was so good. The price point is great for the area too. I got the Mediterranean omelette and the gyro omelette. I substituted toast for pancakes which was the best decision I’ve made all day. The pancake has a crispy edge on one side and soft fluffy pancake throughout. I haven’t had a pancake this good in so long! The omelette were also 10/10“

“Pretty good, authentic Mexican food. Lots of variety, tacos, combos, quesadillas, burritos, etc. a few appetizers , yummy cheese dip. The staff is super nice! Will come back again. Oh and the prices are reasonable, two could eat for about $30. The decor is your typical Mexican restaurant feel, nice solid booths and chairs, ornately hand carved and upholstered.“

“Great restaurant and staff. Wife said their HOMEMADE hamburgers made her order standout. I noticed the Blueberry glazed crepes. I ordered that and told them that I normally have the glazed strawberries. She said they have them also. So I changed my order to strawberries. Later she said that she wants to combine the blueberry and strawberry over the holidays (Memorial and the 4th) for a red white and blue item. The white was the white sauce that they normally inject into their crepes. Not to many restaurants inject the cream sauce anymore. She later came with some blueberries for me to add and try. Must say that that was the best crepes I ever had. Told her to name them - Patriotic Crepes. If you're ever in Lake Geneva, stop in this quaint restaurant that makes you feel at home“

“I love how the place looks on the inside. I have always enjoyed my food but when my brother and I went his 2 orders of wings were undercooked. Pink on the inside. He's too nice to say anything though and he just ate them anyway. Isabella was our waitres she's very informative, attentive and fun to talk to!“

“Good food as Always.Asked for a side of cheese curds with meal.Did not receive them. They were on the receipt. Staff was happy to help resolve the problem. My burger was to be ketchup only. As stated on receipt. Had everything on it. Staff once again was apologetic and fixed the issue immediately. Very clean and well kept restaurant. I will be happy to support again. Thanks“