17 Best Italian Restaurants near Williams Bay

“Tremendous food and great service! We always have a fantastic time!!“

“These are seriously some of the greatest people I have ever met! And their products are always the best 100%“

“This is our go to place, exept on Sunday and Monday (when they are closed) They have awesome pasta ( especially the pink sauce) pizza, beefs, desserts and great mixed drinks.n we dine as a family of thre and have held large parties here! Great place to eat and relax“

“I drive from Palatine, il, stop in marengo, il, to pick up my bff and head up to Sweet Aroma. Food is beyond excellence. We are never disappointed.“

“Out of town work trip had us looking for some pizza while we were in the Elkhorn area. When I say it was the BEST pizza experience of my life, I say it with confidence. Great people, great food, great service, and they try to source as much of their ingredients locally, in the same county, so great for the community up here as well. Wisconsin wins “best pizza in the world” right in Elkhorn.“

“Amazing food and amazing customer service! Taco pizza and the Cheeseburgers are our favorites! Can’t wait to try more from their menu ❤️“

“My husband and I celebrated our anniversary here and thoroughly enjoyed everything about our visit! The food and service were both excellent! Loved the Gluten Free options! We will definitely be back!“

“The latest abd greatest is their sausage rolls. I’ve never had anything so good.“

“My husband and I have been to Luke's twice. We ate thier grilled italian sausage sandwhich, gyro and grilled chicken sandwich. Awesome! Love charbroiled food. Less fat. The whole crew was SUPER friendly and double checked our order at the window to make sure they got it right. Apollo sends a BIG thanks for the cookies, great appetizers!! ❤️Kid-friendliness: Kids are welcome. Kids meal as well.“

“Food was delightful. The branzino was excellently cooked and flavored, with a nice crispy texture. The tiramisu dessert was delicious. The appropriate rating for this restaurant should be above 5 stars. My daughter said it was the best restaurant she’s ever eaten at. Even the pizza off the kids menu was brick fired and had perfect marinara. Also pleasantly surprised by the quality of the decaf Americano - a delicious Colombian blend. Comfortably situated in the Grand Geneva Resort. Heavenly experience.“

“Great service and great food❣️“

“Luis’s is such a gem in Lake Geneva! We order carryout several times a month and our favorite items are the burritos and tacos- all of the meat options are delicious (barbacoa is a favorite) and the portions are generous with rice, beans and excellent tortilla chips as sides. The menu is large with many options and the remodeled restaurant is fantastic! Consistent quality and reasonable prices. Only suggestion is to be open more weekdays for dinner during your winter hours- we’d be there even more!!“

“Very much enjoyed our anniversary at The Getaway! Sat out on their beautiful deck. The calamari was superb, my husband loved his chicken Marsala and I really enjoyed the shrimp Diablo. Our waitress Denise was a pro and added to the great experience. We will be back!“

“What a fabulous dinner and server! We experienced a beautiful view, delicious food and wine, and a very knowledgeable and personable server .. Sabrina. Highly recommend Crafted Italia. A wonderful menu with a variety of small plates and dinners. The atmosphere is elegant and the view of Lake Como .. Breathtaking ❤️“

“Everyone knows Gino's pizza is killer. The Italian roast beef was way good. The Lake Geneva location had a great view of the lake. We were staying in the joining hotel so it was also it was very convenient. A 10% discount for hotel stay was a bonus.The service, however, was terrible. My friend waited 20min to get silverware, I had walk up to the bar for another beer, gave up on wanting ketchup...“

“Very good pizza and super reasonable can’t wait to try something else.“

“great place! would visit again!“