22 Best Pizza Restaurants near Wind Lake

“We stop there sometime when in the area. Jan is a nice person. Everyone there is nice and it is a very friendly place. Food is great. We will go there often. No complaints from us. See ya soon Jan“

“Great service to accommodate the amazing food we had. Owners/management on site and very friendly. They were checking in with all the tables and very accommodating to the patrons. Looking forward to trying more of the menu! Mushroom Swiss was the best I have had in quite sometime! Kid friendly dining room with a lounge/bar up front.“

“We ordered for the first time yesterday at Brothers Gyro & Pizza. The Pizza was the best pizza we had ever eaten. Best crust, best sauce, plenty of cheese and toppings. Perfect! Brother's will be a go to for us for pizza and I can't wait to try the gyro. ❤️“

“Service: always greeted quickly and seated when I visit for weekday lunch. Great service throughout. Food: their Nashville Hot Chicken is quite good and a typical go to. I've also tried specials, burgers and salads, all delicious. Ambiance: casual and bit of a sports bar feel with multiple TVs to watch games.“

“Great food, as always. Thanks.“

“Awesome pizza. It might be a disadvantage that they are only 3 miles down the road. Pizza is great and service is always exceptional! Specials are great any day of the week!“

“I had the Corn-beef Hash Soup. It blew up my mind. It was so so good! Plenty of potatoes, carrots and corn beef chunks. Yum!! I'll go back for more! Our thin crust Wisconsin style pepperoni pizza was delish as well. Mr. Spanky's, the owner, approached to us to say hi and to check if everything was ok. He told us that they will be opening their new location in May. It will serve them well because it's a popular local place. I hope they keep Corn-Beef Hash in their menu. The bar area was busy. Payne was very attentive to the crowd. Spanky's had great live music - Andy Carrols very good duo. Plenty to do in this neighborhood Bar and Grill. See you soon.“

“Yes!!!!! A pizza buffet and I am here for it! Amazing selections. Great quality! Awesome service! What you may not be aware of, you can tell them at the counter what type of crazy pizza you want made. They give you a buzzer and call you up when it's ready. They give you first dios and then add it to the array or other pizzas on the buffet. Dessert pizza! Salad, pasta, chicken....breadsticks...soup! I mean c'mon! This place is the cat's meow of buffets! All super fresh and hot! Service has always been top notch. Clean! Inviting and filling!“

“Armelis is goood bro but a few months ago my visit was okay they said our table would be ready in one minute but it took five minutes and when my brother got his pizza he Noticed that they put onions on it but they made him a pizza without onions jeez why do places always do it to me?“

“I made it a point to stop at this pub since they had briskette. The beer is excellent and fresh. The atmosphere is interesting. It's a little local but really interesting and the menu is very varied. For my part I tried the briskette, it was on the mark. In short, a place to visit.“

“We reserved the space for a surprise party for my dads 70th birthday. Everything was amazing, the food, the staff and help they gave, etc. It set up exactly as we wanted, Katie was amazing and so on top of things all day, and Elisia was a great help and very sweet too. The guests were really impressed as well! We will definitely be back to visit! I’ve also had their fish fry which was very good. We had ribs, pizza, rumaki, Reuben rolls, mini sliders, stuffed mushrooms, salad, fruit and veggie trays, and mozzarella sticks for the party, every bit of food was delicious and it was more reasonable to have the party here than anywhere else with similar quality in the area.“

“Have been coming to Organ Piper since it opened in the 70's. Great food, friendly staff, wonderful service, fabulous entertainment for the price of a pizza. You can't go wrong here.“

“This is THE BEST Golden Chicken in Wisconsin. I faithfully visit here with my punch card to get chicken, pizza, ribs, etc.The customer service is exceptional! The gentleman at the counter (I assume the owner) is a wonderful person. He goes above and beyond with everything from greeting me upon entrance to walking my food out to my car when it’s done!The food… easy 12/10. The chicken is always CRISPY and juicy. Never overcooked. The coleslaw is notoriously nasty at other locations, but not this one! My mom said it’s the best she’s had in all her years of going to a Golden Chicken. The sides, pizza, fish, and other foods items are so fun to try and order.A huge thank you to this location. I hope the word gets out and your business starts booming!See you soon!Ronda“

“Had called several days in advance for a full pan of lasagna and 4 pizzas for a family Christmas party. Pickup was at 11:30 on a Sunday. The food was ready as promised. The lasagna was fantastic! Everyone raved about the lasagna and the pizza. Outstanding service and I highly recommend the lasagna if you get a chance. Thank you!“

“An absolute hidden gem. We love the consistency of amazing food, great service and cozy atmosphere. Just can’t say enough… we love this place!“

“Our server, Clinton, was incredible. Very friendly, attentive to our every need, and great communication skills letting us know where he was placing items, and when our courses would be delivered. The steaks were done to perfection, the asparagus was not mushy and overdone, the French onion soup was perfectly seasoned, not overly salty. The salad was cold, crisp, and a nice size serving in a cold bowl. The prices were more than fare and we were not rushed out. The atmosphere was not overly crowded. We highly recommend this local, family run establishment.“

“always such good food and they’re super friendly. shoutout juan for your service tonight, it was amazing!“

“My husband was told about this place from his boss. We decided to give it a try. We are so glad we did. The food was amazing. Went on a Friday and it was packed but got a table right away. The only negative thing I have is, the clam chowder soup could use smaller potatoes and more clams. Other than that the soup is a 5 out of 5 for flavor. The shrimp dinner I got had HUGE breaded shrimp. My husband got the breaded cod, very good. And let's talk about the coleslaw. I haven't had a decent slaw in yrs and this is sooooo good, if you like it creamy. We highly recommend this place. And we will definitely go back.....“

“Had Crossroads fairly often as a kid, but moved closer to downtown. Was skiing at the nearby snowpark and decided to try it again. Crossroads just does pizza differently than any of the myriad pizza places on the east/south sides, and that's a good thing.“

“We hadn't had the Milwaukee tradition of ham and rolls on Sunday in quite a while and remembered hearing about this spot. It was so good! The rolls were delicious and they have different kinds (seeded, so forth) I got plain but they were so good and so was the warm ham. Our new spot to order from.“

“We ordered 5 pizzas for a pizza party, each different due to people's dietary needs, all were delicious and very much appreciatedVegetarian options: Great pizza but red peppers would have been niceDietary restrictions: Gluten free crust was good, together with toppings was great“

“I'm an idiot and ordered online to their Libertyville location.The Burlington location made the order and gave us free drinks while we waited.They refunded my card fir the Libertyville order and were absolutely top notch when it came to handling my stupid mistake.I'll be back as long as they're here.“