22 Best Pizza Restaurants in Huntington

“Backyard was recommended to me to try out. 100% worth your trip. I started off with a small order of the Mahi Mahi. I may say without any hesitation, some of the absolute BEST I have ever had. Served on a stone plate with a side of soy sauce and ginger. Then I got the small Memphis pizza. Came out perfectly sliced. It had the wood burning stove markings on the crust. Very flavorful. 10/10 definitely recommend! I definitely will be back!“

“the Staff was was excellent!! all around good service clean restaurant.. we had 30 kids an the staff accommodate all our needs an we're super Nice to the kids.. Mrs. Lisa an Logan You Run a Very Good Establishment..Thank you we will be back“

“We have always had great service & love the pubwich, baked spaghetti & two for Tuesday can’t be beat! We got to large pizzas today on the Tuesday deal & it was the best pizza that we’ve ever had from here. Exceptional & quick service!“

“Bombshells is always a great experience! Very pleased with all of the details: the service, food is delicious, huge portions (always have food leftover to take home). They have a new arcade room in the back. Kept the kids busy during our short wait for our food and then we all played a little after we ate. We love Bombshells!“

“Tried the gluten free option pizza and it was yummy. Excellent service, clean and delicious pizza and salads. We will be back!“

“Be sure to try the new IPA on tap, Williamsburg Colony! Great food and service.“

“Amazing people and amazing food.“

“Their customer service makes their pizza taste even better! Which I didn’t think was possible because it’s already my favorite ❤️ I highly recommend eating here any time you have a craving for excellence 😁“

“The times I have gone they've been on their game. The food was very good, on or before the time they told me, and each time the employees were polite and friendly. To be a lil hole in the wall pizza spot, in the middle of Rt. 2, I'll say EPIC!

Parking: Few spots in front and also a huge parking lot off the side which is beneficial when you're about to pull in after floating down Rt.2

Kid-friendliness: They have a lil coin machine thing you can play while you wait and also a lil convenience store attached to it.

Wheelchair accessibility: Level ground so it is accessible“

“We had an excellent experience this evening. The staff was friendly and the food was sooooo good.“

“Best pizza in Huntington! A tradition that continues to be a favorite over all these years. The nicest staff and amazing quality in the pizza. You can tell they care about what they do in every pizza you get! A must if you are in the area or live close by!“

“This was my first visit to this store. The staff were very friendly and clean. The food was delicious and fresh. Very happy bellies!!!-“

“Food and service are excellent. They are very clean.“

“Me and my kids loved there food also they gave us plates and napkins with the order so that was very cute clean up was fast and easy with them over all we gave this place 100 stars in my book

Kid-friendliness: When I went to the door to get my order the lady said hi to my daughter and talk to her a little before she left with that was cool“

“I ordered an order that took my money wasnt even in any system close to here, I called its 6/16/25 10pm . I just wanna say the lady who answered the phone super sweet very helpful manager on shift had me come to store to investigate, ended up taking care of me even though they couldnt find the order, listen I havent have customer service that good in sons long I cannot remember. They didn't have to help me they could've done like the other stores i called trying to find the order one even told me to search an for an area code and I would find my order. This lady at thos Huntington papa johns on 5th ave she is golden.thank you so much.“

“Always has been one of my favorite if not my favorite Giovanni's. They're pizza is always made with rich flavor and never lacking ingredients. You can always count on a wonderfully hot not too greasy but greasy topping pizza to enjoy. I recommend this place and I recommend that they change nothing about their process. Been that way for the last 10 years or more.“

“I don't often leave reviews, but I feel led to tell you what a great manager you have. She has curly hair and is really young, and I was super excited to see her in a managerial role. She's always in a good mood and consistently working hard. My buddies and I get lunch from your place almost every day, and we can tell when she's on duty because our order is always right when she's there. Keep up the great work!"“

“Best salads in town. Bacon cheesy tots were incredible! DP Dough never lets me down!“

“I LOVE MY LOCAL DOMINO'S!!! I can always trust My food is 100% accurate and if it's not they will make it again, without you even knowing. Absolutely fantastic customer service can't say enough wonderful things about this location“

“Omg this pizza was amazing!! cheesy garlic bread was the best!! I walked in ordered the pepperoni cheese stuffed crust pizza I was in and out probably within 8 minutes.. they were so fast and fresh.. they were waiting on me to get out my credit card and pay!! When she asked me for sauces I asked for marinara and garlic butter but she did forget garlic butter but I don't care because of pizza & cheesy bread so good hot and fresh.. absolutely yummy!!“

“We order here a lot! There is times we are really happy with our orders and other times we are not satisfied. It mainly depends on who is working. If a guy named Ryan is working he generally makes sure our order is correct and exactly as ordered!“

“So let me tell you right now about Ginos on Norway Linda the young lady working tonight was so kind and helpful. She made sure that me and my lady had to buy one get one free she got our bread correct because my lady likes garlic bread and I like butter bread. She also made sure that I got my lasagna and my lady has to have her baked spaghetti. She was absolutely amazingand the other people that were in the staff were also great people. They were so kind and awesome. And the other people that were in the staff were also great people. They were so kind and awesome I give this place 1000 stars not five stars not 10 stars 1000 stars you guys rock you are awesome. Words me and the better half just got our bellies full and we’re about to snuggle up on the couch and watch a movie and fall asleep. Make sure you give Linda raise and take care of everybody else in there because they all deserve it. Love, James“